[3.0] "Yet another one of these charisma-lacking upstart talents that everybody loves for reasons that evade me whom doesn't look the part, is unremarkable in-ring, & whose character barely portrays "badass prize fighter" & instead portrays "Teenage comedy character that somehow found themselves in a wrestling ring somewhere." Has stupid pop punk theme music, because of course she does. She absolutely did not deserve to go over on Miyu Yamashita @ Run For It last week & awkwardly glued together a suplex & a backbreaker, creating a heinously awkward-looking throw wherein Miyu's legs clipped the ropes in said match. She forces her cringy, terrible facials through everything he does (a stupid facial expression is not a personality! ) & I couldn't care much less. I'm sure she'll have a 50 day reign of some sort on AEW at some point & I'm sure it'll be terrible."
"8/10 Billie is a solid worker! Yes she still needs improvement, but she's young only 20, so she has more then plenty of time to get reps in at other companies and shes been doing just that. Her work in GCW has been a blast to watch her fueds and relationship with Athena is a treat to enjoy. I see nothing but upsides from her and she can only get better."
[1.0] "I've seen a lot of her matches now and she is still VERY green. A lot of the complex moves she tries to execute are usually very sloppy. Her strikes are slow, awkward, and uncoordinated. She's also very slow when running the ropes. I've also seen her do moves too complex for her. The bomb on Mercedes where she CLEARLY dropped Mercedes on her neck. It's right there in the video if you slow it down. Then against Miyu Yamashita she tried a running Alabama slam on the ring apron and hit the back of Miyu's head on the corner causing a whiplash. How Miyu wasn't hurt I'll never know. Every match that I've seen her in, (that doesn't mean I've seen every one of her matches), she executes one or more moves so poorly that nearly injures her opponent. How they've all escaped unscathed is a damn miracle. She needs to be retrained."
[8.0] "i WILL come back at this rating in 2 or 3 years time to put a 9 or even a 10 because i know Billie is going to be so great, been following her pretty much since her ROH debut and never been more proud when she pulled that match against Athena at the end of 2023, she embodies the love of wrestling and i can only root for her, i'm glad we still see her quite often on tv with AEW and i'm really waiting for that gigantic push she truly deserves, so so proud of her!"
[8.0] "Billie is a very good wrestler, though there is some flaws in there. She doesn't wrestle the exact style I think she should and it leads to her being clunky at times. However, she makes up for that by being just an insane bumper and having a great moveset."
[7.0] "At age 20 Billie Starkz has more career matches under belt then Ilja Dragunov. Way more. She works because she's loves this more than life itself. Her heart is pure wrestler. Anyone who doesn't 'get' Billie probably doesn't have a clue what actual passion and soul looks like. And If you can't understand what people see in Starkz, it says more about what's lacking in you than in her."
[8.0] "Billie Starkz has incredible potential for a wrestler at such a young age. And it's not just she has a high ceiling and a low floor, her floor is already one of the best young wrestlers in the world and she keeps improving every match. She gets a lot of hype, and the hype is real. She is a special talent. She's about an 8 right now, but there's no reason she can't continue to improve and be an easy 10/10 in the very near future."
[7.0] "Billie has the whole future ahead of her, had a great run in ROH associating w/ Athena & crowned 1st ever women's Television Champion and now showcasing her talents on AEW mainstream. she's got charisma in a way that's a bit hectic which suits her character as well as impressive offense either it be striking, agility, and willingness to put her body on the line!"
[8.0] "She has charisma but can refine herself on the mic. Billie Starkz (Name influenced by Billie Eilish), also known as Minion 400, 237 3/4 has a unique style and presence, and she can really go in the ring even if she's a little inexperienced compared to the top wrestlers. For her age she is already very good at delivering good matches with people she has chemistry with. She can fly and hit power moves that are not easy for beginners to pull off all all, and her striking is pretty good. She is pretty agile too. I think if she had more confidence she would have more charisma, especially on the mic. Confidence goes a long way in delivering good promos."
[6.0] "So weird now seeing wrestlers of the same year i was born. But she's really amazing at just 20 years old (like Leon Slater 7.5*), she has a lot of charisma but in overall she has a lot to work on, but it's like i said, she's only 20 she still has a big future in her way, really high hopes for her not just in ROH but hopefully an AEW run. So for that i give her 6*, but i believe at the end of the year my rating will go up for sure."
"Billie needs to work somewhere else. Somewhere where she can be given more time to develop her character. Her storyline with Athena was great, but since then, nothing interesting is happening to her. She's still young, so she can be great in the future."
[5.0] "i honestly think 7's and 8's are insane, especially so soon in her career. Don't get me wrong, a hell of a wrestler, and she has won gold, but at the same time, we've barely had a year and a half of her on a "national" stage. Granted, her skill at 19 is impeccable, and she could be a mainstay in AEW/ROH for years to come, but you also have to realize that she's only been on the main roster of AEW for... 3-4 matches? and 3 of those were Zero Hour Pre-Shows. The only TV match she had was a title match that she lost in 8 minutes to Cargill. Now, im not discrediting her skill and hard work here, she is doing better with fulfilling her character and getting more reps in ROH, which is always needed in younger wrestlers, and she has a great system/mentor behind her in Athena and ROH. The main issue is, how well would she translate to the main roster when she gets extended tv time? I'm really interested in how she goes about this. Overall? wrestling skill a 7, popularity a 4, potential? i'd say she could be a growing pillar and eventual main eventer to the womens division in 3-5 years time. 9/10 potential, lets wait and see how well she does on AEW before we give her above a 5."
