[8.0] "Another real good show in this big wrestling weekend . Some of the matches had the feel of squashes , albeit very good squashes . Matches worth watching : Drew Galloway & Johnny Gargano (c) vs. Catch Point (Drew Gulak & Tracy Williams) , Chris Hero vs. Fred Yehi , Anthony Nese (w/Andrea & SoCal Val) vs. Sami Callihan , TJP (w/Stokely Hathaway) vs. Tommy End , Matt Riddle vs. Zack Sabre Jr. , Marty Scurll vs. Timothy Thatcher and a real good angle to end the show . My top match was Ricochet vs. Will Ospreay which was great ."

[6.0] "Drew Galloway & Johnny Gargano (c) vs. Catch Point was an alright opener but was too long. **1/2. Chris Hero vs. Fred Yehi was good but not as good people have been saying it was. ***. Anthony Nese vs. Sami Callihan was ok. *3/4. Darby Allin vs. Ethan Page was an ok short match. *1/2. TJP vs. Tommy End was ok but not as good as it could of been. **1/2. Riddle vs Sabre was a good technical match. ***. Thatcher vs Scurll was good. ***. Ricochet vs Ospreay I thought was good, but nowhere near as good as their previous encounters. ***1/4. Overall was an alright show, but wasn’t the best EVOLVE show, which is understandable as I’m assuming the wrestlers were saving their energy for Mercury Rising."

[5.0] "Not the greatest EVOLVE show. Yehi/Hero was clearly MOTN and was a really good hard-hitting match up (***1/2), Sabre/Riddle was also very good but didn't quite live up to all the hype for me (***1/4), End/TJ was also a really good technical match that could have been a little better if End sold TJ's leg work more (***), the rest of the show did nothing for me including the ME which I really didn't like."

[8.0] "After the poor booking to the end of the matches at EVOLVE 58 I was a bit worried going into this show that it may be marred by similar poor decisions. This however was not the case and what we saw were clear results for the entire show. The action in the show was pretty good throughout topped with a worthy main event to end out the show and set up nicely for the Mercury Rising show later in the day."

[6.0] "A pretty good show. The opener was OK (**), and the post-match angle w/ Galloway turning heel was pretty cool. Hero/Yehi was really good, and the 2nd best match on the show (***1/2), Nese/Callihan was solid for the time it got (*3/4), Allen/Page was awful (*), TJP/End was pretty good, and it could've been even better had End actually sold TJP's leg work (**3/4), Riddle/ZSJ was wonderful & my favorite match on this show (****), Scurll/Thatcher was bad (*1/4), and the main event between Ricochet & Ospreay was absolutely awful (*). The show had 2 matches that I would say are worth watching (Hero/Yehi + Riddle/ZSJ) & End/TJP was pretty good too."