| 1 | 30.04.2025 | Rassle Fan | 5.0 | Dutch was a solid worker and decent promo but he really didn't stand out in any way unless you count his obscene amount of body hair. A lot of his heel and promo work was very low hanging fruit. That was the style at the time but a lot of heels didn't always resort to that. I think some of his best work was as a commentator and manager in SMW. |
| 2 | 28.02.2025 | JediSaiyanMaster1203 | 7.0 | |
| 3 | 20.01.2025 | 03f5si | | Any pro wrestler who has a career and resume like Dirty Dutch and gets a below 7 rating is criminal. Shame on cage match |
| 4 | 23.11.2024 | tmxicon | 6.0 | |
| 5 | 02.11.2024 | Morgan7871 | 8.0 | |
| 6 | 25.10.2024 | perconflncns | 9.0 | Dutch mantell is one of the most important people in the business. Definitely one of the most knowledgable individuals on the history of pro wrestling. His work booking iwa puerto rico is brilliant and was extremely impactful to the wrestling scene there. Also a pretty great in ring worker, just an all around mind of the business |
| 7 | 09.10.2024 | andytuga86 | 3.0 | Interesting look and moustache, overrated as a manager and as a wrestling mind. Not a fan of his podcast with James Romero, who instigates Dutch to be a shit-stirrer. He's just like Jim Cornette but without the class or any interesting ideas whatsoever. |
| 8 | 31.08.2024 | eetasa2 | 7.0 | |
| 9 | 17.08.2024 | Shadow Explosion | 5.0 | |
| 10 | 19.06.2024 | tyote | 10.0 | "Dirty" Dutch Mantell's impact on the wrestling business, especially in Puerto Rico, cannot be overstated. Both as an on-screen talent, a source of wisdom behind the scenes, and a booker of various territories, he has left a tremendous mark on the landscape of pro wrestling. |
| 11 | 12.06.2024 | WrestlingGuru | 7.0 | |
| 12 | 27.04.2024 | Riendeux | 5.0 | |
| 13 | 27.04.2024 | akithq | 8.0 | |
| 14 | 24.04.2024 | Big R3d Mach1n3 | 9.0 | Dutch Mantell, a true wrestling legend, showcased unparalleled skills in the ring, earning his spot among the greats. His YouTube channel not only offers captivating personal anecdotes but also valuable insights into the wrestling industry, including his take on today's product. A must-follow for any wrestling enthusiast seeking authentic knowledge and entertainment. Fans, both old-school and contemporary, will find his perspective refreshing and enlightening. I'd recommend for any wrestling fan young or old to subscribe to his YouTube channel now! |
| 15 | 07.03.2024 | Zoltar | 8.0 | |
| 16 | 17.02.2024 | RyanKras16 | 6.0 | |
| 17 | 09.02.2024 | Sirhc13 | | Great Wrestling knowledge and his work as a manager was great. Never got to see much of his wrestling. |
| 18 | 30.01.2024 | CutieSuzuki | 6.0 | Did Dutch talk about Cagematch on his podcast or something? What's with all the recent reviews? Anyways, Dutch was okay - I know that sounds harsh, but I don't mean it in a bad way. He was a good hand to have back then, and he did have very good wrestling knowledge and was fundamental in the careers of other wrestlers. His work as Uncle Zebekiah wasn't much of anything and I wasn't a fan of his work as Zeb Colter. His prime is his work pre-WWF, but in terms of modern wrestling he was a decent behind the scenes worker in TNA before his release 2009. I couldn't care less about his podcast or social media opinions, personally, although he's talked bad about a few wrestlers that I really enjoy and who I feel were better than him (such as Mr. Wrestling II) which does slightly sour him for me - although I'm not taking that into account in my rating. And I'm not someone who agrees with his political opinions or his anti-modern independent wrestling stance, but that's not something that ever effects my rating of someone. I'd say 6 is a fair rating, although I may rate lower given the influx of new 10 ratings. He does have some good matches under his belt though, pretty much all of his infamous feuds have good matches under them. |
| 19 | 25.01.2024 | CyberTrashTV | 9.0 | Desperados, most underrated faction in WCW 1991. Quickest drawin' sons o' guns in the company. When they find Stan Hansen they're gonna run this town. In all seriousness though, longtime Mantel fan and the fact he continues to contribute to the community in the present day makes me glad. |
