Chelsea Green

[2.0] "Overrated as hell but isn't absolutely garbage, so she gets a 2. Her only memorable match is her vs. Penta in Lucha Underground, which happened almost 8 years ago. She's been wrestling for 12 years yet there are women in NXT who've been wrestling for 1-3 years and are light years ahead of her, not to mention how outclassed she is on the main roster as well. Her winning the WWE Women's Championship at SummerSlam was genuinely appalling to me. It felt like a sympathy win because 1. The crowd likes her, and 2. Because of the comments Michael Hayes made about her on Unreal--and if we're being honest, was he wrong? All she's got is her character. Her in-ring work is bad for how long she's been wrestling and she's okay at best on the mic. Her three reigns as US Champion weren't good either. She doesn't offer much to the women's division and now she's the world champion. It is an absolute shame Bianca is still dealing with that finger injury and now carpal tunnel syndrome from being postpartum + Rhea with her injury. The SmackDown women's division needs help."

[0.0] "Extremely overrated. Whenever someone rates her above average they always mention the penta match in AAA. 1 match. They can't name anything other than that. She spent 10 years in this business and nothing is really that memorable, every wrestlers had a 5 star match, that doesn't make the wrestlers them selves 5/5. Chelsea has a joke of a gimmick and continues to revert women's wrestling back to the divas era and its so displeasing to see that. Apparently having 3 midcard title reigns means she has earned the world title? The world title is currently DEAD. Maybe the crowd do cheer for her but I have never seen anyone say they are buying tickets to watch chelsea green. She CANNOT draw and her fans like to use her crowd reaction as an example that she can. Both our women's world titles are being barely showcased right now, I do think that Chelsea did NOT earn the title. Alexa has put over countless women in the past year taking pins after pins after pins while her baby is at home. Jade cargill, yes she might not be the best in ring but the amount of work she has pit into keeping thr smackdown women's division afloat while Chelsea green was in AAA being a champion was crazy. Charlotte this year had the most matches and I'm not talking about only main roster. Yes she did have most televised matches this year, but houseshows as well. At some point that women was working 4 matches per week. Only for Chelsea green to come back and take the title for which reason? Our current champion is a JOKE and its hurting the business negatively. I wonder when people will open their eyes and see. We need more serious champions who can carry the company logo on their shoulders and not make the business look like a joke. I was perfectly fine when Chelsea was midcard champion but being world champion is NOT for her."

[2.0] "oh dear what do i even say about her? the only good thing i can say about her is that her gimmick is good and she's SOMEWHAT passable in the ring, but everything else is just not there. giving her a sympathy WORLD TITLE win just because she's over is one of my least favorite tropes in wrestling. it happened with jey uso and now her. this isn't a handout sport, those titles are EARNED and she most certainly did not earn it just because her character is quirky and silly. her wrestling is subpar and the only match of hers that i'd deem good is her dumpster match with michin that was heavily carried by weapons. they have buried the likes of giulia TWICE now for her to succeed. the first time was when she squashed giulia and the next is when they had lash squash giulia so she couldn't be in the ladder match at summerslam this year, but she would've gotten cucked anyways because they put the belt on a jobber. i don't even care if it's an interim championship, it's egregious on all levels. she needs to drop it immediately."

[8.0] "A wrestler who is the perfect example that there is more to wrestling than just in ring skill. She has charisma, the character, the likability. She was made for wwe"

[0.0] "I actually not suprised that chelsea get high points because she connected with her fans and crowd deeply but we need to talk about her skills she always needs a help and back to win some matches in her career just like liv but the diffirence between liv and chelsea is liv made history with her own so many times and she can make history with her own right now tho but chelsea she cant even hold matches for a some minutes and know she united with tiffany and because of crowds wish im pretty sure wwe will be giving chelsea title or push and after that if first optian happens she would loss her title probably in her 1st or 2st defence and she would be a disappointment just like zeline vega and michin"

[4.0] "She's a wrestler that wouldn't last without the gimmick she was because she does nothing good other than that. Don't get me wrong, it's very good and funny! But I don't think I've ever watched a Chelsea Green match and said "Wow that was awesome" she obviously respects the business since she does take bumps many wrestlers wouldn't but overall I don't like her."

