[6.0] "This was a very promising card, that ended in a badly booked, just okay event. Mayu vs Klein is decent. Tenille vs Sakai is actually pretty good (best match I seen with Sakai), but for whatever baffling reason Roh decided to just randomly destroy the one time the women division had momentum and let Tenille lose on the the pre-show. The Klein vs Sakai is then not a good Woh title finale. The highly anticipated Bullect Club matches aren't bad, but not not as good as hoped and way longer then they should be (seems that results in good ratings, but for me these matches were not good enough to be that long). Nothing outstanding or terrible on the event, I would say Ibushi vs Page was the best match of the evening."

[7.0] "A solid event. The double main event, Castle vs Scurll and Cody vs Omega, both delivered, and the latter served to further build the Bullet Club power struggle story well. The undercard notably featured a very enjoyable match from Ibushi and Page, and a fun spotfest in the six-man ladder match. Bully Ray's heel turn was also handled effectively, even if it doesn't seem the most necessary thing in the world. A few parts were underwhelming, like the Women's Title tournament final, and though both Taylor vs Gresham and Martinez vs Ishii were decent enough, each featured a rather scary landing from dives by Gresham and Martinez. Overall a solid watch."

[7.0] "This event could have been the event of year, but it is only a pretty event, the event is also too long and in some parts it seems boring. The opener is an enjoyable match (***1/4), Ishii vs Martinez (***), Page vs Kota is a good match (****), but he had to be longer, the final of WOH is so bad (**1/2), tha ladder match is good, but I have expected more: the match is to confuse (****), boring matches until the main event (Tana-Lethal vs Briscoes ***, Triple Threat 3 Way **1/2), the last man standing is the only passable match (***1/4). Cody vs Omega is pretty according to the booking, but it could have been better. The main event is good and fun (****)"

[6.0] "It is impossible without mentioning this show when talking about the disappointment. This show didn't need to be that long ( over 5 hours ) to be great. The first half was really good. Martinez/Ishii was very good, physical. Martinez really impressed me more and more. Ibushi/Page was my MOTN. Great action no dull moments and hot crowd. I believe page will get better and better. The ladder match was very good, too but not as good as the nxt one. Then the second half happened and the show went downhill. Tag title match was pretty good but didn't need 19 minutes. LMS match was okay, the overbooking didn't help much but the SSP through the table was very nice. Bully ray segment was dumb. Cody/omega was good but went too long and dragged at times. It never felt to reach the next gear. ME shouldn't go last and this again went too long. I'd call this pretty good but not spectacular. I liked the fingers broken though which was pretty entertaining. Overall, I'd not call anything on this show bad but this felt very underwhelming when looking the card on paper. Cut off the time of the last 2 matches and tag title match and the show could have been better."

[6.0] "Expectations were higher then results in my opinion. This ppv was so hyped that at the end of it I felt a little bit disappointed.. Not only because of the quality in the ring, but also for the results to be honest.. I though it was time for Kenny to beat the hell out of Cody and for Marty to win that ROH title... But maybe I'm just being a dreamer.. Anyway the ladder match was the best of the night, Young Bucks killed it once again."

[7.0] "Chuckie/Gresham was a fun opener; Gresham rules (***), Martinez/Ishii was so boring - Martinez's work in it was soooo dull (*), Hangman/Ibushi was also very boring; Hangman's work on top was super dull & Ibushi's selling wasn't anything to write home about - I did like the strike exchange they had in the late stages of the match (*1/4), Klein/Sakai was actually pretty solid; Sakai rocked the underdog role well & Klein did some solid work on top - an OK match (**), SoCal Uncensored vs. Flip & The Bucks was just bleh - felt very choreographed, especially everything Flip did - maybe the worst ladder match The Bucks have ever been involved in (*), Briscoes/Tana & Lethal was very enjoyable - good storytelling & performances by all 4 men (***1/4), Silas/Kenny surprised the crap out of me - they put on one helluva LMS match! Very physical w/ well defined heel-babyface roles (***3/4), Cody/Omega was also really good - I thought it was a total Cody show; great performance by the man (***3/4), Scurll/Castle was a damn good main event, too - other than some of the usual Marty shtick, I enjoyed it very much (***3/4). Overall Supercard of Honor was a good show. Started off good w/ Chuckie vs. Gresham, then fell off quite a bit w/ 4 very forgettable matches in a row, but then it picked up again once The Briscoes vs. Tana & Lethal happened."

[6.0] "Chucky/Gresham: ***1/4. Greshamis excellent. Ishii/Martinez: ***1/3. Really felt like a big deal for Martinez. Tag Titles: ***2/3. Very good, didn't have a ton of heat. World title match: ****. By the end a great match. That's all i cared to see."

[5.0] "I missed portions of this card because I was watching NXT at the same time, and I was tired/bummed out after Cody/Omega so I skipped the final match. /// Punishment Martinez vs. Tomohiro Ishii [***1/2] // Hangman Page vs. Kota Ibushi [****] // Kelly Klein vs. Sumie Sakai - It was so mind-boggling that these were the finalists. Iwatani and Dashwood (especially Dashwood) were the most over women in the tournament, so I thought it'd be common sense to make them the finalists. Instead it was two wrestlers nobody really cares about, the match sucked from what I saw, and had a laughably awful botch finish with a simple DDT. And good idea putting your new women's title on a 46 year old. // SoCal Uncensored (c) vs. Flip Gordon & The Young Bucks - This match was really good until the three guys who weren't in the match came in. I honestly don't even know their names because I don't follow ROH regularly and I don't care. After that, the match wound up being overbooked and way too long. [***] // Kenny King (c) vs. Silas Young - Not bad, but had a silly WWE-style finish. [***1/2] // Cody vs. Kenny Omega - I'll have a lot more to say about this match later, but I was disappointed by it and it barely moved the BC storyline further. Guess we'll just have to drag it out until All In? [***] /// Overall: **1/2. If this show was supposed to be the biggest in ROH history, then they probably should have been very careful about booking it. Parts of the show were so ridiculous that I'd have sworn Russo was behind some of it. Bully Ray's rant sucked, and I hate those shoot-style promos. Lastly, the show went way, way too long. I don't follow ROH regularly, and this event convinced me that it's probably not a good idea to start doing so."