[4.0] "this is just not a good show def some good to decent matches on here but the bad very much outweighs the good, the Orton/micheals match really did nothing for Orton as he almost loses to a concussed man, Lashley v Vince stuff is just not great, good tag match, Benoit v MVP was good but not as good as thier other matches, Edge v batistia was underwhelming same with Cena v Khali as i enjoyed the squash match more"

[6.0] "It's surprisingly a pretty good show. There's nothing particularly bad and even Khali vs Cena is a decently done big guy vs smaller guy match, although not something I would like to watch again. The opener was a little too long considering Flair's capabilities at the time, but it wasn't bad, Bobby vs McMahons at least was short unlike their average match at Backlash, Punk vs Burke had a very nice showing from Brooks and Orton vs Michaels was a nice angle to put over Orton and had some incredible concussion selling from Shawn. Then Murdoch and Cade showed once again what an underrated tag team they were at the time, Edge vs Batista was fine, especially considering Dave's injury and MVP vs Benoit caught me by surprise - I loved that match, loved Benoit's selling of the leg and it was easily their best contest out of the trilogy. So a decent PPV, some pretty good matches here and there and some nice surprises."

[4.0] "I wouldn't call this show a failure, but I certainly wouldn't say it approached good, either. A slightly below average event. Punk vs. Burke was the only really quality match, with Benoit vs. MVP being the only other decent match on this card. Everything else was okay to bad. The ECW title match in particular is infuriating. They used Vince for a few months now as if he was going to be using his heel character to get Lashley over. Like they were going to give Lashley a big revenge match...but as a blowoff, a quick squash where he doesn't even touch Vince is such a disheartening letdown. Michaels vs. Orton also didn't do it for me. I get that they were trying to build Orton back up as a massive threat but...the match, time limit and place on the card just felt thrown together. While Orton did look good coming out of it, the randomness didn't do exactly what was intended. Flair vs. Carlito was a final no chemistry stinker that was booked and worked horribly. This show certainly is not one I can recommend, but there's some enjoyment to be had here if you feel like giving it a try."

[8.0] "I actually like this show. I wouldn't say it's got any classics on it, but it's just mostly solid matches. the MVP/Benoit match is actually really great if you followed the storyline at the time. MVP basically used months and months of being in the ring with Benoit to figure out all his tricks and beat him. It was great storytelling. The Murdoch/Cade vs Hardyz storyline was another really good one from this time and I liked their match here. And I thought Carlito vs Flair was pretty good. Punk/Burke really picks up at the end. Edge/Batista was decent. For what it was, Cena/Khali was decent. And the Orton/HBK stuff really did it's job. Only thing I didn't care for at all was the Vince/Lashley story."

[6.0] "I think I like this show much more than most would. There was a few shite matches like the opener and Edge vs Batista. But the main event was good and the tag match too. A decent angle too that? ll pay off come November. Good stuff. Best To Worst: John Cena (c) vs. The Great Khali - [***1/2]. The Hardys vs. Lance Cade & Trevor Murdoch - [***1/2]. CM Punk vs. Elijah Burke - [***1/4]. Chris Benoit vs. Montel Vontavious Porter - [***]. Shane McMahon, Umaga & Vince McMahon vs. Bobby Lashley - [**]. Randy Orton vs. Shawn Michaels - [**]. Carlito vs. Ric Flair - [1/2*]. Edge vs. Batista - [DUD]"

[6.0] "Perfectly fine event. Bobby Lashley one on three is short but overbooked, and enjoyable. Ric Flair vs Carlito is boring, maybe the worst Carlito match so far in a pay per view. CM Punk vs Elijah Burke is okay, Shawn Michaels vs Randy Orton is more of an angle, The Hardys vs Cade & Murdoch is a good match, Edge vs Batista is disappointing because it could have been better. Benoit vs MVP is the best match of the event and the main event is watchable, even if Khali had no charisma in the match."