Jessie McKay

[5.0] "The more entertaining, and less talented, part of the Iiconics/Inspiration. She's tough to rate, because her antics are a 7, and her in ring is a charitable 4."

[5.0] "Jessie is a weird one because she's been doing this for a very long time, but doesn't look like it. If anything, she's regressed as a worker from her days in Shimmer. That said, she is still easily the better half of the IIconics/IInspiration, both in the ring and on the mic."

[8.0] "A great competitor, really shined as one half of the IIconics, and later as the inspiration (I think? ) in TNA and the rest of the indie scene. Always hilarious but also very good in ring. Good balance and a good roster member for anyone to be completely honest"

[3.0] "She's entertaining and has charisma and can't work for shit. She's attractive enough for the loneliest fans to convince themselves she's amazing at everything, but the reality she's so limited that she's best suited as a ringside presence to be a heater for someone else."

[8.0] "I really enjoyed Jessie in the ring in SHIMMER. Later on in WWE she leaned more in to the entertainment side but was very good at it. A great performer."

[7.0] "Not the best in-ring but she's a killer for comedic timing and antics. Her tenure in WWE ended too soon after the IIconic's breakup to see if she could transition well into a solo run, though I had good memories of her in NXT."

[5.0] "Not good in the ring by any means, but Billie is a VERY good comedic character, like the female R-Truth or Santino. Gets squashed often in matches, but always manages to stay relevant because of her comedic timing and mic skills. Her and Peyton are perfect as a tag team, as neither are main champion caliber anywhere."

[4.0] "What exactly is she good at? Because she certainly hasn't demonstrated that once throughout her career, to me. Billie Kay has some funny charisma and it sounds more natural than a helluva lot of others, but I have never thought once that I needed to go back and watch a match of hers. It's great that she's funny, but that's it."

[8.0] "IMO, Billie Kay/Jessie McKay is one of the more underrated female wrestlers in the industry. While not as talented with her in-ring skills compared to her IIconics/IInspiration tag team partner (and fellow Australian) Peyton Royce/Cassie Lee, she can still hold her own in any given match. Plus, she and Peyton/Cassie have incredible charisma and chemistry. Still kinda baffling why WWE would split them up in the first place."

[6.0] "I really dug Billie; she was great on the mic and had great personality, and she was able to translate it into the ring. Her actual work was subpar though .It's too bad wwe didn't put more work into her because she would have been great in that environment. Oh well. If you've got two left feet in the ring you're only going to go so far. Good for her making a career out of her personality otherwise, but I miss seeing her. Mic skills B+, Gimmick/look, B-, ring work D-."

[10.0] "She oozes charisma, that's not even talking about her in ring work. I love her tag matches and her funny spots. I really hope she does make a return to wrestling soon."

[10.0] "I could give Peyton Royce a 9. But the plus point is my personal preference. Jessie always had a special spark and in my opinion was very talented. She was wronged in WWE and Impact had her redemption. However, she could still do much more. Too bad he avoided moving away from the rings. But it left many special memories."

[3.0] "I mean what is there to say about her. She always loocks of the pace in the ring but its on the mic where my pacitence for her work endes. She is to put it bluntly a banshee on the mic she just screams at the top of her lungs and gigels. Her charter is that she is anoying and she sure is but its the kind of anoying where i want to just turn of the tv."

[1.0] "Billie Kay is a mediocre talent. She sucks badly in the ring, and is definitely the worse worker out of the pair. She's not particularly charismatic (although she probably possess more than Peyton Royce here), and she shouldn't talk on the mic at all. I still have bad memories of her awful promos in WWE with Peyton due to their screeching voices where they pretend like they're getting "good" heat. The IIconics were an awful tag team with a mediocre (and undeserving) tag title reign too. For the record, Billie is NOT funny at all. She's an incredibly obnoxious character where being annoying is her shitty gimmick."

[1.0] "She has been in the tag team with Peyton Royce for a good part of her career and that's it. She isn't talented. Not only on the mic, but also in the ring. Just another annoying girl that got into wrestling business."

[6.0] "Her charisma is a perfect balance for her partner's skill in the ring. The two work really well together. They are a natural fit with one another."

