[5.0] "A passable show. The first few matches just feel like basic RAW/Smackdown matches. The ladder match is great even with the late switch to Tajiri instead of Chavo. Didn't expect the finish either! Battle Royal for the IC championship (thank god it's back) had a lot of twists and turns. Kane chokeslamming RVD and Christian throwing Jericho out. Not sure about the finish though. Booker Ts continued slip down the card is quite the sight. The whole battle royal basically consists of wrestlers Triple H buried in his current reign of terror. Val Venus is back... at least it's better than Chief Morley, I think. We all knew Nash vs HHH was going to stink. The bikini thing goes on way too long and the woman in the fatal 4 way try with their limited time. Trish takes a crazy fall out of the ring. Lesnar v Show really picks up at the end and the crowd really get into it."

[2.0] "The main event is the only match worth watching from this show with the ladder match being an honorable mention. Apart from that, avoid this show. The crowd was quiet for nearly all the show except for the main event, the bikini contest and Piper vs Mr America."

[2.0] "An absolute dogshit PPV with a fantastic main event and a very good ladder match. It felt like so much of this show was filler to get a full card, which is kind of ridiculous since the brands weren't even splitting PPVs yet. It's hard to believe this is the very best card they could come up with. Another awful Triple H match with a DQ finish, a very strange battle royal and a horrible Roddy Piper match were probably the biggest lowlights for me. Oh and that La Resistance vs Test/Steiner match that would've even been skippable as a midcard match on Raw. But Brock/Big Show at least left a good taste in my mouth at the end."

[2.0] "This show sucked. The only saving grace was the main event and Austin's segments with Bischoff, but everything else was meh or just bad. The opener wasn't horrible, but it was quickly forgettable, La Resistance looked promising but their timing near the final minutes was awful, Tag Team Ladder Match was a stupid spotfest and a waste of four great talents and the IC Battle Royal didn't even feel like Battle Royal with all the eliminations taking place so early on, plus the finish was dumb. Then the goddamn Bikini Contest happened which took sooo long, Hogan vs Piper only showed that I don't want to see Roddy wrestle in this shape, Nash vs Triple H was the worst bout of the show with the unbearable, another DQ finish in this HHH title reign and women's Fatal 4 Way was another sloppy and rushed contest in this division. And then the main event fortunately was something decent with a forklift spot that was clever and fun. Big Show looked gassed, but Lesnar carried him to a nice match and the stipulation also helped with that. But overall one of the worst shows I've seen lately with not much standing out and a lot of stuff being simply offensive."

[5.0] "This event was better than Backlash the month before it, but I wouldn't call it a standout card either. It was good enough to get the job done, but this was largely on the back of the two big gimmick matches of the night, which both proved very entertaining. The opening six man tag was a strange encounter that felt so absolutely thrown together, and Hogan (sorry, Mr. America), vs. Piper was honestly just sad. Two watch maybe the two biggest draws of '85-'86 be reduced to this was horrible. You'll find worse than this show, but it's also not one I'd go out of my way to recommend to anyone, either."

[5.0] "Not the greatest PPVs to be honest but the stretcher match is one of the more enjoyable Brock Lesnar vs Big Show matches which had a fair few tough bumps as well as an enjoyable finish. Eddie Guerrero and Tajiri had a great first match together when they defeated Team Angle in an underrated ladder match. Christian has a great heel moment when he cheated to win the Intercontinental Title. Austin and Bischoff had some fun comedy moments throughout the whole show and Sable and Torrie show off a lot of skin in their bikini contest. The rest of the card isn't very good though with Mr. America vs Roddy Piper being Hogans worst match since his return. Nash vs Triple H had a poor match that inexplicably ended in a stupid DQ finsh. Its a very imbalanced show overall."

[7.0] "This show is pretty underrated, there's nothing that bad on the show and despite the very average world heavyweight title match it doesn't mess up the flow of the show and the main event is awesome with the stipulation being perfect for Brock and Big Show"

[4.0] "There are two great matches on this show Brock vs Big Show and the tag team title ladder match, with everything else pretty much being below average at best. The 6 man tag and the women's match probably could've been better with a couple more minutes, but instead, we got two whatever matches. The battle royal was the 3rd best match on the card and that was **1/2 at best. A Hogan/Piper match in 2003 went as well as you would expect it to and Nash Triple H wasn't good at all either."

[5.0] "The tag team ladder match (****) was pretty great, and the main event Brock vs Big Show (****1/4) was downright awesome, the best match their rivalry ever produced. Aside from that, everything else about the show was forgettable. A very average show."

[3.0] "This is a bad show, a really bad show with three contenders for Worst match of the year. There are two matches that may have saved the show if not for those other three matches. BEST TO WORST: Brock vs Big Show [***3/4], Tajiri/Eddie vs WGTT [***3/4], The Battle Royal [**1/2], Six Man Tag [**], La Resistance vs. Steiner/Test [*3/4], Women? s Four Way [1/4*], HHH vs Nash [1/4*], Mr America vs Piper [DUD]."

[4.0] "About on par with Backlash, I feel. There's plenty of filler, like Backlash, and a few crap matches, like Backlash, two of them being DUDs. Only redeeming qualities here are the ladder match and main event stretcher match, both of which I'd give ***1/2. Ladder match is good but it's nothing I haven't seen before, even though it's still fun and Guerrero winning back the tag titles is a nice moment, and the main event is crazy levels of fun near the end. Women's match is also good but it's too short to mean anything. But, oh boy, a 12 minute battle royal is about as bog standard as it sounds and the finish is all over the place, Roddy Piper and Hogan wrestling in 2003 is just sad, and Nash's and HHH's World title match's finish is abysmal. Thank f**k they'd redeem themselves at Bad Blood. Also, Chris Benoit was featured in a 4 min opener. Sick way to use talent."