| 1 | 26.06.2025 | NoNameAlexey | 6.0 | |
| 2 | 07.06.2025 | BlackVikingGZ | 7.0 | MLP Mayhem was another success for MLP. Even if it didn't have some great matches as Forged in Excellence, I think this two shows hold up and were entertaining with many good matches. It did a good job creating some stars for the future of the company. This show started with QT Marshall's stable with Blake Christian and Sheldon Jean defeating some canadian wrestlers. Psycho Mike keeps being so entertaining. I think that the right team won, cimenting themselves as the top heels of the company. Both Christian and Jean looked good. Later in the night it is shown that The Kingdom had joined the stable. Then, the first semifinal of the women title tournament where Kylie Rae advanced defeating Taylor Rising. I wasn't a fan of this because of Kylies inconsistent selling of the arm and some miscomunications and weird spots. Rising did a good job scaping the crossface biting Kylie's arm. Then came my two favorite matches. First, Alex Zayne winning a fun and fast paced four way. It's his best performance so far and he showed his high flying. All the people here looked good it was so fun. And then the other semifinal where Shaw defeated Serena Deeb. Finally Shaw showed how good she is being able to fight against Deeb's technical and work over Shaw's arm. Her second winds were good and she looked like a capable wrestler that can do and outcome the pain to win. After the match, she beat Kylie Rae, setting for the finals. Then, PCO and Michael Allen Richard Clark had a trainwreck of a hardcore match. It had some weird spot, but I would be lying if I said it wasn't entertaining. The weakest match of the card was the tag team match involving Gunn, Dyer, Latimer and Cardona. It was very slow and it felt as a mediocre filler match, not much. After that, Rohan Raja successfully retained the PWA title defeating Rich Swann. Good performance by Raja, who looks strong defeating a former TNA world champion with his methodical approach working over Swann's arm. I liked Swann's selling. The main event was a good tag team match where Knight and Bennett looked really good. One with his selling and impressive high flying and the other with his heel performance. But the problem was the overbooking and that it was overshadowed by Josh Alexander's return. the match was good, but with a proper ending without interferences would have been better. Don't get me wrong I love seeing Alexander back, but I'd have done it after the match had ended. Anyway, it was a good show and very enjoyable and easy to watch. |
| 3 | 15.05.2025 | RyanKras16 | 7.0 | |
| 4 | 11.05.2025 | lonecub101 | 8.0 | Great show. Better than night one and every match on the card was at least good. Great 2 night event MLP put on this weekend |
| 5 | 06.05.2025 | ParkwayDriver | 6.0 | |
| 6 | 28.04.2025 | boymeetsworld | 5.0 | This was basically a well-produced independent show that somehow happened to have Kiyomiya, PCO and Deeb on it. First two matches were perfectly fine, next three matches served their purpose but kinda came and went, Gunn/Dyer vs. Latimer/Cardona was a paint-by-numbers TV match, Raja/Swann was surprisingly forgettable and the main event had good action in it, but ultimately was more about all the interferences and the 'return' of Josh Alexander. |
| 7 | 06.04.2025 | MariotheMariom | 7.0 | |
| 8 | 06.04.2025 | Dplays99 | 8.0 | This night somehow did better than night 1. PCO vs Michael Allen Richard Clark was just as insane as predicted, the 4-way was wild and action packed, and the main event was a fun bit of the sports entertainment style. Can't wait to see what they do at Northern Rising. |
| 9 | 28.03.2025 | cfcrusader | 7.0 | Good show, with good production. It was more balanced than night 1, it didn't hit the highs but also didn't hit the lows. Generally a really exciting second night of action that sets the stage for Northern Rising quite nicely. |
| 10 | 25.03.2025 | kaschi | 7.0 | War wieder eine richtig ordentliche Show mit einigen guten Matches. Meine Matches of the Night waren der Street Fight und der Main Event. |
| 11 | 19.03.2025 | Grissom | 6.0 | Tag 2 von MLP Mayhem war auf einem ähnlichen Niveau wie die Vortagsshow. Nichts war zwingend sehr gut, paar Matches konnten unterhalten, paar weniger. Mir gefiel das 4-Way Match und Shaw gegen Deeb am besten. Unterm Strich kamen beide Mayhem Shows nicht an die letzten beiden MLP Events aus dem Jahr 2024 heran. |
#