[7.0] "This was a very good episode that was only hurt by a few weak matches. The opening match between Team Canada and Jerry Lynn and Heavy Metal was sloppy, but fun. Monty Brown and Sonny Siaki was just a boring slog to get through. Frankie Kazarian defended his X-Division Title against The Amazing Red in the match of the night. For some reason Abyss vs. D-Ray 3000 was here. It went as well as you'd expect. Kid Kash and Dallas defended their World Tag Team Titles against James Storm and Dusty Rhodes in a boring match. Finally, Jeff Jarrett won the World Heavyweight Title by beating Chris Harris, AJ Styles, Raven, and Ron Killings in the first ever King of the Mountain Match."

[7.0] "The first ever King of the Mountain match, and it definitely solidified itself as one of the signature match types of TNA. The in-ring action was very solid, I would consider Kazarian/Red and KOTM my favorite matches from this show."

[7.0] "Aside from the New York Connection Racism Angle, and the whatever opener, this a fun show. I didn't watch TNA until Victory Road 2004, so this all feels like a weird parallel timeline to me. But I mean; Monty vs Siaki was unexpectedly awesome, Kaz vs. Red was expectedly awesome, Abyss destroyed D-Ray 3000 with that Black Hole Slam, NWA Tag Title Match was fun, and the First King of the Mountain Match kicked ass. Want to rate this higher, but those first two points hold it against this show. Also too much Erik Watts."