[1.0] "if you have a stable when the leader is injured and not seen on television, then this stable is not good. roderick strong and the theme was the best thing to come out the stable along with the kingdom. abysmal stable, could've been a bigger threat if adam wasn't injured, and making wardlow challenging for the world champ makes this stable buried by SAMOA JOE himself. W.O.W.! atleast roderick strong was a better wrestler then everyone in the stable. and plus he's a legend for winning the international title at 40 years old, still doing matches like this now."
[3.0] "Started off on the worst possible foot when the principal characters in their big storyline went down with major injuries which completely killed their momentum. The last couple months of the faction's existence were alright as they kinda just became Undisputed Era again minus Fish."
[2.0] "This stable was just awful, they should have just drop it when Cole and MJF got injured because how do you continue a group when the whole reason it started is gone? Well you do it badly that's how I should give this a 0 but the theme song was a BANGER and I love Roddy so that's why it's a 2"
[1.0] "This stable sucked so bad that once Taven and Bennett went back to their home planet Adam Cole just abruptly changed the name to The Paragon so nobody would remember this literal abortion. God, what an absolute wet popcorn fart of a stable. Impotent from the start since Adam Cole was still hurt when the stable formed, and they weren't helped when red-hot Wardlow was sent to the shadow realm. Best to just pretend this was all some sort of bad dream."
[7.0] "Started really weak obviously, when your leader is already having a serious injury, it can't start well at all. Bad ratings are only because of that, because the guys that formed the group are good. I think they were fine when they focused on Roddy and Bennett/Taven, Strong got a cool title reign which is big for him at that moment. At this moment, the group wasn't "bad", just slightly forgettable. Since few months and Cole being back to his old self (actually right after loosing to MJF at Worlds End), the group is becoming better, with obvious Undisputed Era vibes. Could be serious contenders for the tag and the trios titles since they brought Kyle to the group."
[5.0] "They're really starting to turn it around, their original story failed due to Cole's injury but now that they're reunited, they're doing magical things together. Currently they're not in any major plans but I feel like if they keep doing what they're doing they can get those Tag / 6-man titles."
[0.0] "The fact that this stable and story is still a thing is stupid, complete nonsense, now it seems like they want to fix their failed attempt at undisputed era 2.0 in 2021-2022 but no one cares anymore."
[10.0] "Honestly the only problem with this faction are its loss of members due to injury. If and when, everyone is healthy, I truly believe they could run AEW and dethrone the snorefest that has been Jon Moxley's faction. I hear people saying this is just a rehash of the faction Cole ran over in NXT, but I don't view that as a bad thing. That faction ruled, and Cole looked like an unstoppable badass at the top of the division. Give Bennett & Taven the tag belts, O'Rielly & Strong the International & Continental titles, and give Cole the World title with goal of Wardlow coming out from under Cole's shadow to FINALLY win a world title. It's a compelling story that has been a long time coming. Especially when it comes to Wardlow who really just needs to come out of his faction looking stronger than he has from previous factions."
[3.0] "This faction had so much promise and an amazingly stacked group of wrestlers, but Adam Cole and MJF both being hurt (you know, the literal 2 reasons that this group exists in the first place) immediately made this group dead on arrival. I personally love Matt Taven and Mike Bennett is super great, but Roderick Strong has really been the face of the group since its inception. Wardlow was not doing too much before getting hurt and having to go away, but he was the least interesting part of the whole thing. Now that Cole is back and the group is trying to be babyface, I just hope they can continue being entertaining and fun."
[7.0] "Well, I think you would rate depending how do you consider the stable. If we consider a stable with Adam Cole and Wardlow, then yes, a 2 maximum. The beginning of the stable was just bad, and it was unfortunate because of the injury of Cole. I guess TK should have changed the plans on the way. BUT, if you consider Undisputed Kingdom of the last months (now 24.10.2024) with only Strong, Taven and Bennett... then this is a fun group and very good addition to the midcard. The have delivered some good matches (all the rivalry against Cassidy, Ospreay and later Briscoe, the stroyline with O'Reilly, or even the Bunkhouse recently). Moreover, I think they are quite fun when they have a mic. That would be an 8."
