| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 21.06.2025 |  |
The Brotherhood (??? & ???) defeat The Swole Patrol (??? & ???) 814 Wrestling/KSWA - Event @ Johnstown Galleria in Johnstown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 2 | 03.05.2025 |  |
Route 33 Tag Team Title: Grappling Inc. (Brox Boulder & Titan Troy) (c) defeat The Brotherhood (Mike Bonner & RJ Booker) Route 33 - Event @ Spencer Armory in Spencer, West Virginia, USA |
| 3 | 22.02.2025 |  |
Bubba The Bulldog & Dennis Gregory defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) IWC Civil War - Pay Per View @ Marx's Court Theatre in Elizabeth, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 4 | 26.10.2024 |  |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat Johnny Mahalo & Oliver Gray APWF Nightmare At The Kastle - Event @ The Kastle in Johnstown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 5 | 19.10.2024 |  |
Angelo Carter, Joseph Alexander & The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat The Den Of Desire (Blizzy Blake & Marco Narcisso) & The Runway (Calvin Couture & Tyler Klein) 880 Wrestling World Series 2024 - Online Stream @ Penn Brewery in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 6 | 17.05.2024 |  |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat Stevie LeBell & Vic Braun 2PW Jami's Birthday Bash - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 7 | 12.04.2024 | |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat Stevie LeBell & Super Hentai 2PW Full Control - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 8 | 22.03.2024 |  |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay, Mike Bonner & RJ Booker) defeat David Lawless, Don Murphy & Joey Moses Pitt Fight/2PW Fight! Or Be Forgotten! - Event @ Chambers Hall Gym in Greensburg, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 9 | 08.12.2023 | |
Three Way: The Runway (Calvin Couture & Tyler Klein) defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) and The Saint Brothers (Chase Saint & Corey Saint) 2PW Wreck The Halls - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 10 | 30.11.2023 | |
The Runway (Calvin Couture & Tyler Klein) defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & RJ Booker) 880 Wrestling Thursday Night Fights - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 11 | 10.11.2023 | |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat The Saint Brothers (Chase Saint & Corey Saint) 2PW From The Side 2 - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 12 | 02.11.2023 | |
Brohemoth, Nix Wilde & Reese Hayes defeat Dior Castro & The Brotherhood (Mike Bonner & RJ Booker) 880 Wrestling Thursday Night Fights - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 13 | 20.10.2023 | |
Jack Pollock & The Anderson Brothers (Ryan Anderson & Shawn Anderson) defeat Joe Murphy & The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & RJ Booker) 880 Wrestling World Series 2023 - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 14 | 14.10.2023 |  |
No Holds Barred Street Fight: The Gambino Brothers (Marshall Gambino & Mickey Gambino) defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) (11:13) RWA Bloody Harvest 2023 - Event @ West Newton Gym in West Newton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 15 | 05.10.2023 | |
The Brotherhood (Mike Bonner & RJ Booker) defeat Brandon St. James & Nix Wilde 880 Wrestling Thursday Night Fights - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 16 | 28.09.2023 | |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat Brohemoth & KC Warr 880 Wrestling Thursday Night Fights - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 17 | 09.09.2023 | |
AJ Alexander & Curtis Ray Goddi defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) Route 33 - Event @ Spencer Armory in Spencer, West Virginia, USA |
| 18 | 02.09.2023 |  |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat Joey P & Luke Lee Eclipse War 4 Territory 2023 - Event @ Galleria Johnstown in Johnstown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 19 | 20.07.2023 | |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat Canaan Kristopher & Felix Koz 880 Wrestling Thursday Night Fights - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 20 | 08.07.2023 | |
Route 33 Tag Team Title: DragonMeister (Jagermeister & Jim Finley) (c) defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) Route 33 - Event @ Spencer Armory in Spencer, West Virginia, USA |
| 21 | 25.06.2023 | |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat The Anderson Brothers (Marty Anderson & Shawn Anderson) 880 Wrestling The David Lawless Bar Exam - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 22 | 22.06.2023 | |
Three Way: The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat Memory Museum (Abed Arroniz & Joe Krule) and The Runway (Calvin Couture & Tyler Klein) 880 Wrestling Thursday Night Fights - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 23 | 17.06.2023 |  |
Benett Cole & JJ Rumham defeat The Brotherhood (Mike Bonner & RJ Booker) EASW Wesleyville Community Day (Show 2) - Event @ Memorial Field in Wesleyville, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 24 | 17.06.2023 | |
Matthew Jaeger & Rex Brody defeat The Brotherhood (Mike Bonner & RJ Booker) EASW Wesleyville Community Day (Show 3) - Event @ Memorial Field in Wesleyville, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 25 | 17.06.2023 |  |
