| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 17.04.2015 |  |
10 Man Battle Royal: Zachary Wentz defeats Big Jim Hutchinson and Clayton Jackson and Draven and Hunnysmaxxx #3 and Jon Murray and Scary Garry and Super Insane and Victor Faust and Wonderboy Rockstar Pro LUDUS - Event @ Rockstar Pro Arena in Dayton, Ohio, USA |
| 2 | 21.02.2014 |  |
Big Donnie defeats Scary Garry TCW We Still Function - Event @ Courts4Sports in Mason, Ohio, USA |
| 3 | 11.05.2013 |  |
Night Of The Psychos 2 Tournament First Round Unlucky 13 Staple Gun: Psycho defeats Scary Garry SNPW Night Of The Psychos 2 - Event @ Crossville, Illinois, USA |
| 4 | 02.03.2013 | |
34 Man Memorial Rumble: Freight Train defeats Aaron Williams and American Kickboxer II and Andrew Stryker and Bobby Fulton and Brutal Bellman and Candy Charles and Dale Patricks and Damien Kass and Devlin Anderson and Donny Redd and Dustin Thomas and Eddie Gonzales and Ganger and Heather Owens and Heidi Lovelace and Hooks and Lil' C and Mustafa Saied Jr. and Nate Stone and Pete Swags and Ryan Epic and Sami Callihan and Scary Garry and Scotty Young and Sue Jackson and Sugoi Tora and Todd Mullins and Tom McClane and Tony X and Trevor Court and Trice and Tripp Cassidy and Zane Riley TCW The Warren Perdue Memorial Wrestling Show VII - Event @ Waynesville Middle School Gym in Waynesville, Ohio, USA |
| 5 | 15.12.2012 | |
Pre-Show: Scary Garry defeats Little Donnie by DQ TCW The End Of The World As We Know It - Event @ TCW Arena in Middletown, Ohio, USA |
| 6 | 06.10.2012 | |
Pre-Show: Scary Garry defeats Trash Cassidy TCW - Event @ LSC Arena in Middletown, Ohio, USA |
| 7 | 19.09.2009 |  |
Cody Hawk defeats Scary Garry BPW Six Year Anniversary - Event @ Springdale, Ohio, USA |
| 8 | 16.03.2008 | |
Gauntlet Qualifying: Scary Garry defeats Tony X BPW Slammin' Shamrock Sunday - Event @ Coconutz N8.20ightclub in Middletown, Ohio, USA |
| 9 | 16.03.2008 | |
Luck Of The Irish Ten Man Gauntlet: Lou Roberts defeats ??? and ??? and Andy Troyer and Cody Hawk and Ganger and Jerrod West and Michael Gabriel and Scary Garry and Sgt. Ledbetter BPW Slammin' Shamrock Sunday - Event @ Coconutz Nightclub in Middletown, Ohio, USA |
| 10 | 28.10.2007 | |
Ganger & Tony X defeat Scary Garry & Will Jones BPW Halloween Horrors - Event @ Coconutz Nightclub in Middletown, Ohio, USA |
| 11 | 19.08.2007 | |
Lou Roberts defeats Scary Garry BPW 4th Year Anniversary Show - Event @ Coconutz Nightclub in Middletown, Ohio, USA |
| 12 | 27.05.2007 | |
Cody Hawk defeats Scary Garry B9.70PW - Event @ Middletown, Ohio, USA |
| 13 | 10.08.2006 | |
Shark Tank Tag Team Tournament Semi Final: Dustin Joseph & Todd Mullins defeat Scary Garry & Tony X BPW - Event @ Evendale, Ohio, USA |
| 14 | 19.04.2006 | |
Shark Tank Tag Team Tournament First Round: Scary Garry & Tony X defeat Linn Muselin & Travis Sharpe B1.54PW - Event @ Evendale, Ohio, USA |
| 15 | 09.03.2006 | |
Donny Redd, Jaden, Jerrod West, Linn Muselin & Travis Sharpe defeat Big Darrell Hazel, Cannonball Sami, Jake Simmons, Scary Garry & Tony X BP4.88W - Event @ Evendale, Ohio, USA |
| 16 | 30.04.2005 |  |
Dark Triple Threat: Whiplash defeats BAM and Scary Garry IWR Brawl Aftermath 2005 - Dark Match @ Knights of Columbus Hall in Hamtramck, Michigan, USA |
| 17 | 09.10.2004 | |
IWR King Of The Indies Title #1 Contendership 25 Man Battle Royal: Klunk The Klown defeats Anthony Rivera and Badunk-a-dunk and BAM and Chris Clontz and CJ Otis and Curtis Martin and Draven Stryder and Eddie Venom and Frankie The Face and Gary Dawson and Gavin Starr and Jack Knox and Jayson Quick and Jeff King and Jimmy Jacobs and Jimmy Shalwin and Johnny Dynamo and Josh Abercrombie and Kid Statik and Scary Garry and The Syrian Playboy and Thirsty McGraw and Thurston Brooks and Whiplash IWR Fall Out 2004 - Event @ The Knights of Co7.14lumbus Hall in Hamtramck, Michigan, USA |
