[9.0] "Amazing show, no matches under 3.25/5, only the three first matches are under 4/5 (3.25 ; 3.5 ; 3.75 respectively). That means all matches were were good to awesome. PWG at that time was really the place to be for independant wrestling. Those were good times..."

[7.0] "Pretty good show. The first half was slightly better than the second half. Lots of great action here."

[6.0] "I liked about half of the show but I also really disliked the final two matches so I didn't get as much out of this show as a lot of people."

[6.0] "Somewhat lower quality effort in PWG, as lots of people (Trevor; Galloway; Andrews; Kyle; Sydal; Ricochet) did not put their best foot forward. Nevertheless, both Uno/Hero and Sabre/Cole were extremely pleasant contest, while a slew of wrestlers put in noteworthy performances (Chuck; Strong; Trent; Scurll). Most matches are at least watchable and solid, but the whole night is almost always a bit lukewarm and the whole show feels less than the sum of its inordinate parts."

[10.0] "Chuck T vs Lee was a fun opener ***1/2. Hero vs Uno was a good hard hitting match, better than I expected ***3/4. Trent? vs Galloway was another great match ***3/4. Mandrews vs Strong was yet another great match ***3/4. Scurll vs O'Reilly was fantastic ****1/4. Sabre Jr vs Cole was fantastic as well ****. Bucks vs Rico/Sydal was absolutely awesome and a great prelude to the BOLA night 2 Six Man. MOTN ****1/2. All around fantastic show"

[7.0] "As PWG's popularity has reached stratopsheric levels, a friend of mine suggests it should charge $175. 00 per ticket and $250. 00 for front row, its workrate has not. This isn't to say that the invited wrestlers are resting on their laurels, rather it's that effort & length alone do not make for 4 starmatches. The match rated highest on this site is an example of rhythm & dance over a fight; 'Party Marty' may be over with workers but he's so light even Yosuke Santa Maria would be offended by his feminine touch. Evil Uno may conceive of interesting spots but as workers these were two flabby men who were too cute for the match's good. Now something I did enjoy, and something I saw live back in '05 against Sydal/Jack, is Roddy beating on men of much smaller statures. Since in all liklihood he's Jobbing his belt the following night, Roddy made an example of 'Mandrews. ' Now the main event... this was some cool shit. Sydal dousing out M Jackson's 'I'm on fire' line, etc. The seamlessness of watching the Jackson boys execute their standards make them all-time greats, (but they have rarely recently challenged themselves against true heavyweight teams, in which a different dynamic than the ones we've repeatedly seen over the last three years, would exist. ) Rico is also an all-time talent, and those who say he sucks are fans who feel he had too successful a '15 without being a quality babyface that his role within the story demanded. 7. 5 rounded dwn because of all ya who overpraise PWG."

[8.0] "A good show full of good matches. I'd only really recommend the last 4 matches all of which i'd rate at **** with exception to the main event which I had at ****1/4. Despite the many good matches they all had pretty big issues stopping them being rated higher in my opinion and though the main event was a good fun spotfest it was no classic and I feel there isn't really anything particularly new or fresh on this show so I can't rate it above an 8. Still pretty good though with quite a few enjoyable matches."

[9.0] "Great show . Every match was from real good to great . A minimum of talking which for me is a plus . Wrestlers from many different styles blending to put on a highly entertaining show . The only issue I would have is I am so f'n tired of the super kick overdoses . Matches worth watching : all of them and my top match was Kyle O'Reilly vs. Marty Scurll ."

[7.0] "Good show this! Consistently good matches down the card with Chuck/Lee and Galloway/Trent both being very good (***). Scurll/Kyle and the ME were both awesome (***1/2 and ***3/4 respectively) which took this show to the next level - good stuff!"

[10.0] "Fucking amazing show. Chuckie/Trevor was really good (*** 1/4) and so was Hero/Uno (*** 1/4). Trent/Galloway was awesome (****), Andrews/Strong was great (*** 3/4), KOR/Scurll was outstanding (**** 1/4), Cole/Sabre was great (*** 3/4), and Young Bucks vs Sydal/Ricochet was incredible as well, MOTN in my opinion. (**** 1/4). This was one of the best shows I have seen this year. Highly recommended."

[7.0] "The Night 1 of All Star Weekend 12 was a good show. The opener was really fun (***1/2), Hero/Uno was a really good hoss fight (***1/2), Galloway/Trent was pretty good (**1/2), Andrews/Roddy was really good (***1/2), O'Reilly/Scurll was bad & my least favorite match of the night (*1/4), Cole/ZSJ was pretty good (**3/4) and the main event was really good and my favorite match of the night (***3/4). Nothing truly ****+ must see, but 4 really good matches that sure are worth watching."