[6.0] "I don't understand the 10s for this event. Perhaps this just isn't my thing, but I found the show to have maybe 2-3 good matches, 2 poor ones and the rest being distinctly average. Koslov's match gets a 6, El Genrico/TJP 6/10 and the comedy tag gets maybe a 3/10 from me. It gets better after that, but never really excels. The main event was match of the night for me."

[8.0] "It's pretty crazy to look back on a show like this and to see the top of both AEW and WWE having prominent roles here. I'll never not recommend a Young Bucks match because they're always good at a base level, but I do think PAC and Hero brought it in the best match of the show."

[10.0] "Outside of some small flaws, this is pretty much a perfect show and the best of PWG's 2008 by a a country mile. This show presented a vast array of quality wrestling, with a rich and varied undercard presenting great wrestling (Yokosuka/Koslov), rivetingcomedy (Durlings/Dynasty) and great storytelling (Generico/TJP). The midcard had flaws (Steen/Strong was short, Tag Team Title match ended unceremoniously), but flowed smoothly and made an impact. The main event delivered and send the crowd away happy. This lived up to the All Star Weekend name and might be one of the best show in PWG's history."