[8.0] "Jessica is comedy gold. That is her main selling point. Her mic skills combined with her immaculate comedic timing is what brings her up for me. Back in the day, she was even an excellent wrestler as well. Obviously she has lost most of her in ring talent over the years, but she is still immensely charismatic and entertaining, especially alongside Cassie. I will never understand why WWE opted to split them up."

[7.0] "Used to be a great wrestler now her strong suit is easily on the mic and in her character performances, she's one of the funniest women in wrestling. Her wrestling has drastically dumbed down, probably due to injuries."

[7.0] "His microphone and his charisma were very good. She was average on her in-ring levels. She was better in Tag-Team than in solo."

[1.0] "She is just like her teammate but worse. Very mediocre in the ring but both can serve more in the entertainment field rather than in the wrestling field. If you are looking for an instant classic neither she nor her partner will give it to you."

[4.0] "Not the worst, but she's not good either. She is good on the mic and very entertaining, but she is horrible in ring."

[5.0] "very entertaining and funny outside the ring but might be the worst wrestler of all time. Would love to see her as an annoying heel manager but no one should be this bad 13 years in"

[4.0] "She's the definition of adequate. She's not bad, she's not great, she's just in the middle. I dunno, she's just not that memorable to me right now."

[3.0] "She is bad in the ring and extremely irritating, she just shouts all the time and her voice is annoying. It wouldn't be so had if she said something worthwhile but she just says the same stuff over and over."

[7.0] "I like Billie Kay, she? s so good on the mic, very funny and entertaining. She only has to improve her in ring skills a little because she is slightly clumsy."

[3.0] "Honestly good on the mic, she's pretty funny, poor worker though so it doesn't matter if she's okay on the mic"

[4.0] "Unbelievable amounts of charisma and mic skills. Plays the annoying mean girl character very well. Not good in the ring at all, and NEEDS to be in a tag team. It's honestly appalling how bad she is in the ring, because she's been wrestling for almost 13 years. She has a great big boot, but other than that she's pretty clunky and awkward in the ring. Her height/size is a reason for that I think. She is like a baby giraffe in the ring. Also being that she's 31 and has already wrestled for so long, there's no way for her to actually get better. I enjoy her personality on the screen, but that's it. I feel like she'd excel in a manager's role."

[1.0] "If you told me that she? s been wrestling since 2007, I wouldnt believe it. She? s the most awkward and sloppy woman on the main roster. I use to think it? s because they were ? comedy wrestlers? and weren? t allowed to show their ? real? stuff but ever since they? ve returned, they? ve been more serious and Peyton has been showing off while Billie is just there. The only reason she doesn? t get heat from smarks is because they like her cringy catchphrases: ? Hey Kayla, ? and the all too annoying ? you? ve got to be joking me. ?"

[6.0] "Unfortunately for her, she is worse at everything compared to her partner. Except maybe at the mic. Because yes she is very good, sometimes exceptional, when there is a micro near her. This could be exploited for something. But in the ring she will never go near the top. +1 because I like how her Big Boot look so brutal (hope she doesn't botch them)"

[7.0] "Billie Kay is the perfect example of a good wrestler that focuses more on her character than in-ring action. Billie Kay has been a solid wrestler in NXT, but on the main roster, her focus on her gimmick and on-screen character became the centerpiece for her. She's a human cartoon character, and that made her wrestling look sloppy. Now that she's returned with Peyton Royce, she's showing that the wrestling aspect is something she's still talented at, but it wasn't her focus initially."

[4.0] "The iiconics are greater than the sum of its parts. Basic in the ring and the heel annoying shtick only works in small doses"

[10.0] "This woman is very talented and it's sad that she's unable to show what's she's capable of in WWE, she had great accomplishments in the indies especially main eventing SHIMMER twice but since signing with WWE it showed how her move-set was watered down, she's a full package, she has the look, the charisma, the in-ring abilities, the character, the mic skills, she's funny and entertaining (her and Peyton are the most entertaining if not the only entertaining female wrestlers in WWE), and when it comes to the ring she can do different variations of kicks, powerful/powerhouse moves, submissions, high-flying moves, busters, breakers, roll-ups & most importantly tag-team moves so she can do variations of different moves"

