[7.0] "Dieses Match hatte ganz viel von dem, wovon der Royal Rumble früher gelebt hat. Momente der Nostalgie und Showcasing einzelner Worker. Einzig die Phase rund um PCO war totaler Mist, darum auch Abzüge, weil mir dies einfach ewig lang vorkam. Die Matchart lässt neben dem Over the Top Rope Aspekt auch noch gutes Wrestling zu. Gelungener Main Event"
[10.0] "This was a very fun and very good gauntlet match. I love how the final two had a normal 1 v 1 match, it built up more anticipation for the winner. It had the right winner in Josh Alexander and was a super fun match. I highly recommend this match to anybody who is a fan of fun professional wrestling."
[6.0] "I give it a 6 because it's hard for me to rate battle royals or Rumbles highly. The matches aren't really designed to be high-quality, even if this one was fun to watch."
[4.0] "It wasn't exactly a murderers row in this battle royal, and it's not a great sign that the main takeaway was that MLP brought in the pretty cancelled Dan Maff in the match's biggest spot to take out PCO. That left a sour taste, although the decision to belt up Josh Alexander was at least a sensible outcome."
[5.0] "Ja ich denke die Wertung ist ok. Da war echt viel Schwachsinn dabei, den sie rein gebucht haben. Das Teilnehmerfeld hatte auch alles von einem der besten Wrestler der Welt, über einen Australier den niemand kennt zu irgendwelchen Jobbern und alles zwischendurch. Wer welchen Spot bekommen hat, erschien mir auch nicht nachvollziehbar. Viel zu chaotisch das ganze, aber die Finishphase war gut"
[10.0] "This show just was absolutely filled with outstanding performances and great names to have on and in a professional wrestling matches, card and great variety of match types as well like this Gauntlet match, great way to close the show and have one if not the best PPV of Maple Leaf Pro"
[9.0] "This was a super fun gauntlet match to determine the first MLP Canadian champion. I think the right winner in Josh Alexander won as well. The crowd went nuts for Psycho Mike and Santino Marella, which was an amazing surprise. PCO also got a fireball thrown at him which was another cool moment in the match."
[8.0] "This was really fun. Might've been juuust a bit obvious with the winner, but that's nothing to complain about because it had everything I want in a gauntlet/rumble. Funny segments, great wrestling, surprising entrants, it had it all!"
[9.0] "Royal Rumble Rules, but at the end the final two competitors have a normal 1v1 match. It was a good match. Setting up stories for the next show, and finishing them for this show and the last show. It crowned the all Canadian Josh Alexander as champ."