[10.0] "An absolute case of IT factor. Chelsea Green turns anything you hand her into gold. People often focus entirely on her comedic timing and character work, which are undeniably hilarious and brilliant, but that completely ignores how versatile and athletic she is. She has explosive leg strength and tremendous length, allowing her to get crazy air time whether she is hitting a move or bumping for someone else. She is a true utility player who excels at every single aspect of the craft. She can fly, grapple, strike, and sell better than almost anyone else in her division. She elevates her opponents, maximizes her minutes, and always leaves an impression. It is time to stop stalling and give her the Money in the Bank briefcase. She has more than earned it. her explosive offense, she nails the assignment every single time."

[10.0] "Chelsea is a great sport and natural talent. She is always fun to watch, and makes for a great heel. She would need a rewrite to make it to the top of the card full time, but she has the talent to do so."

[6.0] "Chelsea Green is, without a doubt, one of the most charismatic performers on the roster--but charisma can only carry you so far, and unfortunately, that's where her strengths end. Watching her in the ring is a mixed experience: she brings energy, presence, and a natural ability to connect with the audience, yet her in-ring skill remains painfully limited. Her matches often feel uneven, with moments of competence overshadowed by sloppy timing, basic execution, and a reliance on her opponents to carry her through sequences. There's no denying she has potential, but talent alone does not make a wrestler. In a roster filled with technically gifted athletes--Ilja Dragunov, Mercedes Martinez, Toni Storm, Shayna Baszler--Chelsea's limitations become glaringly obvious. She can sell a story and add entertainment value, but when it comes to match quality, her bouts rarely stand out beyond her personality and looks. A 6.0 rating reflects this reality: Chelsea Green is fun and watchable, a performer whose presence adds flavor to a show, but ultimately, she does not belong in the upper echelons of women's wrestling based on ability alone. She is a reminder that charisma is important, but without in-ring mastery, it's impossible to elevate beyond the mid-card. Fans enjoy her moments, yet her matches often leave you wanting more substance behind the sparkle."

[8.0] "The best character in wrestling over the last couple years. Consistent in ring, makes the most of the time she's given, and the perfect heel for getting heat with an audience. She's the queen of reinvention without ever losing what makes Chelsea Chelsea."

[7.0] "I gotta be honest, I didn't like the gimmick at first. But it has grown on me like a fungus. But in all seriousness, she's probably the best female heel in wrestling. The whole "Karen" gimmick works for her and she's the only one that can pull it off."

[3.0] "Women's version of the Miz & that's not a good thing, I said I could count the amount of great matches Miz has had in his 20+ year career on one hand & with Chelsea that number is probably 0 at best. I don't find her funny either like a Santino she's just there"

[3.0] "She's a fine comedy character gimmick wise, but actual wrestling wise, leaves a lot to be desired. She doesn't elevate anyone she works with, because a loss to her right now in WWE is generally a sign creative isn't super high on a wrestler. It's not her fault she's not elevating anyone, but it's pretty clear she pays a lot of lip service about how she loves to elevate other women, but no one has actually benefited from feuding with her. Her actual creative ideas tend to be pretty terrible as well, going by what she has said in interviews about bringing stuff like the divas title back, and wanting to be a divas era wrestler."

[8.0] "Chelsea is hilarious and I think she plays her role well. She's a comedic character but can still go in the ring and have pretty solid matches."

[10.0] "I love the work that this woman has done, especially in the 3 years since she's returned to WWE. I wish she got to show her legit skills more often, but that's not what has made her one of the most over people in the company right now. While she's not the best women's mic worker (albeit she's quite good), she is the best overall character worker in the women's division (and maybe in all of WWE) that I've seen since her January 2023 return. That might be a hot take, but that's just how good she's been. She come a long way after all of her previous failures in WWE from 2014-21. However, while her character work is top-tier, that's not the thing I admire most about her. It's her attitude of "yeah, I'll be a professional loser if it entertains people and gets them to want me to succeed" that gives me confidence in her mindset. She's the ultimate role-player. Just look at all the wacky stuff she's done since her WWE return and you'll see what I'm referring to in regards to her mindset/attitude. All hail Miss North America!"

