[2.0] "JCW's legends show certainly had a respectful tone toward wrestling's past, and there were some fun ideas behind some of the matches - an ECW reunion match, a Memphis reunion match, an NWO vs DX "dream match, " etc. Unfortunately, there wasn't a lot to most of the action, as the age and conditions of many of the competitors kept many of the matches extremely short and basic. The battle royal was kind of fun, and the ECW seven-way match was a brief taste of classic hardcore mayhem (but, with its four-minute runtime, had too many participants to really be anything great). Nash & X-Pac vs New Age Outlaws was probably the best standard match of the night, but didn't really rise up to its "dream match" billing. On the positive side, the commentary from Kevin Gill and Mick Foley was pretty entertaining. It's not "Heroes of Wrestling" bad, but there's ultimately not much to recommend here - these types of "legends" events always seem to work better on paper than in practice. The show is historically notable for featuring the last matches of Roddy Piper, Ken Patera and Austin Idol, the last standard match of Mick Foley (who would be in the following year's Royal Rumble) and the last singles match of Bob Backlund (who would work two six-man tags in Japan in 2018)."

[2.0] "I view this show very similarly to how I view Heroes of Wrestling. It is good in concept (liked how they made multiman matches based on where they worked). That being said the wrestling is extremely subpar. Also why do you book Backlund and Patera for over 6 minutes when giving the 7 ECW wrestlers (most in decent shape) less than 4 and the Rock and Roll Express vs Midnight Express only 30 seconds. Those decisions make no sense."

[0.0] "For some reason, who knows why, the ICP saw Heroes of Wrestling and decided it was a good idea to repeat the stunt. The only difference is that it's 12 years later and so the legends are even more broken down. It's obvious just from looking at the match times that no one had any faith in these guys to work, and rightly so. There was also screwiness, because that's what you need on a nostalgia pop show! Add to that the grating voice of Kevin Gill on commentary and you've got an all-timer of suck."

[0.0] "JCW Legends and Idols (2011) is better than Heroes Of Wrestling (1999) by just the tiniest little bit as just about all the matches were just squashes and shortened to point where they aren't as agonizing to watch, but it still has everything that makes that show the worst of all time with a bunch of old and now out of shape and unfit wrestling legends just beating each other up. Just an atrocious show altogether."

[2.0] "Is this show good. No not at all but if you go into it expecting a shitshow it's not to bad and honistly quite funny. I enjoyed it but probably for all the wrong reasons"

[0.0] "Unequivocally and undeniably the worst wrestling show of all time. Nothing was even close to being OK, it was an embarrassment to the wrestlers and lacked all the energy of a typical JCW show. Every wrestler really felt like they were doing this for the easiest payday pf their lives, and I honestly still don't think any amount of money would be worth that embarrassment."

[0.0] "This was a terrible as everyone said it would be. Everyone looked like they wanted to be somewhere else this night. The combined age of everyone on this show is 2300! Snuka was the oldest performer at 68 while the youngest was Gowen at 28! The only highlight is the commentary. Don't watch this show unless you want to feel miserable and depressed afterwards"

[1.0] "Tito Santana vs. Greg Valentine: -1.5* / 15 Man Battle Royal: 1* / The Midnight Express vs. The Rock 'n' Roll Express: DUD / Seven Way Match: 1.5* / Ken Patera vs. Bob Backlund: -4* / Koko B. Ware vs. Doug Gilbert vs. Dutch Mantel vs. Austin Idol vs. Brickhouse Brown: -2* / Tracy Smothers vs. Tommy Rich: DUD / Kevin Nash & X-Pac vs. The New Age Outlaws: -1.5* / Mick Foley & Terry Funk vs. Bob Orton & Roddy Piper: -3* / Exactly as terrible as you would expect. The 1 point goes solely to Mick Foley and Kevin Gill's entertaining commentary. Mick's gimmick of talking to the wrestlers at the booth just after their match is a good one. Watching this show without the commentary would be 10x worse, I'm serious. There are no highlights whatsoever here in terms of the in-ring portion of the show. Terry Funk's promo about cat poop and horse breeding is.. entertaining? Plus the stuff he said at the end about piper while talking at the booth seemed like a shoot, either that or it was very well worked from Terry."