[5.0] "Comoroto has the look that makes you think he will be a star but has yet to accomplish anything major. In the ring he seems pretty average. He does not get opportunities on the mic as he normally ends up as the muscle in a stable. So far he has only really been used as a jobber. Might have potential if he is pushed."
[3.0] "Has the look, but at this point, if there was anything really there with him, I think we would have seen it by now. He was giving an albatross around his neck from the get go, having to be a part of the stupid Factory. But that was years ago now & he has still remained unproven."
[3.0] "This man looks like the kind of guy you'd push given just the sheer look of this man. The height, the muscle, he's got the looks of a star. Thing is, the man is just being used as a major jobber everywhere he goes in AEW. ESPECIALLY during the FACTORY! This man also shows little skill in the ring outside the basics, and I've never heard him talk, so i assume he lacks the mic skills needed. Overall if this man wants to get better, he needs to leave AEW and come up with something new."
[3.0] "Unfortunately he seems to be a terrible worker which is a massive shame because otherwise you'd be desperate to push this guy. He has an absolutely tremendous look and especially in the modern world where most wrestlers are below average size, he could be positioned as a bit of a monster in the midcard. However, he spends the little TV time he gets jobbing to small guys which just looks silly for a guy with his look."
[4.0] "He seems like an adequate big man but his push has stalled. When he actually wrestled he was ok, but it's clear that AEW has no interest in pushing anybody from The Factory and so Comoroto languishes in lower-card hell. With that said, I'm not sure I'm demanding to see more from him considering how talented AEW's roster is."
"Out of everyone in the Factory, Nick Comoroto probably has the most potential. It's a shame WWE never called him up to NXT, because they really dropped the ball on this guy. Comoroto's career as of now isn't in the best condition, due to the Factory stable and QT Marshall dragging him down. If AEW actually sees Comoroto for what he is (the next Braun Strowman), they might use him for more than a jobber stable."
[5.0] "Nick has a great look and impressive power. He seems to be showing gradual improvement in ring but isn't quite there yet. Right now he's a little lacking in intensity and can sometimes seem a bit lost and/or uncoordinated. He has potential, though, and I look forward to seeing how he continues to progress."
[4.0] "Nick Comoroto has always had a solid looking look to him, he kind of looks like a really buff Karl Marx in my opinion. His work in The Factory has been fine I suppose, I don't think that he'll ever break out of AEW Dark."
[5.0] "Boring big man. There's literally nothing there, what is this guy supposed to be' We already have big men in AEW and all of them, even boring ass Wardlow has some kind of shtick, what is unique about this guy' I like his moves and that's literally it, only reason his rating isn't lower is that and his somewhat unique look. If he goes for the Bruiser Brody thing that could actually work, he showed potential against Dustin in that bullrope match."
[6.0] "giant with character and almost old school style, with so much potential in my opinion but now he is too marginal and surrounded by too many other young athletes to bring out to see if he can really do something more. 6. honest. he commits himself and does the little they give him to do."