Nattie

[4.0] "Well she has the name born into a Legendary family and training. Only I've never seen her have a good match. I just remember her having bad timing and being stuck waiting for the next spot in the match, not being able to think or call it in the ring. Known for her name and longevity ....and total divas. I don't remember her ever getting over much and not having much of a promo. I would say just a flat character over all."

[5.0] "Being a student of the Hart Dungeon she has in-ring skills, but it seems like she's forever cursed to never be over with the audience, no matter how many times she turns heel or how many gimmicks she gets. I can't think of any memorable feuds or angles she's been in through her nearly 2-decade career with WWE. I am guessing she will retire soon and probably become a very good backstage coach."

[3.0] "For someone who has been in the company that long, the overall impact has been minimal, and that is disappointing. She can have solid matches and is clearly skilled, but the character work and promos have always held her back. She has rarely been part of truly major, memorable storylines. It is frustrating because she is a hard worker, respected locker room leader, and someone who clearly understands the business. I think she would make an excellent coach one day. As an in ring performer though, she often comes across as boring and underwhelming despite her experience."

[3.0] "Natalya is simply someone I've never really been able to get into. Nothing is bad about her but nothing stands out. She's obviously a huge mentor backstage and that's great! But I'm not too impressed by her work. Her current Nattie gimmick is awful. It's uninspiring and her stuff with Maxxine Dupri is genuinely horrible. It's crazy to see how much she's fallen off compared to around 2017 man, crazy."

[4.0] "I mean I just don't get it, they should have kept her old look cause she doesn't look like a dominant force like she used too, shes a reliable worker I GUESS, and I assume shes a great mentor backstage but like, wheres the old natalya in like 2016? its like an imposter has killed her and took over her career."

[4.0] "Natalya is mid right now but we all can agree she losted her talent since 2010's in past she was really good she proved her skill to wwe universe she won title opportunies she won many titles but right now i dont see old prime Natalya here i dont even see her in television anymore I think she needs some push from wwe just like Guilia and more talanted stars"

[4.0] "She has the worst non convincing facial expressions during any match she is part of. For someone wrestling for that long is actually quite laughable. Her wrestling is not as good as her rating here suggests as well"

[5.0] "She's a slightly above average worker but she is not really interesting in regards to character work in any meaningful way. She's basically just known as a member of the Hart family. Overall, as far as the complete package, she's as average as it gets."

[10.0] "If you ask me, Natalya is the best female wrestler in WWE history. She has not been given as many championships as others but she has had the most matches and if you look closely at her work. You'll see that she is the one who is carrying her opponent. She has elevated countless amounts of future and current talent but she never got the hype she deserved herself. I think if she was booked in more gimmick and main event matches then the whole world could see her full potential."

[3.0] "She seems like an extremely nice person and one of the best locker room leaders you can have, but I have just found her painfully boring for the vast majority of her career. Every once in a while she'll hit a pocket where she's entertaining but for the most part, her matches feel very lifeless and she's never been one to cut a particularly good promo either. She does have some very solid matches with people like Sasha Banks but I cannot think of a single time in my life where I've been seeking out Nattie's work."

[10.0] "She's actually my favorite wrestler; I think it's just that she's underappreciated by WWE fans. She has been working in the industry for more than 10 years. She makes the opponent look good because she's literally a veteran. Her in-ring skills are very good, and her mic skills are not the best thing she's good at. But personally, her "positive" side outweighs her mic skills. I have recently loved her "Nattie Neidhart" gimmick. She just looks more fierce. I'm hoping they bring it to WWE cause that gimmick is really interesting. And yes, she's definitely gonna be a future Hall of Famer."

[3.0] "I don't know what is it lately with internet discourse surrounding wrestling, but now it seems like every single person that has been on TV for a considerable amount of time suddenly has become a wrestling legend that needs respect. Natalya has been on WWE television since 2008 and what the hell does she have to show for it? Has she ever had a single match I would go back and watch? Uh, no. The only legendary thing about Natalya Neidhart is how long she's been employed while providing nothing of value to the TV product that I watch as a fan. Maybe she's a great influence backstage, but I don't watch backstage, I watch the TV show."

[3.0] "One of the most boring wrestlers of all time. She is the perfect cure for insomnia. She is technically sound but that doesn't mean her matches are exciting. I find her pretty boring. She still has a legacy, and I do have to acknowledge that she has been doing it for years. Never been a great promo, and isnt on the spot with her wrestling anymore. I sigh now every time I see her on the screen, and i wish that wasnt the case"

"[10.0] One of the greatest women wrestlers that has ever stepped foot into the WWE and also one of the most unappreciated. No Nattie isn't the flashiest, but no one is more technical sound than she is. There's also a reason why most of the women and men go to her Dungeon to train. I'm loving her career resurgence as the Low Key Legend in 2025 and I'm really hoping it makes it the main roster and she finally achieves the success she's always deserved."

