[4.0] "An entirely skippable show. There are a few good moments, those being the entirety of Jericho vs Bourne and the finish of the main event where The Nexus attack everyone and Sheamus steals the pin in the chaos. The rest is nothing special at best and bad at worst."

[6.0] "It was a good PPV for the most part, definitely ahead of that pathetic mess that was Over The Limit last month, I don't think it was better than Extreme Rules though, so there's that. On a show called "Fatal 4 Way" the best match on the card was an impromptu/unannounced match between Bourne and Jericho. The two main events are nothing I would go out of my way to watch, and Miz vs Truth was terrible. Must note that the crowd loved Jericho, and the show ended with Daniel Bryan chants."

[5.0] "For a one off PPV, I'd say it did decently enough to get the job done. There are certainly worse. No match on this card is a must see or tore the roof off the building, but besides the US title match being very dull, nothing flat out sucked either. The one thing I did notice is that this show relied a LOT on run ins and outside interference. To the point that it was noticeable, and I was saying "Another one? " by the end of the night. A fine event, but maybe a bit sloppily booked, thinking they could get away with it without people noticing."

"Interesting show here as this was the only Fatal 4-way PPV ever held. Kofi/Drew have a solid opener. Both guys were still early in their careers but they were given a lot of time here and you can tell they have potential, even if this match was nothing special. Evan Bourne and Jericho have an awesome match 3rd on the card where Bourne gets the victory and looks like a future star. Swagger/Rey/Kane/Punk was pretty much nothing. Kane wants to find who took Taker out (it was him all along). Swagger drops the WHC to Rey in 10 minutes where the best part about the match is Punk wrestling in a Lucha mask. Miz and Truth have an unfortunate US title match that took 14 minutes. The main event is Cena/Orton/Edge/Sheamus. The match was fine but didnt blow me away. Nexus jumps everyone towards the end of the match and Sheamus steals the victory and WWE title. Pretty much a nothing show outside of the great Bourne/Jericho match."

[5.0] "Better than Over the Limit the month before, but still not PPV worthy. The opener and evan bourne vs jericho are great, but both feel like great TV matches really. The fatal 4 way concept was okay, but you can see why they never came back to it"