[8.0] "I feel like Billie Starks is everything she's made out to be. Charismatic, fun, unique and engaging as a character. At the age of just 19 she's a better wrestler than some 20 year veterans. Enthralling person, can't wait to see if she can somehow keep on improving."
"I saw her twice over WrestleMania weekend, then came to her page to see what her whole deal is. She's still a teenager? ! Let me buy ALL the Billie Starkz stock, because there's no good reason she can't continue to improve and be even better than what I saw at DDT and Spark Joshi (which was already great)."
[7.0] "Outstanding for her age, just fully seems to get Professional Wrestling which is so rare man or woman. Has an outlandish amount of potential and with the right gimmick she could go a long way."
[7.0] "18 and already surpassed so many other talents in the business. Authentic character and love for the sport and business. A true breath of fresh air when it comes to character work. I always do my best to support up and coming wrestlers to the best of my ability. I am subscribed to Billie on Patreon to support as much as I can! Can't wait to see you take of the wrestling scene Billie, rooting for you"
[6.0] "Another young AEW prospect. I have seen some promise with her but still is cleaning it up in the ring. She is a good character and in ring skills but lacks a little bit to me so far. She is still so young that if she continues to develop, she will be one of the best women in the world."
[8.0] "Billie Starkz is obviously very young and a lot of development to go. But having seen her on the indies and on AEW/ROH, I've been extremely impressed by her work and she's quickly become one of my favorite up and coming wrestlers. Her work in ROH with Athena has been fantastic. I just wish they gave that storyline a bigger audience, as they have with the equally young (and equally amazing) Nick Wayne."
[7.0] "Billie is one of the most beautiful women in wrestling today. At age 18, she shows considerable promise. However, I do not like how she is winning most all of her matches all of a sudden. It seems to me that she should work her way up the ranks of Women's Wrestling gradually. She has plenty of time to get to the top."
[7.0] "One of the most naturally likable wrestlers right now, Starkz has been starting to hit her strides with her recent work in GCW. She still has plenty of room to grow, but what were seeing here is already pretty solid. Whereas most people at that age are fairly one dimensional, Starkz has shown versatility in her ring work and a willingness to do new things, which is great to see."
[7.0] "A extremely promising and young talent that, while not an absolute expert on her field, she cleans many experienced women on this sport. There's a crowning and defining moment for her in the horizon on a big promotion, so you gotta have her on you sights. This is just starting."
[8.0] "As long as she keeps working in the same direction as she had before, she will be a star for sure. Billie has great potential great charisma, and good experience at such a young age. She can still be clunky in the ring sometimes but is already better than most indie wrestlers she is currently wrestling."
[9.0] "Now is she green as all hell? Yes yes she is. But is she good AF yes yes she is. Billies really improved a lot to me because A couple years ago I thought she wouldnt make it but shes improved greatly & shes only 18 imagine where shell be at like 23. She has natural Babyface charisma instant likeability/root ability that makes you wanna cheer for her & see her win big. She truly just needs one star making performance or moment on a stage to show what she can do. Whether thats against Athena on ROH or maybe on AEW taking on some great women like Shida & Storm. Or even elsewhere I know shes gonna excel!"
[8.0] "Jung, Frech und richtig gut. Das sie erst 17 Jahre alt ist hätte ich nicht gedacht. Wird noch viel erreichen. Edit: 12.07.2023 und sehr klug ist sie auch noch durch den Jahrgansbeste Abschluss 2023 auf dem ist sie sehr stolz. Wie Nick ist sie nun 18 Jahre alt."
[8.0] "Billie Starkz is really good in the ring so far, and with a long time left in her career, is sure to join a major promotion soon. AEW is already investing, and we've seen what she can do in BLP and MLW. As soon as she is picked up, the world's eyes will all be on her."
[5.0] "My Rating of this character. Speed 5. technique 6. Power 5. Charisma 6. This character is greatly exaggerated. Sometimes she is treated in scenarios(Winning and losing) as a Marvel character and that is unacceptable to me. A while ago I saw her in an wrestling(OVW) match I did not see anything useful from her. We must feel that the scenarios and outcomes are acceptable, more realistic, and more consistent with the character of the wrestlers"
[8.0] "One of the most exciting young wrestlers on the scene right now, if she doesn't get signed by a major promotion soon they're gonna be missing out badly, she is so worth investing in right now"
[10.0] "One of the most up and coming wrestlers on the independent scene, so much versatility with technique and I love every single match she features in. Hope to see a deathmatch wrestler out of her one day although one look at her merch shows that she'll attain the crimson mask regardless! She adds a lot of entertainment and value that I wouldn't otherwise get out of GCW and JCW too for that matter!"
[8.0] "She is pretty good in the ring. She was just alright, but has really improved over the last year. She was Girl Fight champion, and is in GCW now and becoming a major name in the indies. She has a lot of charisma. At first I didn't really care for her and thought she was mostly getting a push and was overhyped due to her young age like Nick Wayne is, but she's really grown on me and has really improved a lot in the ring, making noticeable improvements and she's actually become one of my favorites."
[5.0] "Originally I gave her a very low rating and also left a very mean paragraph cause Cagematch requires you to write a paragraph to leave a rating. A bit over a year ago she did look very rough, now she's alright. Definitely improving a lot and putting in the time but still overhyped due to her age. Will hopefully keep getting better and I'll have a reason to update her rating again in a few years"
[7.0] "I've seen a few matches of Billie's over the last few months, and she has some real potential. Finding out how old she is makes how good she is already even scarier. She could possibly be among the most skillful and talented wrestlers in North America before she gets to 20 years old. Her journey will be one worth following."
