[3.0] "Not the best show I've ever seen. CM Punk's opening match was decent, but Styles and D'Lo was the match of the night. Everything else was borderline unwatchable thanks to Vince Russo's booking."

[4.0] "This was a tough show to rate. On one hand, it's terrible. On the other, it was easier to watch than the last few episodes. It opens with a chaotic trios match between CM Punk, Frankie Kazarian, and Matt Stryker and Damian Dothar, Johnny Swinger, and Kid Romeo that was one of the only good things on the show. Sonny Siaki and the Vampire Warrior continue the trend of all of the matches in the Hard 10 Tournament being terrible, but theirs was less terrible than the last few by virtue of its being shorter. After some racism, David Young and Traci beat Ron Killings in the Asylum Alliance Tournament. America's Most Wanted reform to beat BG James and Konnan in the other Asylum Alliance Tournament match, although the match is bad and more focused on the racists than anything happening in the match. AJ Styles and D-Lo Brown steal the show with their match of the night number one contenders match for the World Heavyweight Title. Finally, there's a match with minimal outside interference. Of course, its Glen Gilberti vs. Jeff Jarrett for the World Title, so it's not good."

[5.0] "What a show. In the one hand, the opener was a fast paced six man tag, to showcase the debuting Frankie Kazarian and Matt Stryker and CM Punk. It was fast paced and had some good action. The AJ Styles vs D-Lo Brown is trully a hidden gem of early TNA. It was great, those two knew each other, had chemistry and made some great spots. Totally worth watching it. Erik Watts, Kid Kash, Trinity and Goldylock's segment was great. On the other hand, the Hard Ten and the Anarchy Alliance anre two bad tournaments with lots of bad stuff. Killings vs Traci & David Young was awful. At least we know that AMW will continue existing, as Chris Harris and James Storm have reconciled. Finally, the main event. The match was mediocre at best, but the swerve ending with Russo betraying Gilberti was horrible and for me ruined all the build up and storyline. Gilberti might have his flaws as a talent, but at least SEX improved and we could have seen a conclusion to his feud with Jarrett here, but no, with that swerve the feud continues and now Russo is again the leader. I didn't like it. Now what? A Russo vs Jarrett match? It's probably going to be awful."

[1.0] "One point for the extremely good Styles/D'Lo Brown match, even though it only got 9 minutes. The rest of the show ranges from eh to horrible, with particular condemnation towards the Harris brothers bringing their racism blatantly onscreen, the absolute dumpster fire of not one but two horrible tournaments going on, and the epic dud of a main event ending with Russo himself executing an especially dumb Russo swerve."