[3.0] "Lowkey legend? More like Lowkey Garbage. The fact she's getting pushed in Triple A is pathetic. People say "I don't understand how you can hate Natalya." Well for me it's I don't understand why people like her. She's not that good. The ones that came before her are much better. The fact that she's over a seven out of ten rating on here is atrocious. She's more deserving of a five because that's what she is at best and if she wins the Reina de Reinas Championship. That would be an embarrassment to Lucha Libre Wrestling as a whole. She needs to do everyone a favor and just retire already. Women's Wrestling would be much better off without her."

[7.0] "Never cared to much about her from back in the day to know her better but from what I've seen today she act like some short of a locker room leader, or like female r truth? well that's good and all but i see her as a pin eater also, her wrestling skill is good tho"

"I never understood why people liked her. Yes, she's part of the Hart family, but that doesn't make her automatically good. I always found her matches boring and her moves sloppy. And even physically, she never looked dominating, so in my opinion she really didn't have any tool to win matches, yet they let her win many times."

[7.0] "I was surprised to see how old Natalya is when I decided to finally give her a rating, though that is funny because I was also going to mention how long she had been in WWE. I was going to speculate that she can be a bigger star in a different promotion, though factoring her age it might not be a risk she and promotions would go for. Natalya is good in the ring and is still putting on good performances."

"[10.0] Natalya has held both the Divas and SmackDown Women's Championships, showcasing her longevity and adaptability. Beyond titles, she's helped pave the way for women to be seen as serious athletes, influencing a generation of talent through her example and leadership."

"Natalya is the definition of hard work and dedication. Whether you like her or not, she has helped many women in business and is a walking legend."

[7.0] "I would put 6 as her wwe career has been fine. I can't remember to many matches but she's had her moments and some solid matches when they give her the time. She also seems to have been put in a mentor role which she's been cool in but it still feels off to see her lose in the wwe developmental shows. But I've seriously liked her in her 3 matches outside of the company. The GCW bloodsport match, the nwa match and the AAA triple threat tag have made me so much more engaged with her. Hope to see her more!"

[8.0] "I wasn't fan of her role for a period, her act and character comes off bland mostly and sometimes obnoxious (as heel in 2016-18). However, I always resepct her very much when the bell rings, she always remains one of the best of all time, having decent to excellent match with almost everyone. Definitely a prowrestling legend."

[10.0] "Natalya is one of the most consistent and technically sound wrestlers in WWE. Over the years she has been a steady presence in the women's division, often serving as the veteran who can help younger talents improve. Natalya's work ethic and professionalism are undeniable. She can deliver solid matches with almost anyone, and her work in GCW and NWA proves how far her range of wrestling goes. Natalya remains criminally underrated by fans who associate lack of TV time with skill, and the company who has never kept her in the main event picture even though she's earned it"

[8.0] "I do not get why she's over hated Naty is a very talented technician she puts talent over and trains the younger talent all the time. She would be a perfect champion for the new mid card tittles to showcase her unappreciated talent."

[8.0] "People saying she's not good at not paying attention. Nattie is very technically sound. She's not the most athletic, not the flashiest but she can work with anyone. Her match with Kenzie Paige was even better than her Bloodsports match. Maybe people aren't paying attention because she's a woman, who knows."

[10.0] "I am convinced most Natalya haters don't actually keep up with her work. Her latest Bloodsport match with Miyu is an example of how much technical knowledge she truly has. She has more value than just a trainer or mentor. Her promos have really improved since 2016/7, which is where she had to do a lot of talking and wasn't all that convincing. She is immensely limited by the WWE system which has continued to overlook her, giving her a new random partner in a neglected tag team division, and constantly giving her storylines where they have her announce her self-doubt due to her age where you think they're going to give her an underdog story, only for her to lose whatever match they're building up to. Despite her age and years of being active, she is still incredibly slick and smooth in the ring, and overall is a very enjoyable wrestler to watch. Her recent matches with Roxane Perez, Rhea Ripley, and the aforementioned Miyu Yamashita are good examples of this. I was disappointed that she re-signed, as she does not fit in with that company at all. A tried and tested independent wrestler, it made sense for her to sign to WWE when she did in 2007, when there were really no opportunities for women elsewhere. That is no longer the case. It is frustrating that a woman that has held two single titles over the span of a nearly 20 year stint with the company, neither going over 100 days, has had fans insisting that she retire. Her male contemporaries simply do not have the same criticisms or limits, The Miz being a shining example of this, and that is insane considering she can actually wrestle. She is far from being the oldest wrestler, male or female, in the company! I hope WWE allows her to take the independents by storm so she can really showcase her abilities. "Where has this Nattie Neidhart been? " She has been here all along!"

