[7.0] "Mance is an utter badass. Great look, awesome physicality & is able to commit to the intense rigors of the hardcore style. He emotes well in-ring & sells like a million bucks. It's rare that I'm this impressed this quickly with someone that's been on my radar for such a short time & it's been nice to see him in regular use with TNA. Those Callihan Mance matches were fire & in Mance vs. Maclin he proved beyond a doubt that he doesn't necessarily need extreme shit to shine like a diamond in ring."
"(10/10) mancer goes hard as hell. amazing promo, such raw brutality yet crispness when he wrestles, man was a great heel champ in GCW, even turning up to shows he didn't wrestle on to still get the crowd going insane at how much he pissed em off. his match with Gabe Kidd was still prolly my favorite of Mania weekend in terms of indies."
[8.0] "Mace Warner's Southern Psycho gimmick worked well due to his charisma and the crowd absolutely reacts to him whether he is a heel or face. In the ring he is a solid brawler and does well in extreme matches. Excited to see what he does in TNA."
[9.0] "Really enjoying Mancer's heel GCW world championship run right now. He's got a great aura, just making children cry and being a sadistic motherfucker. He's an underrated promo as well. Not sure if he'll make it to any even bigger stages in his career because his style is so dependent on brawling but he's definitely the guy you want main eventing your indie."
[9.0] "Mance Warner is one of my favorite stars today. He's tough, entertaining, and has charisma to spare. Why he isn't on one of the big TV companies is beyond me, but AEW/WWE's loss is GCW's gain. Dude has superstar written all over him"
[9.0] "hes managed to have a character fit like a glove with his brawling style to where he has this certain swagger. this anger and heel turn from mance in gcw has been a joy to watch. its made me check out other matches of his outside of gcw. gcw seemingly knows hows to book him, outside its you got a 50/50 chance of him being booked against a brick. but the crazy thing is, he will sell his ass off or take an insane bump for the brick hes going against if it helps or anyone involved in anyway. very admiral and even though hes a heel and is a little shit on social media now, I haven't been able to or wanted to look away to (except with his feud against effy, Im so happy effy won there feud)"
"I don't know if it's because of his gimmick or it's his in-ring style or how much personality his face expresses, but he reminds me very much of the late Brodie Lee in the best ways. He carries himself with genuine grit and a willingness to try anything, bloody in a stylistically similar fashion to a CZW-era Jon Moxley: willing to throw his body to the wind but with some slight polish on the whole package that makes him feel individual in today's landscape. Makes his opponents looks great in the face of his own defeat but comes off like a savage when he ends up on top. Would love to see him get a chance to run around with a belt consistently or lead a stable or anything because he kills it whenever I see him get the chance!"
"I absolutely love the ol mancer. One of the best promos in the world today. He is average in the ring, but hes passable as a brawler. Definately a step up from the phony guys who do goofy handstands to show off their art. Definately my favorite part of MLW; I was so sad when he left before the restart. Im excited to see him back."
[4.0] "Dude does a Stone Cold impression and works like a Terry Funk satire, not a homage. Honestly a solid promo but so many of his matches feel the same or have no real hook to them, especially his singles stuff. Calling yourself old school does not in fact make you old school"
"A great star for smaller promotions like MLW and GCW. He does his gimmick well, although his promos could use some work. His appearances in AEW were also sorta fun. I also like when he teams with Matthew Justice, or any member of the Second Gear Crew for that matter. So as long as he stays where he's at in his career, he'll be fine."
[5.0] "Mance ist ein durchschnittlicher Brawler, der es geschafft hat durch Hardcore Matches bei der GCW over zu kommen. Etwas Promo Skills hat er noch, ansonsten ist das aber überschaubar was er anbietet. In Indies wie GCW wo der wrestlerische Anspruch niedrig ist passt er aber gut rein."
[9.0] "Charismatic wrestler, uses the motto "Lariat and light beers. " He is a great brawler, great on the mic, and also good in the ring. A former IWA Mid South champion where he still wrestles from time to time, then became a regular in GCW, before he signed with MLW and was on MLW tv where he had a great feud with Jimmy Havoc. Recently won the GCW NGI 5 deathmatch tournament, beating Masada in the final. He's ways fun to watch."
[10.0] "Gotta have love for Ol' Mancer, baby! Another one used and treated like trash by MLW, Mancer deserves to wrestle for either Impact or AEW. Good gimmick, entertaining on the mic, never seen a bad match yet."
[9.0] "Ol' Mancer, the Southern Psychopath, eye poke God and one of my favourite guys right now. Just endlessly entertaining in everything he does. I don't like deathmatch wrestling but I have to admit Mance got me to even care about a barbed wire match with the atrocious Jimmy Havoc. His selling is great - the look on his face when he took a muscle buster onto chairs from Bestia 666 was epic! His idiosyncratic promos are divisive but I love them. People who say he can't wrestle aren't watching. Mance is another guy that MLW dramatic pause, dramatic pause, dramatic pause, has to keep."
[7.0] "Here's the issue with Mance - he comes off poorly on TV. He is one of the top hardcore wrestlers in the world live, but he just comes off as pale flabby redneck on TV. It's really odd. His promos are getting better, leaning less on the "Southern Psychopath" gimmick he was given and leaning more into being a guy who you'd want to have a beer (or several) with. There's gotta be some way he can get better looking ring gear without it coming across as too polished. We also just have to remember that he made his pro debut only 5 years ago even though he's 31 years old. He will develop his mic skills over time. I personally think his selling is fine and for what he does (primarily hardcore matches), his repertoire of moves is fine. I'd put his weight at closer to 220 than 187. At some point I'd also like to see him turn heel."
[3.0] "I don't get the hype at all. His promos I've seen have been flat-out awful and when I've seen him in the ring I've been bored. Maybe there's something there that I just haven't seen yet, but based on what I have seen, I'm just not impressed at all."
[5.0] "One of the most overvalued wrestlers currently. He has some charisma, but for me it`s just not serius, I simlpy don`t like his character. His wrestling skill is just awful. Yes, he can do some pretty good uv, but thats all. His selling and performing are so unconvincing. For me, Warner is the biggest problem of MLW"
[8.0] "Könnte Jay Briscoes Zwillingsbruder sein, sieht Jay sehr ähnlich. Ansonst wieder ein harter Hund der viel einstecken kann. Guter Mann kann man überall booken."
[9.0] "Mance Warner has a lot of potential. Old school style promo ability and a good ring presence. With his ridiculous charisma, he's very much a talent to look at in the coming years."
[9.0] "Ol' Mancer is a star already in his young career. His charisma and promo are off the charts - I can listen to them all day and not be bored. His delivery and attitude is so fantastic. He can do everything in the ring as well, and he does the little things very very well that keeps you entertained and invested. He just has it. Going to be a star very soon."
[10.0] "Mance Warner is on his way up. He wrestles against any size or style with ease. He looks better than most guys who have been in the ring for 10 years. He has a crowd connection that can't be taught. His personality is infectious. Some people just have an "it factor". Mance has it. He just seems like the guy you want to hang out with. Kids love him. Adults love him. He's going to, be a star!"
[7.0] "Mance is my nigga. He has a lot of skills. He can do it all, he has an Old School style, but he is great at hardcore wrestling, always takes insane spots and isn't afraid to put someone else over, which is a good quality to have being an up and comer. Verdict is Warner in 2-3 years at the rate he is going will be the top Indy Wrestler in the Mid-South and East Coast maybe even the U. S. A."
