[6.0] "With mainly the kind of matches that you'd generally find on a good episode of Impact, the main mark against it is that this really just didn't need to be a PPV. That said, one certainly can't fault the in-ring action, as virtually everyone worked as hard as they could to put on a good show. The three-way Tag Team Title match and the Beer Money vs. Bram/EY stood out, but nothing was really awful. It just didn't quite have the big-time feel of a legitimate PPV (especially with little build and without the World Title on the line), but also didn't have the fun, inconsequential feel of the regular One Night Only shows - it was instead caught in the middle."

[7.0] "Four Way X-Division Title: ***, Spud vs O'shea **1/4, Benett vs Robbie **3/4, KO's Gauntlet **3/4, Lee vs Parks ***1/4, Abyss vs Grado ***1/4, Tag Team Titles ***3/4, Lashley vs Tyrus *3/4, Beer Money vs EY/Bram *** A really fun show, with good matches and good Promos, but that Promo between the Pope and Grado was really annoying, but good show by TNA"

[7.0] "Solid One Night Only show with very good main event. Rest match was good (like World Tag Team 3 Way Match or opener for X-Division Title) or booring (like Tyrus/Lashey, KO's match). ONO Live is very good idea and I have hope for more event's like this."

[9.0] "I think the Good outways the dragging and plodding Knockouts match. Was it the best show ever it wasn't. But, for a Live 15 dollar show I was pretty well put together. I think what stood out was the Tag Matches. Also sleeper match of the night was Trevor Lee and Pepper Parks."

[4.0] "This show was a let down. I figured TNA would have done way more for a live pay per view. The X-Division Title match was a fun spot fest. Spud vs. O'Shea was bad and dragged on. Bennett vs. Robbie E was okay. The Knockout Gauntlet Battle Royal was really boring. Lee and Parks had a good little match. Grado did some bad comedy. The Monster's Ball Match felt like an XPW match with high production values. In other words not good. The World Tag Team Title match was really good. Lashley vs. Tyrus was okay. The main even was good. Parts of this show felt like it belonged on Impact or even Xplosion. This show is not really worth going out of your way to see."