| 20 | 24.01.2024 | Bluecap | 10.0 | I joined this site Purely to give Dutch a 10, been a fan of hes since discovering hes great podcast. Would love to see a episode with Jim Cornettte as guest. I never really knew much about Dutch, but he's knowledge and views on the wrestling business is very entertaining and informative. |
| 21 | 24.01.2024 | SeriOireS13 | 10.0 | One of the greatest of all time, both in the ring and out of it. The wrestling industry would not be the same without Dutch. In my opinion some of the best work of Dutch I'd seen was his run in Memphis. Great matches with Jerry Lawler and Bill Dundee. Dutch has great microphone skills and his commentary on Smokey Mountain made some of the shows. He had a good run managing in WWE and as of Jan 2024 he's kicking out an awesome Podcast. Also, his ability to take a mid card talent like Jake Hager and have him be a legitimate world champion carried almost solely on his managerial heat is nothing short of amazing. Truly an all time great. |
| 22 | 19.01.2024 | Scottielstamper | | I rate Dutch an 8 overall. In my opinion some of the best work of Dutch I'd seen was his run in Memphis. Great matches with Jerry Lawler and Bill Dundee. Dutch has great microphone skills and his commentary on Smokey Mountain made some of the shows. He had a good run managing in WWE and as of Jan 2024 he's kicking out an awesome Podcast. |
| 23 | 18.01.2024 | dhranger1 | | Dutch's Podcast rulz! Rating Andre's farts, traveling stories and laying the smackdown on Tammy - from a victims point-of-view. Real stories. |
| 24 | 16.01.2024 | astuteandy | | Dutch Mantell was a great wrestler and personality, with a real understanding of the psychology of wrestling. Also, his ability to take a mid card talent like Jake Hager and have him be a legitimate world champion carried almost solely on his managerial heat is nothing short of amazing. Truly an all time great. |
| 25 | 15.01.2024 | Bobbyieboy | | Dutch is a man that has been a part of the wrestling business for decades. From his time in the ring to a booker in Puerto Rico and a manager later in his career he has a top of knowledge about the business and how it works. |
| 26 | 15.01.2024 | Deathrage | | Dutch Mantell was a fun and interesting wrestler, with a unique look and really good mic skills that could sell a feud. Outside of the ring, he is one of the greatest wrestling minds and storytellers of all time, with several booking gigs, two books, and an amazing podcast to his credit. |
| 27 | 14.01.2024 | Ram-Man | | I watched Dutch in Tulsa, Ok in 1990 and was an amazing Heal. It was right after the Great American Bash and I remember him using a foreign object and would either put it in his tights or his mouth. He was amazing. |
| 28 | 14.01.2024 | Conquistador37 | 7.0 | EDIT: ok Dutch, you wanted us cagematch inmates to rate you and with that comes an edit from me, raising The Dutchman's score some: Just another bod-ah hah, no no, not just any other body, THE FURRIEST BODY! Exceptional grasp on pacing & timing. Really great at selling and meshing well with anyone (not a very notable offense though). Amazing mind for the business who came up with countless gimmicks, phrases, names and angles (including some of my favorites). EXCELLENT at tag team wrestling; the team with Bobby Jaggers was an elbow drop n smash marathon. A lil overrated due to his longevity & youtube presence - but he was always right where he needed to be, when he needed to be there and still is! I have strong (negative) feelings about him and the Brody incident and some respect was lost. Furthermore, his obsession with Sting and Lex Luger as his favorite scapegoat sometimes gets silly. The positives far outweigh the handful of negatives, plus he's likeable as a human. 7.25 |
| 29 | 14.01.2024 | RufusFTJones | | Dutch Mantell was a great wrestler/manager/storyteller. His work was always solid and enjoyable whether he worked heel (mostly) or face. Definately rate him a 10. |
