[7.0] "This card was pretty weak until the main event, but the insane idea of cramming 9 other matches into the first hour and a half paid off for them, as nothing really overstayed its welcome. The show kicked off with a pretty average match between Tony Mamaluke and Jeremy Lopez that was my introduction to Lopez. Christian York and Joey Matthews then squashed Jacob Ladder and Prince Nana to set up the requisite homophobia for these early ROH shows. Bio-Hazard and Michael Shane then picked up the win in a complicated and poorly wrestled match against Don Juan and Paul London. There was a stipulation about the winner getting a contract, but it kinda sounds like that's not happening, so I don't know. Da Hit Squad had a short match with Divine Storm that didn't have any obvious problems. James Mauritato beat Jay Briscoe in the next phase of the odd Briscoe brothers feud, where Mark can't actually legally do anything. The Natural Born Sinners beat The Carnage Crew in a shockingly violent and entertaining Bunkhouse Match. AJ Styles defended his TNA X-Division Title in a quite good Elimination Match against Adam Jacobs and David Young. At this point the show enters editing hell, as there's supposedly a match between Dunn, Marcos, and Mike Tobin and Black Gordman Jr., Brian XL, and Dixie, but all we see is some big guy beating up Dunn and Marcos. The terrible editing continues as Scoot Andrews and Xavier have a match that's edited like a highlights package, and not a very good one at that. Finally, we get the 60-Minute Iron Man Match for the newly formed ROH Title between Low Ki, Spanky, Doug Williams, and Christopher Daniels that manages to be the match of the night, something that's essential for such a long match."

[8.0] "Of course if you book a 60 minute main event the rest of the card is going to suffer, I only really recommend Styles/Jacobs/Young from the undercard. But the main event here is so good that I think this is my favourite ROH show so far."

[7.0] "Aside from the main event, this is a really mediocre show. There are two or three good matches but then we get a whole lot of garbage segments and matches from the usual suspects and a downright bad co-main. Still, the undercard takes less than 2 hours and the main event makes up a third of the entire show, and that was great. It's a one match show, but that match goes 60 minutes, so it weights in more in the overall score. The undercard is mediocre but brief enough to be tolerable and the main event is worth the wait"

[6.0] "This is another difficult show to rate, as it's really a one match card, however that match happens to take up a third of the show. Unfortunately the first 40+ minutes of the event are pretty rough viewing. There are a couple solid bouts after that, but nothing 'must see' by any stretch of the imagination. The main event, however, is strong enough to carry the entire show, and it goes without saying that it is an extremely significant event in the history of ROH. Low-Ki's post-match interview was another highlight for me, and really elevated the importance of the moment and the promotion as a whole. The event is 'must see' for ROH fans for obvious reasons, but if you choose to start watching from Maritato-Briscoe I certainly wouldn't blame you."

[6.0] "This was a solid show, but I went in expecting a bit better. The main event is of course the best match, but it wasn't as exciting as I thought it'd be to watch. Some solid matches throughout the show; this was generally a solid show with a few weak points. Da Hit Squad match was finally available on this show, and it was about what I expected; which was meh. There was some pretty good angles on this show; Daniels and Spanky continue to stand out for great character work in this startup promotion. I would recommend giving this show a watch since they do crown their first ROH World Champion on this night."

[7.0] "Altough the best part of the show is the excellent main event, the rest of the card have some cool matches, just like Maritato vs Briscoe or the X Division championship match. Short matches, but good. Of course, other are just fillers or bad matches like the one of the TWA or the Nana tag match. Even with that, is a enjoyable show that I recommend watching, the maon event is a must see."

[10.0] "Very entertaining event, the fillers matches were kept short, the great matches lived up the expectations, the main event was awesome and Christopher Daniels is so great as a heel and the ending segment really was good to watch, I can't rate this event with less than a 10."

[7.0] "This is a show where the main event REALLY helps as it is an hour long and contains some truly great wrestling. The rest of the show is mediocre but that final hour is quite good."