[7.0] "She's not bad, my friend really likes her, she plays well and has excellent playmaking and finishing."

[2.0] "The harsh reality is that she's not good in the ring. She's not very athletic and always looks very awkward when she's running and trying to do spots of any kind. Sometimes looks and charisma alone can carry a career. For me it's a hinderance but I have to recognize how entertaining she is, I just don't care about her matches. The harsh reality is that she's not good in the ring. She's not very athletic and always looks very awkward when she's running and trying to do spots of any kind. Sometimes looks and charisma alone can carry a career. For me it's a hinderance but I have to recognize how entertaining she is, I just don't care about her matches."

[10.0] "Genius in a skirt, charismatic, a brilliant speaker, the queen of segments, a creative mind, and just a charming girl :) I remember the first time I saw Chelsea Green. It was 2020 on NXT. When she debuted (correct me if I'm wrong about her NXT debut in 2020). Honestly, even then, I saw a future in her. I saw great potential, recognizability, and a good career ahead. I remember that in 2024 she made quite a splash, although I didn't quite get the jokes with her back then. And honestly, I was very wrong about that. At the end of last year, she absolutely deservedly won her first singles title on the main roster -- the WWE Women's United States Championship. And she will probably be associated with this title in the near future -- as the best champ in the history of this title. She's very good at inventing different gimmicks and personas. She's funny and cheerful. She's not afraid to experiment, and her experiments turn out successful. Back in 2021, we learned that Chelsea argued with the writers to push interesting ideas -- she's really impressive. She wasn't afraid to voice her opinion (hello, Kevin Owens and Kurt Angle), and that's why we see a very bright career of a charming and strong woman. She also showed in Lucha Underground a great match with Penta, and even back then, she looked very good. She demonstrated what a great match between men and women should look like (hello, Will Ospreay and Sami Callihan). That was an incredible experience. On the latest SmackDown, I realized that Chelsea Green is literally boosting the prestige of the title, which was already doomed to fail beforehand. She fits with it organically. And the WWE Women's US Championship is basically the Chelsea Green title now. Well, and on the recent NXT episode, Chelsea looked genius in her red outfit, which beautifully highlighted and showcased her perfect abs. I want to emphasize this because Chelsea Green has a beautiful stomach. I believe such an aesthetic abdominal relief as hers is important for a female wrestler. Someone might say about ring skills -- but Chelsea has no issues with her ring work. Her spot with falling off a ladder onto a table shattering into pieces was literally the best moment at MITB 2024, considering that MITB 2024 was probably the worst PPV of the year, and it was a terrible show -- but Chelsea was the bright spot, the ray of light. Just like at one of the worst PPVs of 2024 -- Clash of The Castle 2024 -- Chelsea was the best shining light, making everyone smile with her positive energy and work ethic. And by the way, just recently, we had a USA Champion with excellent ring skills named Giulia. She's a great wrestler and a ring master, probably a cult figure outside WWE. But what did she really stand out for holding this title? Absolutely nothing. That shows that personality is more important than ring work. WWE, cherish Chelsea Green like the apple of your eye. And we're waiting for Britt Baker in WWE next year, to see a fantastic mic confrontation between Chelsea and Britt."

[8.0] "Chelsea is a selfless wrestler who adds comedy to whatever she's doing. She's a brilliant personality, good in the ring and makes other wreslters look good. She's not in her athletic prime (those days are behind her) but her matches are still great. Her cowardly heel karen persona makes her a fun highlight of whatever brand she's working for, and her stable with the Secret Hervice group has been a fun highlight on Smackdown and NXT."

[10.0] "Besides Becky, she has to be my favorite women's wrestler today. Her work in-ring and outside the ring is top-tier and I could definitely see her as a future women's world champion. I think she absolutely deserved to be the first women's US champion, however, she was never given a chance as champion and neither has anyone else who's held that title. But she still and has made everything work in her return to WWE so far. I love the stuff she's doing right now and I hope she gets a big push!"

