[7.0] "2! ? What is this rating? I get that 2019 wasn't a great year but some of the ratings are just way too low and frankly this is as strange as it gets. It's obviously not a huge PLE but it was a fun show with good matches with the womens tag match the most enjoyable"

[6.0] "Doesnt need a rewatch but theres nothing bad on this shows its just a bit of fun and the womens tag match is actually really good and makes me wish it was down on a PPV that more people watched as its right really enjoyable workers and may be as good as the womens tag division has got. The opening match is a generic slow heels vs fast babyface matches with Montez being beaten down for a fight while before they fight back and we get his awesome frog splash to give them the win and Owens Vs Lashley is fine"

[5.0] "No idea why this gets such a low score, its just a network special and not there to do much except have a few matches and further a few storylines. The womens tag match is really enjoyable and worth watching again and the other 2 matches shown are strong enough for this show to be a 6/10. I dont know why people expected there to be an actual epic last man standing match between Lashley and Rusev on a network show"

[6.0] "People are so hard for nothing. Okay, this show doesn't have the reputation of a great Starrcade show but that was not the goal and even if it's just a glorified house show, the show itself is not bad at all. KO Show with Ric was fun. Street Profits vs. The OC was not exciting but had nothing bad about it and put the Profits in the spotlight perfectly The Women's Four-Way was fantastic and was the showtealer. The main event wasn't great but I loved Owens' promo. Overall - people need to calm down, it was not show of the year worthy, but there's nothing THAT bad."

[2.0] "Obviously only rating the roughly 1/3 of the show to be broadcast. In terms of positives, the Street Profits vs. Gallows/Anderson was a solid tag bout, and the main event of Owens vs. Lashley was decent enough while it lasted, until Owens effectively disappeared so the lame Lashley-Rusev story could continue. Ultimately - like most of these Network specials - this was just a portion of a house show, and it's sad to see the Starrcade name relegated to something like this."

[2.0] "A lot of the matches that looked promising were never aired. The OC vs street profits match was ok. Same for the women's tag team titles match. The match most people were waiting for - Lashley vs Rusev never happened. Rusev beating up Lashley didn't compensate at all. Overall, judging from what was televised, this was a bad show."

[3.0] "Not sure what the point of this was. The dark matches look exceptional, but only the few in attendance would know. I didn't even know this was on and watched by chance. The three matches were reasonable. Profits vs OC was very messy. Gallows and Anderson are far too robotic a pairing to put on a good match with a green team. Dawkins is rubbish. The women's title match was very enjoyable. The Kabuki Warriors are an amazing team. The novelty of having Alexa back probably made the match seem better than it really was, but there was lots of action and some good flowing exchanges. Everyone got to have a good moment. Lashley and KO was fine and the beat down from Rusev got the crowd going. Only 3 matches and more of the brain dead Ric Flair prevent even an adequate rating. It would be nice if anybody in attendance could give a lowdown on the dark matches."

[0.0] "What can people say to defend this show? From the empty seats to the 2. 33-1 dark match to viewable match ratio. To having your main title defended on a show advertised but not shown. This is rightfully labelled a disaster. You'll catch me watching NJPW World tag league or weekly nxt and aew. How many more chances can we give wwe that they are constantly a disappointment and proven unending times they do not even consider what is best for the fans. Just what's "best for business" (Money)"