 # | Name | Promotion | Career Start | Career End | Length of career | Rating | Votes |
| 1 | Christy Hemme | 19.07.2004 | 17.12.2009 | 5 years | 6.21 | 221 | |
| 2 | Brock Lesnar |  | 11.10.2000 | 25 years | 8.12 | 1427 | |
| 3 | Shelton Benjamin |  | 2000 | 25 years | 7.65 | 795 | |
| 4 | Stephen Swann | 1998 | 16.12.2007 | 9 years | |||
| 5 | Tony Mamaluke | 1998 | 24.02.2018 | 20 years | 5.86 | 73 | |
| 6 | Todd Shane | 1998 | 2019 | 21 years | 2.36 | 32 | |
| 7 | Mike Shane | 1998 | 2018 | 20 years | 2.37 | 34 | |
| 8 | Chad Collyer | 06.12.1997 | 2016 | 19 years | 6.42 | 42 | |
| 9 | Molly Holly | | 02.08.1997 | 2005 | 8 years | 7.72 | 194 |
| 10 | Jeremy Lopez | 29.07.1997 | 28 years | ||||
| 11 | Eugene | 01.09.1996 | 29 years | 5.32 | 280 | ||
| 12 | Prince Iaukea | 04.1996 | 2015 | 19 years | 4.47 | 56 | |
| 13 | American Giant | 1996 | 29 years | ||||
| 14 | Kwee Wee | 1996 | 2011 | 15 years | 3.70 | 43 | |
| 15 | Tarus | 11.11.1995 | 29 years | ||||
| 16 | Jamie Noble | | 1995 | 11.12.2022 | 27 years | 7.18 | 378 |
| 17 | Geza Kalman Jr. | 1994 | 03.10.2010 | 16 years | |||
| 18 | Kurt Beyer | 09.01.1993 | 28.07.1994 | 1 year | |||
| 19 | Jeff Bradley | 1993 | 32 years | 6.59 | 16 | ||
| 20 | John Seru |  | 1993 | 2005 | 12 years | ||
| 21 | Kane | | 18.06.1992 | 33 years | 8.04 | 1281 | |
| 22 | Mark Mercedes | 1992 | 03.08.2019 | 27 years | |||
| 23 | Thundercrackk | 1991 | 2000 | 9 years | |||
| 24 | Sean Waltman | 1990 | 2022 | 32 years | 6.51 | 452 | |
| 25 | Ken Shamrock | | 06.1989 | 2022 | 33 years | 7.40 | 277 |
| 26 | Haystacks Calhoun Jr. | 1989 | 07.2003 | 14 years | |||
| 27 | Bobby Blaze | 11.09.1988 | 2004 | 16 years | 4.27 | 10 | |
| 28 | Rex King | 1987 | 2004 | 17 years | 3.52 | 30 | |
| 29 | Paul Diamond | 1985 | 03.06.2013 | 28 years | 4.97 | 58 | |
| 30 | Chris Champion | 1984 | 20.10.2017 | 33 years | 6.08 | 11 | |
| 31 | Bob Cook | 17.12.1981 | 04.11.1996 | 14 years | |||
| 32 | David Adcock | ||||||
| 33 | Rey Ayala | ||||||
| 34 | Mike Marcello | 2000 | |||||
| 35 | Greg Von Stekker | 2008 |