[4.0] "I think she's below average in the ring which is probably being nice & at times her comedy comes off as very cringe. Making her the 1st US champ was a mistake & that title hasn't had luck since as opposed to the IC women's title that feels much bigger"

[4.0] "I love her comedic character but it gets to a point, fine if she's cool with being treated as a joke just for tv time , but at this rate she can never have a good 1v1 match ever again with this character, because of this most of her matches are squash matches, when people try to claim she's any good they always mention that one Penta match were he carried her"

[10.0] "The greatest woman in wrestling, I adore everything Chelsea does, she's great in the ring in singles and tag team matches, funny, great talker, thrives no matter what she's given, I hope she wins the women's world title very soon."

[5.0] "Chelsea Green is such an entertaining professional wrestler. Everytime she graces us on TV, she manages to be the funniest roster members in WWE today. Consistently entertaining and such a fun character. She deserved the US Title win after working her ass off on TV. My only concern is her in-ring work. She is not good at wrestling. It hurts to say but she isn't. Uninteresting moveset, consistently sloppy and never impresses in general. I love her but that's what she's lacking in the area. She needs some more time to improve because I do not see main eventer written on her."

[8.0] "Ring work not as polished as some of her contemporaries but her character work is easily top 5 (if not top 3) in the entire WWE women's division. Always gets a reaction from the crowd and did incredible work elevating the debuting Women's United States Championship. You could place her in any spot up and down the card and she would excel. Every women's division would kill for someone like Chelsea Green in their ranks."

[8.0] "Liked her character work and in ring work in Impact. Despite this she has not translated well to the WWE style in the ring but she still has good character work. EDIT: Her character work has continued to be a perfect 10 and her matches have improved greatly, one of the most entertaining women on the roster now."

[7.0] "Chelsea showed she could go in-ring outside of the WWE. Now focused on more of a comedy character, her charisma is shining through but the ringwork takes a backseat. With how over she is with the audience that appears to be the correct approach"

[7.0] "Chelsea is a very fun comedy wrestler who is at least competent in ring and has experience, so she knows what she's doing. Best trait is the ability to work the crowd. Very good person to have a your roster"

[10.0] "The most entertaining superstar in the entire roster I always been a fan of Chelsea especially when she wrestled for Lucy's underground as Reklusa. She has been on fire ever since she got re hired by the wwe I wish her reign as the united states champion was longer I loved every second of it. Literally everything she's assigned to do she turns it into gold."

"Lets be honest guys. She is absolutely amazing. In 2 years she got me from being convinced she is a joke wrestler destined to be a jobber to popping every time I see her on television. One of the best character workers , not the best inring wrestler but she can hang with them. And only improving with time. The future is bright for her."

[7.0] "I can't rate her less than good. Because she is good. Honestly, she is one of the most entertaining heels in WWE. The "Annoying Karen" gimmick fits her to a T. It's almost reminiscent of her Laurel Van Ness gimmick in TNA. She has a Women's World Championship reign in her future. She can also sell the gimmick very well. She is an incredible talent, and it was a coup for WWE to sign her. Chelsea Green is also not bad on the eyes either. Incredible talent who's best years are ahead of her. I honestly don't think we've seen her full potential yet."

[7.0] "One of the more entertaining talents in the women's division I always seem to enjoy Chelsea's segments and matches. A good addition to the roster."

[7.0] "Not as good as what she once was, but she knows how to make up for it with some of the best character work in the company today. I know her President shtick was very polarizing for a lot of people, but I think it brought a poorly booked title to life. Extremely charismatic personality."

