[7.0] "This was a really fun show, and helped bring my itch back to watch old ROH shows. While there was some matches on this show that were only just decent, most of this show was a pretty easy watch. I'll be honest that the Prophecy gimmick was a very intriguing and bold gimmick to do with a company just starting out and finding their feet; especially with selective title matches; I've been finding it very interesting. The last three matches were a hell of a stretch to close out the show."
[6.0] "While a solid show overall, this was one of ROH's weaker efforts in 2002. It doesn't have anything that feels like a MOTYC like many of the other events have. It is a largely consistent show (despite a bit of a dip in the middle), though, with a lot of different styles represented on the show (granted with multiple people pulling double duty it did seem like they had some difficulty filling out the card). The opener is very good, and I really liked the last three matches. I also want to give a shout out to Matt Thompson - I couldn't review his match since he doesn't have a cagematch profile, but he is such an oddity in early ROH. He is tall, skinny kid that's about 6'8 so he's an absolute giant in ROH, and basically all his offence is random high flying. He is very green but he is so unusual that he actually really wins over the crowd. I would have been very curious to see him stick around. That aside, what hurts this card the most is that all the best matches have been done better elsewhere. It leaves this feeling fairly inessential. It's still an entertaining show despite this, however, and one that I believe ROH completionist should enjoy, even if I wouldn't recommend it to everybody."
[7.0] "This show has a problem and it's that the midcard is just a filler. The opener is great with Mark Briscoe joining the Prophecy, but the rest of the card until the last three matches is really bad. I mean, the 10 man scramble match is a disaster, lots of squashes, the ROH chapionship match is mediocre and the Boston Street Masacre is just horrible. The last three matches are great, specially the Main Event. So I recommend only watching the opener and the three last matches, the rest isn't good enough."
[4.0] "This show goes right back to the problems that plagued ROH's early shows. Too much filler and not enough meat. This show has a good main event but also puts their champion in a non-title match in the third match of the night. The scramble match is ridiculous and the tag team street fight is a big let-down. Even Styles/Daniels wasn't as great as expected."
[5.0] "Nach dem Event in Boston ist dies die erste Show, die auf rohwrestling. com in der Mediathek ist. Leider muss ich dieser Show nun gleich zwei Punkte weniger einräumen. Einzig das Scramble Match, sowie Dragon vs Williams haben mich wirklich überzeugt und AJ vs Daniels war etwas enttäuschend. 5 Punkte!"
[4.0] "First things first. The show-opening backstage promo with The Prophecy. Samoa Joe absolutely kills it. Daniels is ranting away, Joe is behind him just making faces, shaking his head, having none of it. It's great. Really sells him as purely there for the money. It's great. The 10 man scramble was an enjoyable spotfest. Joe's squash of the RCE was enjoyable for what it is. What's not great? Whoever decided to have the camera on the entrances with an extreme fisheye lens should get fired. Da Hit Squad vs Mamaluke & some kid who is about as green as you've ever seen, a match where Xavier was presumably meant to look strong but failed because nobody knows his opponent. Homicide vs Joe & Style vs Daniels were both matches that will be bettered in the future, & the main event was fine. But the highlight of the show was Joe making faces so that's not a good sign."
[6.0] "Sehr schwankende Leistungen bei dieser Show. Eine schöne Halle haben sie sich aber ausgesucht. Ein gutes Tag Team Match als Opener weiß mir zu gefallen. Mace vs. Laree ist dagegen natürlich schon relativ crappy aber auch kurz. Lopez kann mich wesentlich mehr begeistern als der ROH Champion. Xavier geht gar nicht. Noch schlechter ist nur noch Matt Thompson. Schlechtes Tag Team Match mit vielen Upfucks. Der Scramble hat natürlich auch ein paar Upfucks ist aber generell ganz unterhaltsam und chaotisch. Joe zerlegt mal eben den Express. Gesehen und vergessen. Der Streetfight ist ok aber nix besonderes. 6 Man Tag Team ist ebenfalls extrem langweilig. Nichts was man in Erinnerung behält. Joe gegen Cide ist natürlich ganz gut aber viel zu kurz. Styles gegen Daniels war dann schon wesentlich besser und Styles konnte mich endlich mal wieder von sich überzeugen. Gutes Match. Der Main Event war dann natürlich genial. Williams und Danielson wissen was sie im Ring machen und ich war echt überrascht als die 30 Minuten schon um waren. Ganz klar das MotN."
[7.0] "Um einiges besser als die erste Boston-Show. Es gibt zwar einige Matches auf der Card auf die ich hätte verzichten können, aber das Positive überwiegt klar. Der Opener ist stark, der Street Fight eine ganze Ecke besser als ich gedacht hätte. Joe vs Homicide hätte mehr Zeit verdient, überzeugt aber auch so. Die beiden Main Events sind einfach klasse und schließen eine gute Show ab."
[6.0] "Mark Briscoe fast als One Night Only bei der Prophecy, und schon gleich in einem schönen Opener. Nur das folgende ist bis zum Boston Street Fight kaum erwähnenswert.. Die 3 finalen Matches hingegen entschädigen die Show etwas. Die 30 Minuten im Main Event sind perfekt gewählt. Zusammenfassend gebe ich der Show 6 Punkte, weil der Start einfach zäh war. (Ten Man Scramble hat viel High Risk, ist aber viel zu unübersichtlich.. )"
