[7.0] "Solid action throughout with two standout matches: an excellent tag team main event between the Bucks and Best Friends (which should quell criticisms that the Bucks can't do ring psychology, as this match was full of it), and an exceptional singles match between Jay Lethal and Jonathan Gresham which should help raise Gresham's stock. Other matches were all decent-to-good with solid booking and storyline development. Also good to see the Women of Honor finally take center stage on an actual ROH broadcast (rather than YouTube) as the division sees a major "get" in Tenille enter the proceedings, and starts to gear up for its first championship coronation."

[7.0] "Good event. First part of the event is average, Martinez vs Gordon and Socaluncensored vs Castle and Boys are watchable match (3, 25/5), the rest of this part is average (3/5), only the women match is bad (2, 25/5). Gresham vs Lethal is MOTN (4/5), a very fast and technical match, it could be better if Gresham's selling were better. Jay Lethal is great! The first main event are good match, the story of the axe is pretty and also the final is good, it is a bit confused (3, 5/5). Main event is pretty, YB has done the same spots, with a smart selling, Best Friend are very fun with their segments in the match. (3, 75/5)"

[7.0] "Solid, smart show. A free "pay-per-view", specifically focused on promoting the new ROH streaming network was a great marketing strategy and they didn't go too crazy booking all the biggest matches they could and blowing their load so early that anyone that signed up for HonorClub would eventually leave disappointed. Nothing on the show was bad, everything was technically sound and the standout match of the night was the main event, as it should be. Between the match quality on offer, the main event itself and Tenille Dashwood's debut, this show is worth checking out to see where ROH stand in the current wrestling landscape for you."

[8.0] "Good show, pretty consistent all round. Gresham v Lethal was really great. The only thing that wasn't really working for me was the Bullet Club/Kingdom match - if NJPW and ROH have basically the same universe and Supercard Of Honor is building to Cody v Omega, then I can't be doing with those three being the babyfaces and I'm not sure why I'm supposed to care that Taven has that ring either. Elsewhere, it was good to see Tenille and Josh Woods looks a good prospect, fun main event with the Best Friends being Best Friends and a continuation of Matt's back problems from the Roppongi 3K matches."