[6.0] "I think I like the IIconics gimmick more than most, but I don't think they're doing enough with the duo. They're working the bitchy girl thing well, but they also need to be winning matches here & there (even if by underhanded means) and that's not happening. They just keep losing & it's hurting Billie & Peyton. The program aside, Billie is not the best in the ring. She looks rather clunky at times, but it's so hard to tell because they give her so little in ring time. And when she does get in there, it's usually just to work the basics. I'm not sure if she would ever work as a single & I don't think she has the skillset to make it alone. But if they book her better as a team, I think they can be an entertaining act for years to come."

[4.0] "She's a bit botchy, she's not very good in the ring, on the mic she's fine, but whenever I see a match of hers, it's very boring."

[1.0] "How can someone be almost twelve years into the business and look like they're barely twelve minutes into the business? It takes real talent to have been wrestling for over a decade, which includes three years being trained in WWE's developmental league, with some of the best trainers available, and still be this bad."

[10.0] "Her and Peyton are the most entertaining on the smackdown women? s roster decent enough at wrestling to back it up it? s a shame they get no tv time because the i iiconics really have something special"

[1.0] "I've seen her as Jessie McKay and she was average nothing tremendous but really solid. As Billie Kay, she is not pushed but damn, she is horrible in every match where she is in the Main Roster. Sloppy in the ring, bad promos which are not fun at all, can do a right bump, don't communicate well with her opponent. I've seen potential in NXT but she's not as protected in the Main Roster so we see much more all her weaknesses."

[5.0] "The former Jessie McKay - who looked RADICALLY different! - was not the best person they could have found on the indies, nor was she the best who could've been promoted from NXT, but she is OK."

[5.0] "One half of the highly-entertaining Iconic Duo with Peyton Royce, it's clear she's the less spectacular of the two but she doesn't go without her merits. She's stunning, she can really work her character and in SHIMMER and some matches at NXT she has proved she's a capable worker. There does seem to be something missing that would prevent her rising without Royce, so she's in the perfect situation as it stands."

[4.0] "Horrible matches, bad in-ring performance, and Billie Kay desperately needs a new finisher... The Iconic Duo character is garbage and makes me wanna throw up, she is obviously the weaker link of The Iconic Duo"

[4.0] "LIke her bff Royce, I found billie kay very sloppy and awkward in the ring. Her execution and timing are terrible. Her mic work is so-so decent at best and she can draw some heel heat for sure. Overall, I am not impressed with her and the iconic duo in general."

[4.0] "Pretty good characterization, but she's kinda average in the ring and in her execution at the moment. Also can't punch/kick for beans which blows during a big match situation, it makes me feel bad for people like Asuka and Ember Moon."

[9.0] "Billie Kay despite an evil gimmick plays well his role of heel to perfection. She is very strong at the microphone, she has done some good match, without showing her in-ring ability. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- Billie Kay malgré une gimmick mauvaise joue bien son rôle de heel à la perfection. Elle est très forte au micro, elle a fait quelque bon match, sans montrer ses capacité in-ring."

[10.0] "Just a stand out example of adapting to the system - known for her girl next door aerial babyface fire in the US and now flipped the script as a sultry, brutal and evil fatale. Perfect example of development. Versatile character, fitting her role now in NXT. Will be a good addition to the main roster one day."

[6.0] "I like the heel gimmick, I love her entrance music, I enjoy the partnership with Peyton Royce, I just feel like something is missing from the character. I feel like some mic skill improvement would and maybe a stand out match to get some heel heat."

[5.0] "Hasn't really impressed me and her matches on nxt have been dull and fairly sloppy imo. I do however think it's ridiculous to give wrestlers 0-1 ratings as none of them are that bad so I'll five her the benefit of the doubt and maybe with some more time her character will be more interesting."

[8.0] "Billie Kay was someone I always liked in SHIMMER, especially during her feud with the amazing Madison Eagles. What I've seen in NXT I've been liking, definetly a strong contender for the Women's Championship."

[8.0] "Really good, really, , long legs! Hope she can become as meaningful, as she deserves to be; in WWE! Glad she made it to WWE."