[9.0] "I don't understand the hate Natalya gets. Started her career on the Indie scene, wrestled in Japan and earned her name. Then she went to WWE and instantly became the best wrestler in the Women's division until the Women's revolution at least. Now she's a locker room leader and has clearly improved the talent around her (namely Liv Morgan for example) and if you pay attention she has good matches like in NXT last year. Fart gimmicks aside, she was never a focal point on TV, or had the belt enough to garner as much criticism as she's had. She is also a lot better than other wrestlers who have "stuck around for too long" *cough* The Miz *cough*. Perhaps to some she's a symbol of time gone by, perhaps it's the names she is usually tasked with making look good (Ronda Rousey), but if she was as a youngster now it would be a totally different story and was far more of a complete package than most NXT wrestlers who are praised for hitting a drop kick. It's a shame WWE had few on her level in her prime years. I would have loved to see what she could have done outside of WWE, at least we will be getting a taste of that this year."

[6.0] "Disaster on the mic. I get she is technically good but have you ever been entertained during a Natalya match? Can you remember any? Can you even remember any rivalries of her? That validates my answer enough."

[4.0] "While Natalya isn't bad, she isn't good either. Her presence in the ring isn't missed, though I don't particularly care if she's there either. Her promos are mediocre, not bad, not memorable. And her in-ring work isn't amazing either, but it's not really bad. To summarize, she's as bland as it gets."

[7.0] "I have such a soft spot for Nattie. People are way too harsh on her for some reason. Despite that, she has proved consistently (even present day) that when shes given a good opponent and adequate time she can produce some really solid matches! Hell, even during the divas era when women were given barely one 2-3 min match a night she had impressive performances which is obviously very hard to do with such little time. Nothing but respect for her."

[4.0] "She is fine enough overall but I'm just gonna be honest, I have always found her so unequivocally boring that I don't think I've ever genuinely been able to find enjoyment in her work outside of a few slight exceptions, she is technically sound and overall adequate enough as a wrestler, but she lacks so much in so many areas, and being in the Hart family isn't really enough to salvage her work for me, so again she's not deplorable (like definitely not a 3 or below), but I've never found her particularly good overall, just never really got the hype personally... 4/10."

[8.0] "Natalya is an active legend for women wrestlers in WWE, but she never really feels like a big deal and I cant really say its her fault. She came at a time when she was that one woman who knew how to wrestle at all, during an era when women wrestlers were meant to have bra and panties matches. That said, shes had a huge impact for womens wrestling and helped develop the next generation of talent, even if sadly that didnt include her. All in all, shes the prime example of a legend whos not respected."

[6.0] "A good wrestler, I have a lot of adoration for her. I think she has a very good ability to wrestle, underrated ring skill. Maybe it's my fondness for the Hart Family talking, but I think she's above average... considering her prime, she certainly ranks among the best."

[5.0] "Natalya is not bad inside the ring but damn she's so boring and is uninteresting in everything. Natalya has literally no chsrisma, when you see her you feel nothing and when she speaks, it's even worse, she's unable to transmit us emotions because her acting isn't that good which is kinda strange for someone who is in the business for such a long time. As a heel she's not good and as a face she's tasteless, she's literally interesting in nothing and despite the fact she's a dependable worker with a plenty of experience, it's hard to be interested in Natalya."

[7.0] "Many fans are too harsh about her work. Even today, she remains a good and reliable figure in the women's division. Her mic skill is holding her back though, and she's definitively a better heel than a face."

[4.0] "Natalya is easy to like when you enter the world of wrestling. She easily plays the average wrestler, highly technical and capable of losing after competitive matches. She masters the emotion of anger or knows how to play the victim easily. Unfortunately, she has no charisma, her facial expressions and mannerisms are tedious and her microphone skills non-existent. It's hard to find her credible, especially today when there are so many talented athletes, and it's hard to find a place for her. All the more so since, unfortunately for her, the writing of her many turns and characters has long been miserably bad, and her many changes of team, each as bland as the next, mean that today no position on the card would suit her."

