[8.0] "Decent and well built UK edition of Smackdown here with a far better effort than Raw when it came to the match quality as well as pushing storylines forward. This show is most remembered for the excellent heel turn from Eddie Guerrero where he and Rey Mysterio lost the Tag Tile rematch to MNM because he refused to tag in after a miscommunication mid match. It was a slightly better match than last week with Eddie standing and watching Rey get attacked post match and then he walks out on him afterwards. Eddie's facial expressions really sell it well. I was a bit disappointed with how the London vs Chavo match was booked with a dumb finish, but I'm happy they're at least continuing a strong storyline going into the next PPV. The 4 Way Elimination match was really good as well, which segmented into a few rivalries playing into the finish where Kurt Angle eliminates Booker T with a chair shot, while Booker T costs Angle the match returning the favour with JBL getting lucky again and Big Shows quick elimination is handled in a logical way where everyone land a finisher on him and Angle landing the Angle slam through the announcers table to cause a count out was a great spot. Unlike the terrible UK Raw show nothing really stupid happens on this show and it's enjoyable from start to finish."

[8.0] "This is a good show, it's important because there is the heel turn of Eddie Guerrero on Rey Mysterio after weeks of tension. The Elimination 4 Way match in the main event is good, with betrayals every ten seconds. Also, Chavo Guerrero vs Paul London is an acceptable match, but the ending is disappointing."