[7.0] "This was a solid show because of the wrestling, as Angle/Haas, Cena/RVD, and the Dudleys match were all really good, with the latter cementing Spike's heel turn, but Orlando/Rene was bad and pointless and the final segment was also bad, featuring a midget Undertaker and Orlando Jordan heel turn as JBL's Virgil despite wrestling as a face in a filler match early in the show. Ugh."

[6.0] "For the most part I thought this was a fine Smackdown with a good Kurt Angle return match against Charlie Haas, a solid John Cena match against RVD and a fine Dudleys match with a good swerve at the end with nothing really blowaway, but some fine set up with Summerslam coming up. The JBL/Mini Taker segment is crap though and WWE goes to the well with this nonsense so many times even though it's just not funny. Orlando Jordan aligning with JBL is a bit of a wet fart as well. Eddie Guerrero with the ladies wasn't a good fit either as Vickie had already appeared on Smackdown before so it was well known he was a married family man at that point. It's not an awful segment, but not exactly his A material either."

[4.0] "This was a fine show, nothing really stands out but nothing is terribly bad either outside of the last segment. Cena/RVD was probably my favorite match on the whole show, and Angle/Haas went on too long considering where both guys are positioned on the card it probably should've been a 6-8 minute match. The Dudley's angle was cool, but the last segment was just stupid WWE comedy."

[5.0] "Bit of a flat episode, none of the matches stood out too much, probably the Dudleys tag and angle was my favorite bit of the show. Eddie and JBL are almost always there to save us but both got weak material to work with, Eddie vamping with the divas and JBL making fun of Undertaker with a little person."