[6.0] "There's a few good promos here, especially the entertaining E&C segments throughout the show and the awesome Rock/Jericho promo and Undertaker returned and gives Regal a last ride for some reason, but it was just an okay show as the match card looked great but the quality of them never really went above average. Austin/Rikishi in the cage was fine, but its a lesser version of their Street Fight at No Mercy, Rock v Jericho was good but not at its full potential and Angle v Triple H was a disappointing one-sided beatdown! The mystery with Rikishi's accomplice continues when Rikishi says The Rock was the real mastermind after he turned on him after the main event to leave the show on a cliffhanger. I kinda thought it was unlikely because the mystery attacker who got Austin on SmackDown would have had to have still been in an alliance with Rikishi with the way it was set up."

[5.0] "An average episode where the promos were better than the matches. Undertaker comes back but still just average."

[5.0] "The E&C promos and Rock/Jericho promo were great, but other than that, the show was predictable and kind of boring. It was definitely a few steps down from last week's show. I didn't really get the Stone Cold/Rikishi cage match - pretty much the same result as the PPV. And now Rikishi is going to feud with the Rock? Ugh.Trips was fantastic throughout the show though."

[6.0] "This was a solid show with the return of Undertaker, Triple H just brutalizing Angle in their match, Rock and Jericho had a highly entertaining backstage segment and a solid match to follow. Rikishi left the show with a huge plot twist making you want to watch Smackdown"

[4.0] "I'm not sure what happened here. They are falling back into a lot of their bad habits and things are already starting to get stagnant again. This is by far the worst show they've done since Austin's comeback."

[5.0] "Return of Undertaker, some funny segments with Edge's birthday, strong microphone battle between The Rock and Jericho but all matches had poor interest, even steel cage match."