Priscilla Kelly

[5.0] "She's bang average. I haven't seen anything that's THAT bad from her but I haven't been impressed by anything she's done. I'm pretty split with her I'll be honest."

[7.0] "Priscilla Kelly is one of the wrestlers who seems to be able to do it all on the indies. Whether it comedy, death or standard wrestling she excelled at it all. She was a solid worker in WWE but always in a stable never getting the attention she deserved. Good in the ring and good at working a crowd."

[8.0] "I really enjoy watching Priscilla - both the wrestling and her character. Wrestling's all about characters and Priscilla has been able to create a niche one and get mainstream runs with it. Her character on the Indy's has been better on the Indy's than in NXT."

[6.0] "She has never stood out to me she was just there her most memorable stuff was when she was in toxic attraction."

[9.0] "I don't know how everyone's Summerslam went but mine was watching posters of Elayna Black with bitter tearful daggers of disappointment and sadness. Empty spaces where a person who looks like you fits in. And you were gone. And then- Priscilla Kelly was there and was perfect and hot and badass in every part of you I missed. Kelly killing it for everyone for everyone. How the hell does a chick like that happen and how lucky are WE! Yes! Thank you for being the thing Priscilla and thank you for being there to make it right. I loved everything about it. That's my kind of pain."

[9.0] "Priscilla Kelly aka Gigi Dolin is a unique presence in modern wrestling for me as she blends a raw, unpredictable energy with solid in-ring skills and fearless character work. Her persona isn't just provocative; it's bold, layered, and stands out in an era where too many gimmicks feel copy-pasted. Where she can be sexy but dangerous and isn't bound to the norms and does what she wants which is why she gets a 9/10 from me because she's not only committed to "Hell's Favourite Harlot" persona but also continues to evolve, whether it's on NXT or on the indies. A true performer who deserves more spotlight."

[4.0] "Everything that made her exciting and fun to watch before joining WWE has been gone for a very long time. It's a shame too because I thought she had a unique look that would elevate her. Evidently I was wrong since she's been toiling in NXT for 5 years with nothing to show for it."

[3.0] "I liked PK more when she was on AEW, NXT has completely failed with her and she's not really helping herself either. She was first with Rose as a +1 (out of 2), then they turned her face but Jacy ultimately won the feud with going over with the fans and having 2 successful features (Thea feud and Fatal influence), meanwhile Gigi went on to have a seemingly interesting storyline with Ariana Grace but then she injured herself and instead of continuing from there, she gets put in a group for Tatum and Shotzi to carry her. Her ring work is nothing to write home about and i cant remember one promo of hers. Even in this new group she feels like the filler member. I feel she is one of the girls that can be let go, however she is now in a group and used."

[7.0] "she has a good aura and sells very well, I love her entrance to the ring and she has returned from his injury a little more agile than before, showing some movements that she did not perform before."

[6.0] "She has a great look and natural charisma whenever she is on TV but still lacks in her in-ring work. I'm not sure what the future holds for Gigi because it feels like she has plateaued. Even if she happens to get called up anytime soon which I doubt, I don't see much they will do with her."

[7.0] "Her faction (Chemical X) has caught my attention as of late. Before her previous absence on TV, she was one of my favorite NXT women's workers. Her presence on screen always made any storyline have a little crinkle in it, making it more interesting. Her in-ring work was most prevalent when Toxic Attraction still existed, as she blew her stablemates out of the water in that aspect. Her recent return has already raised eyebrows from a lot of people, including me and makes me curious for how well she'll perform in this true wrestling business boom as her stock has gradually been recovering."

[7.0] "Gigi has good ring gear and good stage presence, she has a good character and makes herself noticed when she enters the ring, inside the ring she is like a roller coaster sometimes she can show incredible potential and be amazing to watch but sometimes she can be a bit slow or sell some things a bit poorly but from all that we can conclude that she is a good wrestler and this 2025 she arrived with the desire to surpass herself"

[2.0] "I was hoping she would be let go from WWE during her injury as I don't think it's been the best environment for her to thrive. She spent the vast majority of her time post-Toxic Attraction getting into feuds that went nowhere, standing in the background of locker room sketches, and generally just getting jobbed out at every opportunity with nothing to show for it. Her whole angle with Arianna Grace had its plug mercifully pulled after her departure, as during the storyline she seemed entirely checked out both in and out of character. And I cannot be happy enough that I rarely see people refer to her as 'Georgina' anymore because god almighty did that shtick run its course at lightspeed. It's cool to see her team up with Shotzi, who she has history with, alongside Tatum who's pretty much cosplaying Gigi's look in the indies when she went by Priscilla Kelly. But I would still prefer to see her in a less restrictive promotion where I believe she could make a bigger name for herself, as being stuck in NXT for four years now isn't particularly the best look. Especially with so much younger, fresher talent that's been running circles around her for a long time now."

"Thoroughly underrated. Has the look and all because she isnt a 10 out of 10 wierdos dont like her, has her place in alot of companies"

[5.0] "Well sadly i think her injury ended every once of hope for her in NXT, everyone else in that division has stepped up and i don't see a place for her. Unfortunate."