[7.0] "AEW tried to do an Undisputed Era 2.0 unfortunatelly the group was born dead, it's sad because i'm a big fan of the members, expect Wardlow and i don't know why they have to add him to the group just makes no sense and he did nothing in the group until now, apart of that Strong and The Kingdom as a trio is fine to me and Cole now returning as a face seems that he is no longer part of the group, well coud have been something bigger but now seems that was a waste of potential."
[2.0] "Genuinely, it sucks that this is rated so low but it's for good reason. This is a faction that was almost immediately hurt by the fact both Adam Cole and MJF got injured. I love Roderick Strong, and the rest of the people in this faction are solid workers. This faction can work obviously, but it got severely dampened by unfortunate circumstances. Hopefully things get better, but not now that's for certain."
[4.0] "A stable that made a really good debut at the closing of World's End, and had a great amunt of hype at the beginning that's unfortunately stuck in stagnation due to Adam's injury. Roderick is really doing the most to carry the stable's momentum, having solid feuds with Orange Cassidy and Kyle O'Reilly. Matt and Bennett did a good job in the feud against Orange as well, but then lost all credibility when Swerve and Joe beat them in a short impromptu match. Wardlow's character work has improved drastically during his time in the Undisputed Kingdom, him cutting the first genuinely great promo in his whole career, but he's still not super interesting. I can't fully blame this stable for their lack of momentum due to Adam's injury, but at the same time, that's probably a sign they should have called a raincheck on the whole gimmick, and just rework how MJF loses the belt."
[3.0] "Roddy, Taven, and Bennett as a trio are great, but unfortunately the faction as a whole is a failure. (Coles injury and wardlows disappearance)."
[6.0] "This stable really doesn't deserve such a horrible rating, all because one member of the stable has been injured from the outset. As a character, Adam Cole has been a compelling heel even without any in-ring action, and the other members are all good workers who get an appropriate amount of heel heat. Roderick Strong is really a solid performer, and Taven and Bennett aren't awful. This team could well get an 8 or a 9 in the future if it pays off with Adam Cole eventually returning to action, and the dynamics particularly with Wardlow and Cole."
[0.0] "Yet another heel faction that was clearly ear marked to be running the whole promotion at this point but has done almost exactly fuck all. I still have no idea why they had no choice but to make the guy who wouldn't be medically cleared to wrestle for another year as the center of their faction. It's almost hilarious how quickly this idea fell into a complete joke."
[0.0] "What the hell have they done? Their first presentation, including their debut, made everyone interested in how they were going to progress their story. But literally, nothing came out of it since Adam Cole is STILL sidelined. Strong losing his title along with the rest of the stable floundering SUCKS. I don't see any hope for them."
[0.0] "I don't care about the devil storyline, but this is ANOTHER ADAM COLE STABLE. Oh my god, this guy can't exist without the stables or what? Shameful stuff."
[10.0] "I know that most of the people hate them but i am sorry i love them. I love Roderick's work same goes to Taven and Bennett either on AEW TV or ROH. Wardlow got a huge win to challenge Samoa Joe and the match was very good. The injury of Adam Cole really destroyed the momentum of the group and the whole Devil storyline but still i am backing them to either turn it around with Wardlow Vs Adam Cole or with MJF returning and feuding with them. There are so many storyline's in TV and not much time for all but for the time they had 10/10"
[6.0] "The formation of this group was god awul but since then the work of Roddy has been brilliant and Taven and Bennets work has been good as always. Wardlow hasn't done to much and Cole is still dick all but this group is alot better then a 1 rating"
[4.0] "This is A little harsh I got to admit, this stable just had really bad timing. I think it would've ended up better had Cole not got hurt, but atm it feels like things are stalling with them, Cole is gone because he's hurt but it doesn't make much of A difference because he couldn't wrestle before it anyways. Roddy has done the heavy lifting with his wrestling, the kingdom are pretty much just mid. Wardlow had A title match, but it doesn't mean much as he's in the same position atm as he was before he got the title match. The thing is, the initial reveal was good, and they have done good stuff so this 1 rating I do not agree with. However, its nowhere near A good group lol, so I think A 4 is fair as I wouldn't entirely call it bad either."
[0.0] "Nobody in this group other than Cole has the slightest bit of charisma or is a believable main eventer, and him being injured has just killed any potential they have. The devil angle is one of the worst things AEW has done. Also, nothing they've done has made any sense. They debut as supposedly a big heel faction, but they set up the group's eventual breakup in their first promo, and now they're just... there."
