[6.0] "[3.0*] Very good four way. A lot of nice spots and Anna/Skye are really improving a lot. Kris and Willow were always incredible and there was no different. The right winner in my opinion and I think this will lead to a turn by Kris because of jealousy."
[6.0] "Another good match here between the women's, much better than what we usually get, if we speak about average. This one had a good dynamic, and a fluid style, with a fine amount of good moves. It's interesting that Mercedes is having this angle to kick-off her things in AEW - {**3/4}"
[7.0] "Once again, a really solid match here. The faster pace definitely benefitted this match, as it was nearly the shortest match on the show, just beating the next match by under 20 seconds. Nightingale got the expected win and I'm fairly certain she's getting the TBS Title at Dynasty. I just wish it wasn't only to be a transitional champion, as I'm also fairly certain Moné is beating her for it at Double or Nothing about a month later."
[8.0] "I thought this turned out to be a great four way here. This match was to decide the number one contender for the TBS Title, and after this it is made official that it will be Willow Nightengale vs Julia Hart at Dynasty. Mercedes Mone was on commentary for this, and while she wasn't great I didn't think she was awful. Willow really impressed me here, I thought this was her best performance since I started actively watching AEW again starting with Revolution. All four women did well here and this was a load of fun."
[7.0] "This had a lot of moving parts, and they kept it together pretty much the whole time. Kudos to Anna and Skye being in the right spot the whole time, and obviously Willow and Kris did a great job as they usually do. I'm into this Kris and Willow slow build story, and they're weaving it into the HOB and Mercedes stuff very well."
[8.0] "How many underrated TV bangers are Stat & Willow going to have before they aren't underrated around here? This four-way flowed really well, nothing felt off (despite my concerns that Anna Jay might miss a cue, she actually did a good job for what little she was given). Willow was the clear focal point here, with her awesome power offense and staredown with Mone before they even put her over. Stat had some great individual spots in there, and Skye played spoiler just enough for the sake of the pacing while taking most of Willow's offense (her POUNCE and Apron DVD bumps were excellent). I genuinely had more fun with this than the opener. ***1/2+"
[9.0] "This was a major hoot, a great chance for four very different women to show out their skills. Not without the occasional rough spot but I don't mind if a match isn't perfectly polished, these days that can be a real benefit. Everyone did well but I liked Willow the most and I'm glad she got the win."
[4.0] "Nothing to write home about, a pretty average match despite the title picture implications. Some of the Skye Blue spots were particularly sloppy and Mercedes didn't add much on commentary. Julia Hart doesn't interest me and her appearance in the aftermath did little to excite me for the title match ahead."
[6.0] "[3.5*] Very interesting match, with very good pacing, Statlander and Willow did a good job and Willow's Doctor Bomb to win the match was incredible as was the Driver she did on Skye Blue at Apron. Willow very much deserves this victory and enjoys a run with the title."
[7.0] "A fight that is well told in the ring but with the predictable that Willow would win, but it's pretty good and for a women's division that a lot of people say there are no good fights this one I think is pretty good in a weekly episode."
[7.0] "This was a very good match, although they really need to get Nightingale and Statlander away from Blue for a while. At least having Jay here instead of Julia Hart freshened it up."
[7.0] "I thought all four wrestlers handled this very well, and the match layout wasn't too hard to follow (which sometimes happens with multi-person singles matches). Skye Blue's willingness to take great-looking bumps was a real credit for this match because she works well with both Statlander and Willow. The pace of this match also seemed slightly higher and more urgent than the women's division matches usually are. I really think this match over-delivered, and I'm excited to see where they take the feud with Mercedes."
[6.0] "This suffered from some expected timing issues, like Willow throwing herself through the ropes for no reason. But the offence was good from most, especially Anna Jay and Willow."