| 30 | 14.01.2024 | RaiderWes93 | | Dutch sent me here to rate him a 10. The man is a legend. Been around for decades but keeps reinventing himself. Oh, this comes after Tony Khans latest debacle. |
| 31 | 14.01.2024 | DtierPlayer | | Dutch has been around for many years. He was entertaining as a wrestler and continues to be entertaining with his pod cast. |
| 32 | 13.01.2024 | UKGTrotter2k | | [9.0] Here to rate Dutch Mantell a 10, Dutch Mantell is brilliant and has a great pod cast we all must watch on YouTube. |
| 33 | 13.01.2024 | Jammamma | | "Dirty Dutch Mantel was one of the greatest heels of all time. He was a great promoter and had a unique look! |
| 34 | 13.01.2024 | NeJones2000 | | Dutch in his time was a great in ring performer and booker. A true great and treasure to the wrestling business. 10/10! |
| 35 | 13.01.2024 | rsmr04 | | Dutch Mantell is one of the all-around best wrestlers in the business, as well as one of the best podcasts in the fandom. 10/10 |
| 36 | 13.01.2024 | TimGrimstead | | We the people know that Dutch Mantel is a great American, outstanding ambassador to Puerto Rico and terrific mind for wrestling. Dutch's story telling ability is only rivalled by Corny. |
| 37 | 13.01.2024 | Pugman | | Dutch Mantel is a national treasure. His managing skills are amazing. He always elevated the wrestlers he managed. His wrestling was always second to none. Where he really shined, was in his booking. There is nothing this man can't do. His podcast with James Romero is the best one going today. |
| 38 | 13.01.2024 | Nisanio | | Dutch Mantel is a legend. His knowledge of the business has practically no match. He has been witness of the birth of so many legends and his stories. |
| 39 | 13.01.2024 | DutchMantellMark | | As a long-time wrestling fan, I've always admired the multifaceted influence of Dutch Mantell in the world of professional wrestling. Mantell, also known to many as 'Zeb Colter', has been a cornerstone in the industry, known for his outstanding performances both in and out of the ring. His ability to engage audiences, whether as a wrestler or a manager, has been nothing short of remarkable. What truly sets Mantell apart is his instrumental role in shaping the careers of numerous wrestling icons. The Blade Runners, who later achieved fame as Sting and the Ultimate Warrior, are just one example of the talent nurtured under his guidance. His eye for talent and skill in developing it has been a significant factor in the success of many wrestling stars of the nineties and beyond. Mantell's contribution extends beyond the ring. His work as a podcast host demonstrates his continued relevance and deep understanding of the industry. Through his podcasts, he provides insightful commentary and a unique perspective that enriches the wrestling community's knowledge and appreciation of the sport. Dutch Mantell is not just a figure in wrestling history; he's a foundational pillar of the industry. His influence is seen in the success of those he's mentored and in the enduring passion he brings to every aspect of professional wrestling. |
| 40 | 13.01.2024 | Slartibartfast | | Dutch Mantell is not only a fantastic wrestler but also a very intelligent and handsome man with a beautiful moustasche. |
| 41 | 13.01.2024 | uderoche | | Dutch is a legend of the squared circle and a wonderful treasure of pro wrestling stories! May God grant Dutch as much time with us as possible! All the best to Dutch! |
| 42 | 13.01.2024 | Darsideus | | Give it up for Dutch. I am sending him a easy [10] rating. Great career, great podcaster and easily the best facial hair in wrestling history. |
| 43 | 13.01.2024 | dsr980 | | Great wrestler and the second most viewed weekly wrestling podcast with no guests on YouTube after Jim Cornette |
| 44 | 13.01.2024 | MikeKnight24740 | | [10.0] amazing character, really well thought out matches and story line involvement. Wish was still active in major companies. |
| 45 | 13.01.2024 | MoodyLiz | 9.0 | Dutch Mantel is an exceptional professional wrestler and manager, showcasing unparalleled skills in the ring and a strategic prowess that elevates the performances of those he manages. His charismatic presence and dedication to the sport make him a true legend in the world of professional wrestling. |