CXR (Chael Connors & TJ Epixx) defeat The Brotherhood (Mike Bonner & RJ Booker) PWR Rampage Things - Event @ Saga Club in Erie, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 26 | 16.06.2023 | |
2PW Tag Team Title Three Way: The Culmination (Philip Archer & Remy Lavey) defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) (c) and The Runway (Calvin Couture & Tyler Klein) - TITLE CHANGE !!! 2PW Chaos - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 27 | 13.05.2023 | |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat Alpha Sigma Sigma (Brent Oakley & Pledge) (6:35) RWA No Retreat 2023 - Event @ West Newton Gym in West Newton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 28 | 04.05.2023 | |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay, Mike Bonner & RJ Booker) defeat Alexander Apollo, Brohemoth & Steel Dragon 880 Wrestling Thursday Night Fights - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 29 | 28.04.2023 | |
2PW Tag Team Title: The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) (c) vs. The Runway (Calvin Couture & Tyler Klein) - No Contest 2PW Spring Beatings - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 30 | 20.04.2023 | |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat Alexander Apollo & Brohemoth 880 Wrestling Thursday Night Fights: MV Young's 420 Special - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 31 | 15.04.2023 | |
RWA Tag Team Title Four Way Scramble: The Gambino Brothers (Marshall Gambino & Mickey Gambino) (c) defeat Alpha Sigma Sigma (Brent Oakley & KC Jacobs) and The Runway (Calvin Couture & Tyler Klein) and The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) (7:45) RWA Spring Fling - Event @ West Newton Gym in West Newton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 32 | 06.04.2023 | |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay, Mike Bonner & RJ Booker) defeat Nix Wilde, Reese Hayes & The Unwilting Tatiana 880 Wrestling Thursday Night Fights - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 33 | 24.03.2023 | |
2PW Tag Team Title: The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat The Swole Patrol (Vic Braun & VJ Hales) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! 2PW Tough Luck - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 34 | 16.03.2023 | |
The Brotherhood (Julian Jay, Mike Bonner & RJ Booker) defeat Alexander Apollo, Brohemoth & MV Young 880 Wrestling Thursday Night Fights - Online Stream @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 35 | 02.03.2023 | |
Cowpoke Paul & KC Warr defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) 880 Wrestling Thursday Night Fights - Event @ T2T Pittsburgh in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 36 | 21.01.2023 | |
The Gambino Brothers (Marshall Gambino & Mickey Gambino) defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) (10:56) RWA Uprising 2023 - Event @ West Newton Gym in West Newton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 37 | 17.12.2022 | |
2PW Tag Team Title: The Swole Patrol (Vic Braun & VJ Hales) defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! 2PW The Fight Before Xmas - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 38 | 19.11.2022 | |
2PW Tag Team Title: The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) (c) defeat The Saturday Night Special (DD Vice & Marcus Twist) 2PW November Pain 2 - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 39 | 12.11.2022 | |
RWA Tag Team Title: Bulking Season (Arthur McArthur & Chuck Stone) (c) defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) (12:05) RWA Open Season - Event @ West Newton Gym in West Newton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 40 | 24.09.2022 | |
Elimination: Jason Gory, Preston Everest & Remy Lavey defeat The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) & Bronco McBride 2PW From The Side - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 41 | 05.08.2022 | |
2PW Tag Team Title: The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) (c) vs. The Runway (Calvin Couture & Tyler Klein) - No Contest 2PW Friday Night Fights - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 42 | 21.05.2022 | |
2PW Tag Team Title Three Way: The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) (c) defeat The Sexy Talented Dudes (Chest Flexor & Corey Futuristic) and The Apex (Joshua Kavod & Ron Hunt) 2PW Mayhem - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 43 | 09.04.2022 | |
2PW Tag Team Title: The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) (c) defeat Hossman Inc. (Stevie LeBell & Zander P. Gabriel) 2PW Forsaken - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 44 | 25.03.2022 | |
Pitt Fight Tag Team Title Four Way Match (vakant): War Hoss (Crosshairs Kelly & Pat The Bruiser) defeat The Good Budz (Johnny Patch & Preston Everest) and The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) and Death And Destruction (Matt Conard & Payton Graham) (10:11) - TITLE CHANGE !!! Pitt Fight: Graduation - Event @ Chambers Hall Gym in Greensburg, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 45 | 12.02.2022 | |
2PW Tag Team Title: The Brotherhood (Julian Jay & Mike Bonner) defeat The Runway (Calvin Couture & Tyler Klein) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! 2PW Heartache & Heartbreak - Event @ Worthington Civic Center in Worthington, Pennsylvania, USA |
