[6.0] "The wrestling was solid, but bad storylines held it back. Shawn Michaels vs Jericho was enjoyable despite the DQ finish, and the Evolution six man tag was fun. Kane's storyline was bizarre, and Stacy Keibler's push is odd."

[5.0] "The wrestling is mostly solid here, but the bad storylines are still dragging this show down badly. Shawn Michaels vs Chris Jericho might not be one of the best matches they had because it ends in a DQ finish but I still enjoyed the match. The main event is your typically good Evolution six man tag match and it's another one worth checking out. There's some obvious filler matches though and Stacy Kiebler's push in the Women's division is baffling. Diva Search is mercifully over with Christy winning the contract and Vince McMahon announces the new Taboo Tuesday PPV concept where the first match made is Eugene vs Bischoff... oh joy! The Kane angle is just a really bizarre focus of the show. There was moments in there that I found unintentionally funny like Kane's overacting and Snitsky's promo, but oh man is this a bad storyline. They somehow turn Kane into a sympathetic babyface because of this.... how the hell does that work?"

[5.0] "A middling episode. Most matches are forgettable except the very fun main event, HBK/Jericho was not one of their best outings. Some extremely silly stuff on this show, the Kane/Lita miscarriage angle is so bad that it loops around to be funny. The Diva search is finally over."

[4.0] "There were two really good matches and the opening promo was good, but the rest of the show did not click. Stacy getting a women's title push? Tajiri/Hurricane and Maven/Grenier filler matches? Plus the Diva Search."