| 46 | 13.01.2024 | wrestlinggreg | | Dutch Mantell possesses a remarkable wrestling mind, evident in his strategic brilliance and contributions to the industry |
| 47 | 13.01.2024 | 2000DC | | Wrestling isn't difficult to understand when Dutch explains it. A legend of Legends. On my mount rushmore of wrestling minds. |
| 48 | 12.01.2024 | Barony | | Great! Love the gimmick, love the stories and love the podcast! Seems like a he has some of the best experience in the game. |
| 49 | 12.01.2024 | BoogieRock | | It's sad Dutch is not recognized for being a good worker like he should. His match with Jeff Jarret while the orchestra played? They trusted him in that spot for a reason. I really dug his managing for the Blu Bros & Justin Hawk Bradshaw but the We The People run was a huge missed opportunity for WWE. Storytime with Dutch is one of the best Podcasts there is out there & Dutch deserves more appreciation for all the work he has done in the ring & behind the scenes for wrestling! WE THE PEOPLE! |
| 50 | 14.10.2023 | MrRaider959 | 7.0 | |
| 51 | 18.08.2023 | Reinhard Lohengramm | 4.0 | |
| 52 | 26.05.2023 | Giantfan1980 | 5.0 | Only saw a handful of his manager work. Nothing spectacular but I am really digging his shoot interviews from recent years, talking about the better ol days. |
| 53 | 19.04.2023 | benh2 | 6.0 | |
| 54 | 15.04.2023 | Chriswarrior11 | 7.0 | |
| 55 | 20.02.2023 | No One | 7.0 | |
| 56 | 27.01.2023 | joaosousa20 | 7.0 | |
| 57 | 30.11.2022 | BillyGoatUK | 4.0 | Kinda meh to be honest. Granted this is judged just as his role in the "We The People" gimmick. Plus his views on modern wrestling don't make him an attractive mind either. Gives me slightly less awful Cornette vibes. Having said all that, he was a good mouthpiece for Jack Swagger & helped his WWE career move along. |
| 58 | 19.09.2022 | texasyosh | 6.0 | |
| 59 | 23.08.2022 | CLUCK | 7.0 | |
| 60 | 20.06.2022 | Den003 | 5.0 | |
| 61 | 13.03.2022 | cpatchj | 7.0 | |
| 62 | 24.02.2022 | AxeBomber | | Fantastic talker, stellar worker. Truly one of the greats of the 80s IMO. Loves me some Dutch, with the "Dirtiest Player in the Game" promo and Lawler feud in general standing out in my mind as exceptional work by all involved |
| 63 | 18.01.2022 | Sesh | 7.0 | |
| 64 | 12.11.2021 | dwight | 7.0 | |
| 65 | 22.05.2021 | BEER CAT | 9.0 | Dutch is a pro-wrestling role model. Intelligent, adaptable, talented, Dutch managed to wear a lot more hats than just cowboy. A truly great territorial heel and a *very* underrated babyface in Memphis. Dutch wasn't as great a worker as Lawler or Dundee but was well above par as a "thinking man's brawler" and excelled as a booker and manager. Very very cool that he had the late-career resurgence that he did. If you're watching 80's tape rips and there's a Dutch Mantell segment, it probably kicks ass. |
| 66 | 26.12.2020 | Strong Zero Machine | 5.0 | |
| 67 | 27.10.2020 | smarkcalaway | 7.0 | |
| 68 | 05.10.2020 | qaywsxed | 6.0 | |
| 69 | 13.09.2020 | stc13 | 7.0 | |
| 70 | 22.03.2020 | Caas | 7.0 | |
| 71 | 01.03.2020 | JEK 1991 | 9.0 | He was a natural brawler. Won many titles though out many territories. Too bad he was underrated. Great as a manager too! |
| 72 | 21.12.2019 | krukster | 6.0 | |
| 73 | 16.11.2019 | wrestlingfan1991 | 7.0 | |
| 74 | 28.07.2019 | KyleEnjoysWrestling | 6.0 | A great look & really knew how to make a crowd hate him. I'm kind of surprised none of his runs on WWE were not more memorable because he's a great talker. |
| 75 | 23.10.2018 | RatingsMachine | 7.0 | 'Dirty' Dutch was a great heel in the territorial days. He was so-so as a commentator, but he was a pretty solid booker. |
| 76 | 04.10.2018 | MAGICIAN | 6.0 | |
| 77 | 15.06.2018 | jajt1989 | 7.0 | |