[2.0] "Gigi Dolin is an completely sleeper at wrestling, barely sell moves, moves herself in a 0.25x speed, she's literally an orange gnomo, she had to be called to be part of a bad-ass faction, with two talented women to FINALLY be recognized in the business! Cause showing ass in instagram would't help so much, after Mandy Rose got released later in 2022, we could see, who was the talent girl in the group, and CLEARLY it was Jacy Jayne, not because she's ROUGH in the ring, an perfect mic skill, has an BAD-ASS gimmick, and literally an beast in the ring, Gigi got throwed away like trash, I think she should go back to the Performance Center and train off."

[4.0] "Since the end of Toxic Attraction, Gigi has been left behind in terms of character growth. Her feud with Jacy Jayne after their split was interesting until it completed, then Jacy flourished and Gigi has been... there. I don't see any character from her and her promos sound monotone and very rehearsed which is unfortunate for someone that's been in the game for nine years."

[2.0] "Gigi Dolin has absolutely nothing going for her outside of looks and oftentimes makes me debate turning the channel. The feud between her and Jacy turned me off from both women as wrestlers and while Jacy at least had a cool moment from it, getting color in one of their matches and looking like a badass as a result, I got nothing from Gigi except getting tired of her. While Jacy would go on to be entertaining in her role in Chase U, Gigi still has nothing and is still a slow uninteresting worker with an annoying voice that relies on calling people bitches in her promo to pop the crowd. I hate her upbringing and what she had to go through, and I understand that wrestling is something that helped her get through the trauma, so I hope she's having fun, at least."

[5.0] "She is just not that good in the ring, sure she's a little better at technical wrestling, but she also moves very slow. Sure, I get it, she's hot and has a big butt, yada yada, she's just not very good as a wrestler, though I will say she has improved in WWE and might end up getting better over time."

[7.0] "I like her. She has tons of personality and in ring, she is decent enough, there are plenty of rooms for improvement and ample time to improve. One to watch for."

[6.0] "She's ok. Her performances are hit or miss. I like her and Jacy together as a team. The sum of the two is better than them individually."

[6.0] "There was a time when it looked like Gigi Dolin could become the breakout star of Toxic Attraction. She's a pretty solid worker with a great look, has a good presence, very charismatic, and can cut good promos. When the group first debuted in NXT she was easily the best in the group. However since then, she has suffered numerous injury setbacks and has become significantly slower in the ring. She's still decent, but her ring work deteriorating this early in her career is not a positive sign."

[8.0] "The former Priscilla Kelly was a fairly decent indie talent for several years. As Gigi Dolin in the new era of NXT, she's one of the few standouts in this iteration of the brand. By far the best worker of Toxic Attraction. Quality wrestling, her selling is terrific and shows plenty of character. The NXT women's division still boasts some excellent talent despite the overall product regressing since the change. Confident to put her in that group. Just a shame she wasn't signed earlier when she really could've torn it up during the last couple of years of black and gold. On another note, her present run has helped her transform and shake off the infamy gained a few years ago due to the puking/tampon schtick."

[9.0] "She's great in the ring, especially her selling which is top tier. She has an incredible look, great natural charisma, excels at character work and, though you wouldn't believe it if you only saw her on NXT, she's a good promo as well. She should have been the leader of Toxic Attraction since she's by far the most talented in the group."

[6.0] "She is ok in the ring, not so good on the mic but has a distinctive look to her. I'm not the biggest fan as of now but she is doing her best."

[6.0] "Of the crop of new women in the 2.0 era, Dolin seems the most competent in-ring, which isn't surprising, given her greater experience. Still she's got a ways to go, and her character work is all over the place (though this admittedly isn't really her fault)."

[3.0] "I've seen her vomit and I've seen her use a bloody tampon in wrestling matches. I honestly think that if she didn't sign with WWE, we might've seen her take a dump in the middle of the ring before she ever attempted getting over with a promo. An embarrassment."

[4.0] "Really liked her in the Mae Young Classic & thought she had something with the sort of character you might expect to be wearing a black crown of thrones. But since then, instead of building an intriguing character, she's gone all in with the gross out stuff. She more known for the tampon spot & puking on Joey Ryan's junk. Is that the sort of stuff that's really going to turn you into a star? Considering AEW passed on her, I think the proof is in the pudding."

[7.0] "This rating is probably based more on potential than actual accomplishments, but TPK is certainly moving forward on those as well. She's getting plenty of work in the ring with established stars and has performed well with male wrestlers who are twice her size in front of crowds (and not just in the training ring). This is great experience especially for one so new. She has 'the look' and has the ability to play many different roles. Her size makes her a natural underdog that the crowd can root for, but she's showcased a dark side that she plays with conviction against her babyface opponents. I've not heard her on the mic much so that could be a challenge, but she communicates well non-verbally with her various looks and facial expressions. She certainly has a few stumbles and can appear green in the ring at times, but considerably less than one would expect with only a couple years of in ring experience. Her dedication to the her craft is evident and serves as a great foundation for future success and opportunities to show herself to a wider audience."