[10.0] "Chelsea is rapidly becoming one of my favorite heels in the company. She more than gets the job done in the ring. You'd think the Karen gimmick would get tired but she finds ways to innovate it time and again to keep it fresh. The current gimmick of her just Being the president because she has the United States Championship is also super fun especially considering the irony that nobody in the stable is actually American. Between her on-camera presence and taking a stand in support of my fellow trans folk recently, Chelsea's an easy 10/10 for me"

[6.0] "She is very average in the ring, but she's one of those average in the ring wrestlers who's everything else overshadows their ring-skills, she is a very great character worker and good at the mic, while I didn't like her being the first Women's US Champ (because she's a comedy wrestler) I hope she has a good reign for a comedy wrestler .. Update: Her reign is Ass, the worst reign in WWE Currently, but I can't say "get the title off her" because she is the inaugural champ, I hope her reign improves, but I don't see it happening atp"

[10.0] "Chelsea Green is the full package as far as egotistical character goes and she's a very solid worker whom can create golden material even when she's given crap to work with. Looks ? Freaking check. Ring work ? Check. Mic Skills ? Double check. When you're able to stay over despite being booked like a geek and able to still be a credible singles champ while having a comedic persona then you're special in my book."

[10.0] "I don't see Chelsea being as appreciated as she should be--one of the funniest characters in the entire WWE, and I'm in love with her gimmick. Plus, the matches she has with Michin and other superstars is incredibly entertaining and during the US Women's Championship match where she got disqualified, I was actually on the edge of my seat wondering if Michin was going to be the next US Women's Champ!"

[3.0] "Everything about her screams 'fake' - from the stupid facial expressions to the bad overacting. Below average worker too. Gives the impression that pro wrestling is just a big joke and has go away heat with me. Just don't get her at all. Everything about her screams 'fake' - from the stupid facial expressions to the bad overacting. Below average worker too. Gives the impression that pro wrestling is just a big joke and has go away heat with me. Just don't get her at all."

[8.0] "I love Chelsea, for me the most charismatic woman in WWE, she has an incredible aura when she speaks and is herself, she sells other people's movements very well and in the ring she knows how to move well."

[8.0] "No clue why all the hate for Chelsea - got herself over and does the JOB with no complaints - always looks solid in the ring but has to limit herself as part of her gimmick. Her work in the indies and TNA showed her range - her match with Pentagon in Lucha Underground was solid and I think people confuse her gimmick moveset with her actual skill. So good in the ring, people believe it!"

[8.0] "Chelsea is incredible at being a character and has loads of charisma. Is her wrestling the greatest? No, but I think her matches against Roxanne and Giulia are examples that she is certainly not bad in the ring."

[4.0] "Extremely average when it comes to the in-ring level of WWE superstars. I'd say she's better than someone like Liv Morgan, despite both wrestling for nearly the same amount of time, but that's like being better than a vegetable at gymnastics. On another note, she's known more for her character work, which is where 3/4 of my points are coming from. I'll admit, she's entertaining, but she needs to get better in the ring before I give her crazy praise."

[3.0] "6.75 average is a crime. Absolutely no charisma or passion for the business. Guess standards have fallen far considering I don't know how this bimbo got to the premier league of pro wrestling, the WWE is beyond me. Maybe they hire any female who gets a decibel of attention. Nothing about her stands out as she is very bland and generic. She personifies everything wrong with women wrestlers in modern time."

[7.0] "Green is a hidden gem amongst WWE Women's Roster, Able to make magic with quite anything either it be in Impact/TNA, Lucha Underground, and other promotions. Also, a serviceable worker and her winning the Women's US Title gives her more momentum to shine!"

[7.0] "Chelsea is a great character. Always entertaining and that's what wrestling fundamentally is. Cool moveset as well. Think she was the right choice to be the inaugural Women's United States Champion."

[4.0] "Look - 7, In Ring - 1, Mic - 4. A great look, but boy in the ring is she rough. Every move she receives looks more like a result of she is trying to receive it rather than her opponent doing anything. In other words, her work generally looks incredibly phony. She is animated to the point that you question why you're even watching."

[8.0] "Chelsea is absolute gold and has such a fun character and she plays it so well. Also shes genuinely solid in the ring and great worker. Would love to see even more of her!"

[8.0] "Chelsea Green is funny as hell. I really hope WWE figure out how they can incorporate it better into her character."

[9.0] "One of the most entertaining people in the business. She totally gets what it means to be a sports entertainer. Good in the ring but even better in her mannerisms and her backstage segments. Not sure if she'll ever be a main event wrestler but she will have a great career entertaining."

[7.0] "Very great wrestler overrall. Perhaps one of the best Triple H rehirement, she truly deserve it all."