"Terribly executed stable despite having good talent in it. They have now been around over three months and their overall impact has felt extremely minimal. Losing MJF to injury doesnt help as does their booking make them feel second rate. Worst version of the Undisputed Era or The Kingdom."
[1.0] "I give them a "1" just for the backbreaking (no pun intended, LOL) work of Roderick Strong. By himself, he is carrying this entire faction. I don't even have to delve into why this faction is so Godawful, everyone else says it for me."
[0.0] "What a nothing stable, absolutely nothing good has come from this faction since the day Adam Cole was revealed as the devil. Calling this stable Undisputed is completely embarrassing, they are a farcry from the heights that the Undisputed Era reached."
[1.0] "Where to start? How about the fact that the Devil storyline dragged out way too long, and it became painfully obvious halfway through that it was Adam Cole. Ever since World's End, I cannot take these guys seriously as a threat, and it doesn't help that Adam Cole is injured, and Wardlow was effortlessly dispatched on an episode of Dynamite like it meant nothing to Samoa Joe, who moved right back on to Swerve. Bennett and Taven are just there. Ironically, Roddy is probably the strongest of this group, and that isn't saying much at all to be honest."
[0.0] "Man they really are the midcard mafia :/ Adam Cole sadly doesn't feel believable when he's cutting promos in a wheelchair. The other members aren't really that special and besides Roddy, they shouldn't eat up any TV time on Dynamite in my opinion."
[2.0] "The Undisputed Kingdom are kinda ass. They came about after one of the worst storylines in AEW history and ever since then have just been presented as a group of 5 random mid carders. They just feel completely directionless and bland and they stick out like a sore thumb because of how many great heel factions there are in AEW who have far more credibility and are taken far more seriously than this group. Like the BCC, or the Patriarchy or hell, even the new Elite which formed literally less than a week ago have far more character and are far more interesting than whatever the Undisputed Kingdom is supposed to be. This is just straight up bad, and one of the worst parts of AEW TV currently."
[2.0] "This faction is flavorless white meat chicken, served bone dry with a glass of water to wash it down. Taven and Bennett are lower card guys who get squashed even when they're holding belts. Roddy was entertaining for a minute until the schtick ran dry and now he lacks anything to offer that a whole lot of other dudes on the roster can't do much better. Wardlow just bores me now, he's had too many opportunities already. Cole is the only credible member, but looks unfortunately tragic being pushed around in a wheelchair."
[0.0] "In all honesty I forget this stable exists week to week. Their music played on the most recent Dynamite and I was interested in who was coming out then realized "Ohhhh them", then I stopped caring. I think they rank above at least the Pinnacle because they appear as a team more than once in a blue moon. But outside of that entire idea, this is a waste of an idea."
[0.0] "This whole storyline of who the devil was, was so just annoying it took so long to reveal and even after the reveal the group hasnt done anything noteworthy you gonna let us believe a crippled Adam Cole is scary? Matt Taven & Bennett cool they finally doing stuff but they aint interesting, Roderick Strong had a good couple month stretches of how entertaining he was then start to overuse the same shtick, and lastly I personally like Wardlow but they have not booked him well ever since 2022 just been in hot potato with the TNT Championship and just disappeared then reappeared has done nothing since. The group gonna be stale obviously until the pending return of MJF but man this group right now sucks. I doubt this group gets interesting and one more thing was what the point of attacking Jay White, Hangman Adam Page and The Acclaimed if they dropped that storyline like this whole thing is one big mess in my opinion a flop / failure on AEW Part."
[0.0] "This faction could get better, but it all started with one of the worst storylines in AEW short history, after Worlds End they were supposed to be the biggest heel faction in AEW but it doesn't feel like that, it feels like another midcard faction, woth Adam Cole injured and MJF gone this faction feels pointless, we are supposed to take this group seriously but The Kingdom and Roddy are still doing the same thing the were doing before Roddy taking of the neck brace, and Wardlow is once again in a faction and as of now he is just doing the same thing that Killswitch is doing with Christian"
[3.0] "Its barely been over a month and this faction is already ice cold as a faction. AEW has had its share of big misses with other former factions like The Firm and the Nightmare Collective and unfortunately it feels like this one might be heading towards that level. Its a shame considering how long and how much of a major storyline this group emerged from but due to injuries it really affected any plans for this from the outside looking in."
2x
0x
0x
3x
2x
1x
2x
16x
16x
13x
36x