[5.0] "At the time this was filmed, the Young Bucks vs. Bad Influence was a dream match, so this was worth seeing for that alone. (Of course since then Bad Influence left TNA and have had plenty more matches with the Bucks in ROH, PWG, FWE and HOH. ) The rest of the show was perhaps a waste of time, but a fun one. The Monster's Ball with Joseph Park vs. Judas Mesias was fun to see a different side of Park in a match like this rather than Abyss. The Hardy/Runt vs. Team 3D and LAX vs. New Church tag matches were also solid. And the hardcore battle royal was a lot of fun, with several nice surprise appearances (Scorpio, Guido, Funaki, Storm and Swinger) and the awesome visual of Shark Boy fighting people off with a dead fish. Far from the best One Night Only show, but also far from the worst - it entertained me, anyway. Still not sure why it was titled "Hardcore Justice 2, " when it was actually the fourth show of that title."

[8.0] "I really like this concept of One Night Only, but it would be better if it was live. Great performances by Bad Influence, The Young Bucks, 2 Cold Scorpio, Funaki, Little Guido, Bob Holly and Spyke!"