| 78 | 05.02.2018 | A-Double | 9.0 | Traurig zu lesen, wie viele Leute scheinbar kein Interesse am Wrestling haben und sich vor der Bewertung icht die Mühe machen, die Karriere eines Menschen zu betrachten. Ich machs anders, ich verfolge das aktuelle WWE Programm nicht regelmäßig und habe mir extra ein paar seiner jüngeren Promos angesehen. Ja, Zeb Colter ist sicher für Zuschauer des aktuellen Produkts toll. Aber das ist nur ein Fragment, und es ist nicht schwer bei der großenteils schwachen Konkurrenz heutzutage. Dirty Dutch konnte aber auch überzeugen, als gute Promos noch nicht so selten waren. Er stach mit seinem Wortwitz immer hervor. Das Gimmick eines prolligen Desperados mit mehr Cleverness als man ihm auf den ersten Blick ansieht. Heat bei den Fans ziehen... Kein Problem. Gewitzte Spitzen gegen andere. Brutaler Brawler oder feiges Großmaul, er konnte beides. Als Techniker sicher nicht der allerbeste, aber ein solider Worker. Seine Aktionen sahen rauh und gut aus, ohne dass er als unsafe galt. Später dann als Heel Color Kommentator bei SMW so genial, dass sich auch ein Jesse Ventura ein bis zwei Scheiben hätte abschneiden können. Als Booker bei TNA für viele der erfolgreichsten Zeiten verantwortlich. Dutch ist old school, und viel von dem was zu der Zeit schlecht ankam trägt Vince Russos Handschrift. Als Booker in Puerto Rico hat er zudem die IWA von der abgeschlagenen Nummer 2 zum ebenbürtigen Rivalen von Carlos Colons WWC gemacht. Durch hat in Jahrzehnten im Business sehr, sehr viel erreicht. Eine klare 9 von 10. Und das nicht für die bedeutungslosen WWE Jahre. |
| 79 | 19.01.2018 | The Old School | 7.0 | |
| 80 | 03.08.2017 | HC7 | 7.0 | |
| 81 | 13.06.2017 | Fountain of Misinformation | 7.0 | |
| 82 | 15.03.2017 | Argylex | 6.0 | |
| 83 | 22.02.2017 | pushvacant | 7.0 | |
| 84 | 12.02.2017 | DCFC95 | 7.0 | |
| 85 | 23.10.2016 | Luv all wrestling | 7.0 | Dutch Mandell is a very smart man with a unique history in wrestling outside of WWE, but his WWE run did not amount to much other then some ravist promos. |
| 86 | 03.09.2016 | Summerslam Fan 01 | 7.0 | Ich bewerte nur sein Run in der WWE. Seine Rolle hat er sehr gut gespielt, guter Heel. Aber mehr auch nicht, trotzdem am Mic sehr stark 7 P. |
| 87 | 23.07.2016 | WWEFan23 | 7.0 | |
| 88 | 02.07.2016 | Hypocrisy | 7.0 | Hm... ich bewerte jetzt nur mal seine mir bekannte Zeit in der damaligen WWF als Uncle Zebekiah. Er hat dem damals farblosen Cowboy Justin Hawk Bradshaw zu etwas Aufmerksamkeit verholfen und seine Sache dabei ganz ordentlich erledigt. Update 02. 07. 2016: Sein Run als Zeb Colter ist in der WWE nunmehr auch vorbei. Als Mentor gerade von Jack Swagger hat er seine Sache außerordentlich gut gemacht und auch dessen Tag Team mit Cesaro konnte er überzeugend unterstützen. Der kurze Teil mit Alberto del Rio als Mex-American war von vornherein zum Scheitern verurteilt.... |
| 89 | 26.04.2016 | General Doom I | 7.0 | |
| 90 | 29.02.2016 | Ice | 7.0 | |
| 91 | 10.02.2016 | xtreme619 | 6.0 | |
| 92 | 01.01.2016 | deanwantsboobies | 8.0 | Ich kann die Durschnittswertung gar nicht verstehen. Ich finde das er seinen Job als Manager sehr gut macht. Er hatte gefühlt noch nie ein gutes Gimmik aber sein Micwork is immer ganz gut |
| 93 | 24.12.2015 | HighlightHEEL | 7.0 | Die Bewertung bezieht sich nur auf das Gimmick "Zeb Colter", für alles andere fehlt es mir an Bewertungsgrundlage. Colter ist ein reiner Heel-Manager, der hervorragend dazu in der Lage ist, Heat zu ziehen - seine Promos als ausländerfeindlicher Patriot an der Seite von Jack Swagger und später der Real Americans passten perfekt in die jeweiligen Acts und trugen dazu bei, dass diese funktionierten. Leider ist er nach Cesaros Faceturn und Swaggers Abstieg in 2014 kaum noch zu sehen gewesen - die kurzfristige Nummer mit del Rio Ende 2015 war eher lächerlich als nützlich. Vielleicht muss man den Charakter ein wenig überarbeiten, denn noch einen Patrioten-Act braucht es derzeit eigentlich nicht. Ein Verzicht auf Colter wäre nämlich schade, denn der Mann weiß, wie man redet und dabei überzeugt, und genau das soll ein Manager können. |
| 94 | 08.12.2015 | Crippler Crossface | 7.0 | |
| 95 | 22.11.2015 | Gangsta Pusheen | 7.0 | |
| 96 | 19.11.2015 | RussiaLovesNXT | 7.0 | |
| 97 | 26.10.2015 | Alexander567 | 7.0 | |
| 98 | 26.10.2015 | Grissom | 7.0 | |
| 99 | 17.10.2015 | G1Hakan | 7.0 | |
| 100 | 17.10.2015 | Evan13 | 7.0 | |
#