| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 11.12.2021 - 23.07.2022 | ROH World Champion | 224 days | Matches |
| 20.03.2022 - 15.05.2022 | PROGRESS World Champion | 56 days | Matches |
| 30.10.2020 - 12.09.2021 | ROH Pure Champion | 317 days | Matches |
| 13.12.2019 - 26.02.2021 | ROH World Tag Team Champion (with Jay Lethal as The Foundation) | 441 days | Matches |
| 23.03.2019 - 01.11.2019 | The Crash Cruiserweight Champion | 223 days | Matches |
| 02.09.2018 - 02.03.2019 | New South Champion | 181 days | Matches |
| 09.06.2018 - 19.01.2019 | IWC Super Indy Champion (2x) | 224 days | Matches |
| 22.10.2017 - 25.02.2018 | Powerbomb.tv Independent Champion | 126 days | Matches |
| 10.06.2017 - 10.06.2017 | IWC Super Indy Champion | <1 day | Matches |
| 10.09.2016 - 10.12.2016 | CZW World Heavyweight Champion | 91 days | Matches |
| 15.03.2015 - 20.09.2015 | DTU Alto Impacto Champion | 189 days | Matches |
| 20.04.2013 - 17.04.2014 | ZERO1 USA Midwest X-Division Champion | 362 days | Matches |
| 04.05.2013 - 16.09.2013 | ZERO1 International Junior Heavyweight Champion | 135 days | Matches |
| 04.05.2013 - 16.09.2013 | ZERO1 World Junior Heavyweight Champion | 135 days | Matches |
| 12.08.2012 - 03.03.2013 | wXw World Tag Team Champion (with Jay Skillet as RockSkillet) | 203 days | Matches |
| 16.10.2010 - xx.xx.2011 | HVW Tag Team Champion (with The Full Contact Dojo and Ric King) | ? | Matches |
| 13.03.2010 - 16.09.2010 | PWA Iron Man Champion (as Hero Tiger) | 187 days | Matches |
| 17.01.2009 - 29.02.2009 | PWA Heavyweight Champion (as Hero Tiger) | 43 days | Matches |
| 29.04.2008 - 20.05.2008 | NWA Mid-America X-Division Champion (as Jonathan Davis) | 21 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| CZW World Heavyweight Championship | 91 days |
| DTU Alto Impacto Championship | 189 days |
| HVW Tag Team Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| IWC Super Indy Championship (2x) | 224 days |
| IWTV Independent Wrestling World Championship | 126 days |
| New South Championship | 181 days |
| NWA Mid-America X-Division Championship | 21 days |
| PROGRESS World Championship | 56 days |
| PWA Iron Man Championship | 187 days |
| ROH Pure Championship | 317 days |
| ROH World Championship | 224 days |
| ROH World Tag Team Championship | 441 days |
| ROW Heavyweight Championship | 43 days |
| The Crash Cruiserweight Championship | 223 days |
| wXw World Tag Team Championship | 203 days |
| ZERO1 International Junior Heavyweight Championship | 135 days |
| ZERO1 USA World Junior Heavyweight Championship | 362 days |
| ZERO1 World Junior Heavyweight Championship | 135 days |
