[4.0] "This is a skippable show. Wrestling was ok. I found myself falling asleep as I didn't care who attacked shawn michaels. The reveal at the end is weird. You have the video depixelating to show HHH's face and then shawn "i know it was you", lol yeah dude state the obvious lmaooo. i think that was a botched promo for both of them really because HHH sorta just sits there waiting for something to happen. It was weird. I still appreciate the feel/vibe of raw now that bischoff is back. it seems like he's always in the middle of something and pushing stories forward. This is the kind of thing that existed during peak attitude era and during the few months where the "outsiders" seemed real on nitro... whether the episode was good or not.in terms of the wrestling didn't really matter as long as stories were pushed through. So, for this episode i'd say the matches were basic and nothing special while the stories doing something/anything were nice to see. Also I was like wtf when the two big guys attacked lilian garcia. I totally do NOT remember this stuff with these two big guys from back in the day, at all, so this is still fresh to me."

[6.0] "The closing segment here is an all time great Raw moment with a show long angle finding out who HBK's attacker was. What made it so good for me was all the red herrings giving motives for several wrestlers. I just get goosebumps at the part where Triple H is revealed as the attacker and he just smiles. It's brilliant heel work and his promo afterwards is just chilling. HBK finally coming out of retirement for Summerslam instantly made it my most anticipated match on the card. "I know that I'm no longer the Showstopper! But I can still fight". I'm still finding the wrestling side of the show lacking compared to Smackdown, but storylines like this gave the show a must watch kind of quality which does remind me a lot of peak Nitro. Have to say I hated that 3 Minute Warning attacking Lillian Garcia segment though. That just comes off as shocking for the sake of it! Also it was disappointing to see Victoria's in ring debut against Trish Stratus rendered unwatchable because of Jerry Lawler's creepy questions at Molly Holly throughout the match!"

[4.0] "This was the show where HHH was revealed as HBK's attacker. Outside of the final segment and three good matches in the Booker/Goldust tag and the last two matches this show was very lacking."

[5.0] "Ok episode of Raw. The opening segment between Triple H and Jericho was fine but it doesn't lead to anything between the two during the show. The whole show is built around who ran Shawn Michaels head into the car window with Triple H questioning people as well. The main event was the best match but that was still only fine. The finally segment between Triple H and Shawn Michaels was really good even if the rest of the show wasn't that good."