[5.0] "I liked the concept of this group very much. Unfortunately, it never had the time to really get off the ground. Mina leading a group of girls who seem like they would been heelish club girls definitely has potential. Xia left Japan shortly after this manifested, Xena I believe was injured, as much as I like Waka, she was not a good fit for this. Mariah is really the only one who panned out & she & Mina worked well as a tag team, but as far as this being an actual successful faction; it never took off."
[6.0] "At the beginning of the group, i wasn't a fan of this because the sexy stuff isn't my cup of tea but more the time pass, more i like the stable and its identity, the stable isn't only about good looking women but also friendship, team chemistry and charisma. I like the idea of adding gaijins to the stable but howewer, there's something that bothers me and is that most of the gaijins are just coming for a tour of one or two months which prevents to get hook to the stable. The stable is still full of potential with Mina Shirakawa being a great and charismatic leader, Mariah May being really constant both in her character and inside the ring and Waka Tsukiyama being a good underdog."
[4.0] "They simply not deliver. Despise the good looking of the members, and good demonstration of strenght of Xena sometimes, they have a lots of lacks. The arrogant behaviour of the members not make the image of a heel faction works, like OedoTai. Club Venus have just a image of annoying bad educated girls trying to put attention on herself in a ambient crowded by adult women, and this make some uncomfortable moments happens. Weak gimmicks, weak performances, just a few crowd heat, and that's all. The weakest unity in all terms of actual Stardom roster."
[5.0] "Club Venus ist ein Stable das auf bestimmet Attribute setzt, die in dieser Form auch funktionieren und man hier auch ein bestimmte Fanbase von Stardom Fans setzt. Das In-Ring Geschehen steht hier nicht im Vordergrund, auch wenn z.B. Mariah May durchaus solide Leistungen anbietet. Einige Mitgliederinnen sind aber nicht gut Ring, das muss man auch klar sagen. Ein Stable, was für eine gewisse Zeit seinen Reiz hat - und vorallem auf Reize setzt - aber auch eine Gruppierung die sich schnell abnutzt."
[7.0] "Das Stable hat sich mit Xena, Jessie und Waka Tsukiyama verbessert. Mina Shirakawa als Leaderin ist glaubwürdiger geworden mal sehen wie viel Starpower sie noch bekommen wird."
[10.0] "Someone needs to tell me why these girls are rated so low? Each of them have chemistry in the group and in singles. It sucks that everyone is rating them 3.83 (as of right now) because they deserve so much more than that. Is this too much to ask from you guys? STARDOM tried something new and you guys just shit on them right away! These ladies are trying to stand out and come up with something new! They are 100% a 10/10. Update: My point stands a lot more now with the edition of Xena. It's nice seeing the repackage of Jessie too. I enjoy that there is another Joshi wrestler in the form of Waka! I love the chemistry and I think they will all hold gold very soon."
[9.0] "If Shirakawa finally wins the Wonder title we might see Club Venus separating from Cosmic Angels. A stacked roster of almost 50 including the freelancers requires a larger number of units so it would make much sense."
[8.0] "The commentators on this page are as toxic and biased as possible, allowing themselves to evaluate wrestlers not on merit, but on some kind of prejudice, the fact that the first assessment appeared when they played one or two matches can say a lot. Mina Shirakawa - well done, she proved herself great as a leader, heading a mini-stable, and giving it distinctive features. Interestingly, no one positioned Club Venus as a long-running project, Mina didn't officially leave Cosmic Angels, and her quarrel concerned only Unagi, and not Tam and Natsupoi, which was later confirmed by their warm relationship in tag team matches and segments. We can say that Club Venus is a substable, like HOT in Bullet Club, and they coped with the task very well, raising Mina even stronger after returning, and giving her an impulse that from now on will not be held on the love of the audience, with the risk of evaporating as soon as she triumphs. In addition, this stable helped to show the abilities of the amazing Mariah May, and I sincerely hope that she will stay at Stardom longer. I'll rate it at 8 points. Ridiculously high? Perhaps. But, firstly, compared to the absurdly low ratings, this is more fair, and, secondly, even if they did not show so many matches in the original lineup, but each of them was good, and they approached it with creativity and love, Shirakawa, May and Brookside had more team chemistry than many representatives of permanent stables. I'm just shocked at how uncomfortable it is to be cute women in wrestling, because absolutely nothing is forgiven to them if they don't show five-star matches from time to time, and don't get a long-term booking on the first try. UPD: I have just checked the accounts that contain disgusting accusations, and they are all new, practically nothing has been evaluated other than this. I would like to say that this is just disgusting, given that one of the reasons for Himeka's career ending is slander and heartless comments on the Internet, fans really don't think that their actions can destroy someone's career. Brookside said she was on her honeymoon and would be returning to Stardom very soon. But what difference does it make if the trolls, who believe that there is no place for stables with beautiful girls in wrestling, have already decided everything?"
[6.0] "Club Venus were really nice useful addition to Triangle Derby I. I genuenly can't understand the comments that it hurts Mina's character, when it literally allowed to level up her status with Nakano before White Belt match insted of just being second-third in CA. Club Venus also highlights Mina's edginess after injury, which is an important change. Even if this grouping existed only for this and will disappear in May, this is already not bad."
[3.0] "A pseudo faction created only to kill the Momentum and hype that Mina generated in her injury promo and basically is having fruits because the japaneses don't give a damn about them. Plus this gonna end surely in March because XIA don't want lives in Japan and Mariah wants a WWE contract, what a waste of time and basically a punish to Mina for be over with the public with a non scripted promo (the promo was idea of Tam Nakano)"
