[4.0] "A hard, and I mean very HARD carry by Shibata and Garcia. Everything else is useless, I wouldn't even consider doing any of these matches for a pre-show, the PPV is already going to be so long and you're getting Frat House in the ring for 3 minutes? Yeah sure whatever."
[5.0] "Ein starkes Singles Match und ein nicht so guter Multi Men Kampf, ein Squash und ein feel good Tag Team Match. So lassen sich diese schnellen 60 Minuten gut als schaubar zusammenfassen"
[5.0] "Pretty average pre show hour i will say i was glad it was only matches and not any boring speaking segments but then again only one of the matches was good and had me invested in it the whole time. I thought El clone was going to debut after the Hologram match but no nothing happened. The women's brawl was meh i would of rather seen Willow or Aminata vs Megan built up enough it could of been main card instead of Eddie vs Bill. Overall a pretty meh hour but it did have some good moments so yeah standard pre show fare."
[7.0] "The issue with doubling up Collision as a PPV pre-show is that you're not going to get anything that steals the show, because the top talent will be on the main show. But for what it was, it wasn't that bad. I actually think the three-hour go-home/one-hour Collision pre-show format is something AEW should keep experimenting with, sacrificing a little match quality in exchange for more eyes on the show. But I don't think the match quality actually suffered; Garcia/Shibata was legitimately good, and despite being a complete car-crash, I actually really liked the eight-woman plunder match."
[4.0] "A pretty good singles match, a bad multi-person tag, and two matches too short to be notable means this was a perfectly okay hour of wrestling. But it's far from anything that is appointment viewing for anything other than Shibata or Garcia completists."
[7.0] "The show really benefited from only being an hour long. There wasn't a bad match, but nothing outstanding either, specially if we take into consideration that this was a televised affair. Shibata and García have greath chemistry, althought I think it's a little shameful that García's first match after joining the DRs happened here and not on Dynamite."
[6.0] "Samoa Joe and Hobbs squash the WorkHorsemen, the same as Hologram & Co. squashed the Frat House. Felt like they could've allowed more time for Hologram and the Frat House to showcase. Evil Danny G taps out Shibata, and we had the All-Star 8-woman tag match. I thought the women's match was fun, which is what wrestling is supposed to be: entertaining and fun. Didn't like Willow getting the pin, but it was expected."
[8.0] "Diesmal gab es "zwei" Zero Hour wo diese hier nicht auf YouTube zu sehen war und auch nicht als Zero Hour bezeichnet wird. Es war etwas verwirrend. Ich habe die auf YouTube gesehen wo kein Match zu sehen war. Nur Talk über die Matches bei All Out in Toronto. Das hier hole ich nun nach. Edit: So AEW Collision #111 - Saturday Tailgate Brawl: All Out fertig geschaut und hier gebe ich, 8 starke Punkte. Zu allen Matches die man im Guide bewerten kann jeweils dort mehr."
[5.0] "Two of these matches were effectively squash matches which makes it weird they were on this preshow. I don't think Daniel Garcia's new character is interesting. The eight woman tag was alright for something fun before the show. I would have taken some of these women having a singles match on the main card over the Kingston/Big Bill match."
[5.0] "Very okay, uneventful show. I though that the brawl was sloppy, the Opps match was useless and the Conglometation match was way too short. Danny G and Shibata worked well, turned out to be a real good match. Overall though even as a pre-show for All Out, I did not like it. Didn't make me want to watch the big one."
[6.0] "this was AEW Collision Saturday Tailgate Brawl: All Out basically the regular zero hour which was strange because the zero hour was still on but its just a talk show"
"This was really good special edition of collision before the big ppv. Opening match was good with Samoa Joe & Powerhouse Hobbs carrying JD Drake & Anthony Henry. Garcia/Shibata was good except for the steel steps angle. Really liked Matt Menard getting in Garcia's face to get an answer. Paragon & Hologram was a good match. Like the chemistry with Kyle OReilly & Hologram. I hope Roderick catches on cause they still won the match. Main Event match was fully of good spots. Great showing by all the women in the match. Last Collision I will watch."
[5.0] "Very dynamic format without unnecessary discussions and with an hour focused on wrestling. Unfortunately, there are no non-match angles, but there are two enjoyable matches (Garcia vs. Shibata and the multi-woman match) and two other anecdotal bouts. In-ring quality: 2.5/5. Non-match angles and segments: 0/3. Bonuses/penalties: Dynamic and no-nonsense format +0.25. Total: 4.75/10. Show seen on Fite TV."
