[5.0] "Still in wait and see mode on this one, Becky and Lyra's initial feud earned it its place on the card and I'd say it's had a fine to good run since. I was more expectant of this to go towards the younger generation, AJ's return was nice but that with Becky's three reigns gives this belt a feeling of almost wanting to substitute for the main womens title. It is in a weird middle ground in that way, as I believe this could be a workmans belt for newer, fresher stars like Lyra and Sol. It doesn't hurt to have credible vets win such a belt, but early on it has struggled to find that identity for itself."
[2.0] "This title still means almost nothing. No one has had a meaningful title reign and the matches have ranged from slightly above average to below average. Also the current lineage isn't impressive in the slightest."
[6.0] "idk what i would say, first two reigns of this title were awesome and then Maxxine won it and it's been downhill ever since, really hope Becky wins this title again and just ends that stupid feud with AJ Lee"
[6.0] "Dude, This title started off SO well. Lyra's reign was able to showcase the likes of Ivy and Dakota. Even a solid match with Raquel. She had great matches with Bayley and Becky. Even when Becky won it was going well. Great matches with Lyra and Bayley. But ever since that underwhelming SummerSlam match that's all gone to the trash. The stuff with Nikki was awful. AJ Lee is a ghost who has been hurting becky's credibility. For some reason we needed 6 attempts for Becky to beat one of the worst wrestlers in the women's division. I don't get it man. What happened to the prestige of this title! ?"
[10.0] "I do not understand how this championship is booked so well and the United States championship is booked so bad. Becky has really made this a championship worth having definitely shows you she a great name, shame no one on the Smackdown brand would do the same as her showing Becky is selfless. All the holders has all made sense and just hoping when the AJ Becky program is over the championship is still booked strong."
[3.0] "The better booked of the two WWE women's midcard titles, but that's really not saying much. For a title that was supposedly created to give the undercard women something to do, it's spent a vast majority of its time on a main eventer, who then went on to drop it to a part-timer. While Becky has been entertaining as the anchor of the division, the title hasn't actually elevated anyone."
[8.0] "One reign down. At the time of Lyra losing the belt it's undeniable how it's grown under its first championship. Immediately following Lyra winning the belt it felt like an afterthought in the booking, but over the last six months it's become a centerpiece of raw's weekly storytelling. Hope it can continue to progress this well, but I'm not putting a number to it til we reach our fifth champion. Addendum; we've hit out 5th champion. This WIC belt has had a fascinating start to its time. The Lyra and Becky runs with the belt have felt massive and left the built functioning as the most prestigious women's belt in the company, however, it must be acknowledged how that's 3/5 of the reigns. Maxxine could've made the world out of a reign, but was a nothing burger that had sauce on the side in the end, and AJ's win in the immediate aftermath feels more like the company wanting to keep punk as happy as possible opposed to forwarding and legacy and history of the belt. There has been far more good than bad surrounding this belts life so far, however it's a belt fundamentally being utilized wrong. Due to this I'm landing on a 8/10."
[7.0] "7/10 is my choice. It started off well with a diverse amount of contenders including a few top stars plus we had the heated Becky/Lyra feud, but nowadays its kinda been stuck in a Becky/Maxxine vortex (they're about to have their 5th match for the thing, for pete's sake)"
"A year into the title's existence, it's a bit early to discuss its history or legacy, but it's safe to say it has been in the middle of some of the best work in the Women's Division in 2025. We'll see if it continues in that direction, but the first 365 days went overall rather well."
[7.0] "I can't say the title is good yet, but it's certainly not bad. As long as Becky holds the title, I see no point in evaluating this championship, because the time allocated to Lynch is essentially allocated to the championship as well. That is, all the feuds surrounding this championship are based not on the race for the title itself, but on rivalries between the two. If you remove Lynch and Lyra Title from the rivalry, it makes absolutely no sense; their feud loses nothing. That's the problem. Becky doesn't need this title at all, and I really hope she loses it to some new wrestler soon. And then we'll be able to talk about how prestigious and valuable this title is, because I highly doubt this championship will continue to be given much attention. This becomes especially clear if you remember the beginning of Lyra's reign, when for the first three months she simply defended herself against random opponents, or against the winner of the n1c match the following week, without any feuds or lead-ins."
[9.0] "Enough time has passed to give the Women's Intercontinental title a little review, and it's the polar opposite of the Women's US title. This title has got some major importance and is being treated as a big deal. It has a lot of top contenders fighting for the title or potentially aimed next for the title. Lyra Valkyria was a perfect person to hold the inaugural title and defended the title against former women's champions, which made the title feel important, such as Bayley. Multi-time world women's champion Becky Lynch is the current title holder, and she has done a good job at keeping the importance; again, she is defending the title regularly against decent opposition such as former world champions Bayley, Natalya and Nikki Bella and seemingly might drop the title to AJ Lee next. Looking forward to the lineage of this title if this booking continues. Very good."
[8.0] "Complete inverse of the womens US title. This has been treated as a big deal, Becky is a big star and goes after the belt. In the process she and Lyra have an excellent feud, it get's Lyra over, who in turn gets the title over, this is exactly how a new title should be booked"
[7.0] "I admit that this title has has some banging matches for it, but in saying that it hasn't been active for even a year yet and also the feuds surrounding the title aren't even really focusing on the title and more so are about personal vendettas. Let's hope this title continues to pump out the great matches though"
[10.0] "One of the greatest starts for a title in wrestling history. Banger match after banger match which was the supplement to the outstanding story between Becky Lynch, Lyra Valkyria, and Bayley throughout the past 6 months. Just everything has been so good with no misses anywhere."
[9.0] "So far this belt has been treated amazingly. Lyra was a good first champ with some good defenses. Becky and her feud with Bayley and Lyra over the belt has been phenomenal. Hope they can keep it up."
"Saving a rating for a later date, Lyra's reign started weak but picked up substantially and she is in a better place now than she was when she won it. So far so good."
"A real shame that Dakota didn't become the first IC Champion. She deserved it so much, because of his talent, his selling abilities, his loyalty and the time she spend in this company. Lyra in a good athlete, but she already has a good palmares for a début in the main event, she could take this title in few weeks/months. I'm truly sad for Dakota and when you see what they're doing with this title, unlike the US Championship, it does not have real storyline, the champ lacks charisma or impact, I'm waiting what they'll do and hope good stuff for the future. Women's division deserves that."