[5.0] "There's just something that makes her dreadful. Not very good in the ring, and horrible on the mic. I find her pretty boring. She still has a legacy, and I do have to acknowledge that she has been doing it for years. I'm also pretty sure she's the only Hart still wrestling for WWE. Still she's only a 5/10"

[8.0] "Natalya is an excellent in-ring wrestler that has done a tremendous job elevating young talent as she enters the later stages of her career. Moreover, she comes off as grateful and positive to be in the position she is in, which is refreshing to see in such a negative world. Donning the pink and black, she's had the look and character of a wrestler since day one. She's comfortable on the mic as well, but like many members of her family, she truly excels in the ring. Natalya is one of the few WWE women's division wrestlers that excels in mat wrestling. Her strikes are impactful while her moves look painful instead of gimmicky. Although it's a bummer watching Natalya job so frequently, she does so with grace. Hopefully, she is able to get one last competitive run - whether it be in WWE or somewhere else - as she still has it."

[6.0] "Natalya's impact behind the scenes is important and unprecedented. She never fit in with the traditional model of what was expected of women and seems to be a real leader. As a wrestler though, I find her move set to be drab and uninspiring and her charisma to be lacking. Having said all that though she is deeply important and influential to women's wrestling in WWE and seems to be a truly lovely person. I hope to see her as a producer one day, she would be great at that."

[6.0] "Natalya is a decent in ring worker, but that's really just about it, I will give her an extra point (bringing her score up to the 6 points I gave her) for being in the business for a long time and being able to be one of the few women's wrestlers from the 'Divas Era' to transition well from that era (the other notable one being Naomi). Other than those things I mentioned, there isn't much she can do anymore from a career perspective, she's 41, has had a few title reigns in the company, and has had some decent matches, with her best being vs Charlotte on NXT. I have always had respect for Natalya, especially since she's from one of my favorite wrestling families in the business, the Hart Family."

[6.0] "Natalya is good in the ring, she has tons of experience and has the pyschology since she comes from a wrestling family. But unfortunately the only interesting thing about her is that she is the longest employed woman wrestler in the WWE. She lacks change which is the biggest reason why I wouldn't mind if she was no longer in WWE. She doesn't contribute anything considerable to the program anymore and is just.. there. I think that taking a break might have been better for her career in order to come up with something new. Neither her character nor her moveset has evolved since she started in the WWE and it's seriously getting quite boring. I think that she hasn't really pushed herself to go outside her boundaries. But at the same time, she doesn't have the power to put together her storylines which hinders her growth as well. ,"

[5.0] "I don't remember her ever being very good. She's been a pretty average performer always, average, but nothing more. She has a couple of kinda decent matches and that's it, and she's over 40. Victim of poor booking on some ways, thats impacted her career storngly, let's be honest and fair. 5 out of 10, i guess. Nothing special for me."

[10.0] "For me; Natalya is one of the pillars of women's wrestling today. She is a ring leader and a good worker all around. Yet given the time to shine; she doesn't do it often and people have yet to complain about her being in all these matches. She is a decent wrestler but in any match she always does her best to put the other person over. For example; her matches against Rhea Ripley for the championship, all the matches they had she always put Mami over in those cases."

[10.0] "She is really THEE STAR, she has been wrestling almost for 20 years and still looks good and can fight, Nattie really can show up in matches like Elimination Chamber, Royal Rumble and Money In The Bank. Nattie really deserves her flowers because she really shows that the agr is just a number. She gave Rhea rioley her best title match and gives everyone opportunities to go over her, she is so charismatic and so funny like shes really the best veteran and lets not forget her world records likeeeee."

[6.0] "She's had good matches, sure, but she is an extreme example of what Charlotte's problem is, in that she doesn't have a character at all other than "She's related to the Hart's" and while a decent technical performer, I often struggle to find a reason to care about any match she's involved in."

[4.0] "Yes, nattie is a veteran, and yes, nattie deserves all the respect in the world. But in the ring now, she is not very good. Never been a great promo, and isnt on the spot with her wrestling anymore. I sigh now every time I see her on the screen, and i wish that wasnt the case."

[10.0] "Natalya is a veteran who everybody should respect. She had naver got enough credit for her work and putting every single women over. She deserves atleast one more good title run."

[4.0] "Does not have much offer anymore other than a decent match every once in awhile. She gets put into the title picture when they have no one else to go against the champion and at this point they brought back enough women wrestlers that she doesn't need to be on tv."

[10.0] "After last night match with rhea and the promos going towards it, it just shows how amazing of a talent natalya is and how much she is underused by the wwe, a true legacy diva that has proven time and time again that she is historic and she is also the women who wrestled the biggest amount of matches in history."

[9.0] "Very, very underrated talent in WWE. Can work with anyone, at any time, on any show, and will deliver. Can showcase her opponents abilities like no other in the women's division, and is great worker in her own right. Her booking & character development are her only downfall."