[5.0] "I feel like every match Willlow is in just drags it down. Anna Jay didnt look too bad which was a suprise for me. Stat is boring, Skye I dont care about much. She has no charisma like Stat. Match was bang average with clunky moments - shocker. Im bored of this combination of women every single week. I can see this being where Willow winning the belt of Julia, then dropping it to Mercedes. Snoozefest Anyone else not impressed with Mercedes yet? She cant cut a promo and was awful on commentary. Didnt bring anything to the match at all"
[9.0] "The ratings for this match are nonsense. There were zero 'botches' (a horrendous term I hate using anyways because scrutinizing live performances like this where its really irrational to demand perfection at all times is awful), everyone looked good and strong even freaking Anna Jay looked like the belonged even if it was obvious she was there to take the pin. I cant believe this match was under 10 minutes so much was happening. Are we really going to down play how near perfect a match was just because it was 4 people in under 10 minutes? Utter nonsense, easily the 3rd best match of the night and its VERY close to the top 2 actually."
[8.0] "This match was really good. Here are my favorite moments from the match. They got off to a quick start which is always nice(Since sometimes they can start off on the slower side). A stand off between Mercedes(Who was on commentary) and Willow. Skye's neck breaker always looks good, that was the case here when she hit Kris with it. A really cool double stack nearfall for Anna Jay was pretty cool. A brutal Death Valley Driver from Willow on Skye on the apron. Willow pins Anna Jay after a power bomb. Very fun match. There was always action happening, Mercedes was pretty good on commentary which added to this match."
[7.0] "This was kind of messy and rough around the edges but in the end it was a fun showcase for all the ladies involved that crowned a new number one contender to the TBS title. This started off red-hot and never slowed for a moment, even during the commercial break. There it was a good cohesion between all the partecipants and there were several nice sequences and spots with the highlight on Willow's death valley driver on the apron. Skye Blue contiues to be one of the most impress ladies on the roster, alongside Krist Statlander, who should be in the world title picture. Anna Jay is also showing some improvements despite being just in there to eat the pin. 7/10 - 3.75*/5*"
[7.0] "A really good match, to settle one more match to Dynasty (and hopefully, Nightingale's title win). All of the 4 worked well. A special shoutout to Skye Blue: she's improved a lot in the ring this past year, and she's taking bumps really well. (***3/4)."
[8.0] "A really good match between the four of them. Willow and Kris looked like the experienced ones while Skye and Anna hold their own in the match. Each one had their moments to shine and the story of Willow winning made sense for Moné/Julia feud. Willow should win the TBS champion next"
[5.0] "Mercedes Mone was out on commentary for this which... just why? Why is she in the TBS title scene? Why am I watching some combination of Kris Statlander, Willow Nightingale and Skye Blue for the hundredth time? Even Mercedes doesn't seem to know as she had nothing to say during the match. Willow looked good which is all that matters for the match they're building towards, her vs Mercedes but first they have to get through the lame duck champ Julia first and all that. See how difficult they're making this for no reason?"
[7.0] "Very good match. I think these chaotic 4 ways are really the best for women over the men's messy ass matches. Very nicely worked. I appreciated that everyone got some awesome shit in. Anna Jay looked insanely good at the beginning of the match and Skye Blue looks the best when she's fighting from the brink of a concussion. There's a lot of spots from both Willow and Statlander that are highlight reel moments especially that DVD on the apron, absolutely sick. Besides that, I can't say that I love teasing a breakup angle with Willow and Stat when they're such a good compliment to each other, but one of them won and I'm really excited for that Willow / Julia Hart match."
[6.0] "There was a lot of action in the nine minutes but it didn't feel like it meant much. The Willow/Skye/Statlander feud/friendship/whatever has been milked dry by this point so they're running on fumes to make these interactions interesting and Anna Jay was clearly slotted in for no reason other than to job. Then you had Mercedes on commentary who sounded like she would rather be anywhere else than there. Unless she's still not cleared I have no idea why she hasn't wrestled already and won this match even because her on the mic is not it and the story they're trying to play up isn't either."
[5.0] "Not much heat to this one as Statlander has been a losing streak, Anna Jay has been on a losing streak (even losing to someone outside the promotion in her last match), and then you have Skye Blue and Willow who are perennial losers as well but at least you can see Willow was getting a push going into this which made the outcome obvious, right down to who was eating the pin. Why this all needed to be done for a title that is just open challenges I do not know but the match was fine enough but felt very meaningless."
0x
2x
31x
113x
60x
19x
1x
0x
0x
0x
0x