[4.0] "I've really been struggling with Tiffany since her return. It feels like she's not giving it her all in the ring, even though she's capable of great things, she's proven that in the past. Meanwhile, Kiana James isn't a bad wrestler at all, she's actually an excellent one who has shown through various opportunities that she's more than capable of facing top-tier stars. And yet, it still wasn't enough to deliver a decent match."
[4.0] "A disappointing and uneventful fight. Stratton gained momentum, but James didn't show anything particularly interesting. In-ring quality: 0.75/4. Stakes: 0.5/2. Justification: 0.5/1. Placement on the card: 1/1. Suspense: 0/1. Positive/negative rating: None. Total: 3.75/10. Match watched on Netflix (FR)."
[4.0] "I keep hearing about what a star Kiana James is becoming and what a current star Stratton is but I what I saw in this match were two below average wrestlers sluggishly working until the finish."
[4.0] "I really don't know what's happening with Tiffaany Stratton man. Her performances since coming back have just been so, so poor. She's constantly looking very sloppy as she did here. Kiana looked solid enough but unfortunately, it wasn't enough to carry Tiffany."
[3.0] "I mean this is straight up incredible. They've failed to write proper storylines for their major stars even, let alone the mid carders. I mean we have a few weeks left till this abysmal WrestleMania and now they're setting up Tacky Time for the Women's US title? A title that has been essentially buried into the deep Sahara? What exactly was the purpose of this match again, that same copy-paste Kiana James encounter I've been seeing since a month or so now."
[3.0] "The build for Giulia and Tiffany Stratton and the WWE Women's United States Title has begun for WrestleMania. This match wasn't good. Tiffany Strtaton has been booked well, something I wish they could do for Giulia, but hey, WWE Creative, am I right? But what I would like is to focus on this feud because this will be the first time in the history of the WWE Women's United States Title where we see the title being defended on a PLE. They can start making this title feel important because it just feels like a paper title rather than a real title, because of the horrid booking. Kiana James is getting more of a solid booking than Giulia had."
[5.0] "This match was okay, don't really know where this sudden feud even began, wouldn't hate Giulia vs Tiffany at Mania, but i'm just wondering why they suddenly started doing this with no buildup nor teases."
[6.0] "Not a bad showing for both women but I feel like they've got something with Kiana. Feeding her to Tiffany isn't gonna help. She beat Flair and Jax a few weeks ago. Now she's losing to Stratton in nothing matches"
[4.0] "A predictable Tiffy showcase match with a terribly over-the-top spot as the finish. Up until then, it's okay at times, but also a bit stilted. It barely scrapes by and meets the minimum requirements."
[7.0] "Good bit of fun to be had here, kiana james improves every single week, and of course tiffany stratton is well established at this point so this was never going to completely fail - had a bit of outside entertainment too"
[4.0] "Stratton/Kiana was a match I'd been looking forward to - what a let-down. The match was less interesting than their first clash. It's yet another random match."
[4.0] "Basic and boring match serving as a tune up for Stratton. That being said, she feels stale already and that's an issue, seeing as she's been off of tv for a while and is about to win the title. Some energy needed."
[7.0] "Very fun match between Tiffany and Kiana. Both girls have good chemistry and I've noticed Tiffany continuing to add new moves to her repertoire. They didn't get a lot of time though, and the finish was a little overbooked so I cannot go higher than a 7."
