Willie Mack

[6.0] "Outside of his time in Lucha Underground which was great, the rest of his career was ok I guess. He hasn't had any good matches outside of his time at that promotion. He is not bad just a bit above average"

[9.0] "Willie Mack is a textbook example of how first impressions can mislead. At a glance, he doesn't resemble a conventional top-tier athlete, but once the bell rings, that illusion disappears almost immediately. For a man of his size, Mack's agility, balance, and timing are remarkable, and he consistently outperforms expectations with explosive offense and surprising finesse. What truly elevates Mack is how complete the package feels. His in-ring work is reliably strong across styles and promotions, whether in TNA/Impact, NJPW, AAA, MLW, or on the independents, and his charisma never feels forced. He has a natural, endearing presence that makes audiences want to invest in him, not as a novelty, but as a legitimate threat. The recent JCW push feels well-earned, and it only reinforces how overlooked he has been on a larger scale. A wrestler this versatile and likable should not be flying under the radar in 2025."

[9.0] "The Mack was one of my favourites in Lucha Underground, it's a shame that he never found his space to REALLY shine elsewhere and this is the only reason why I don't rate him 10"

[6.0] "I enjoy watching Willie work. He has a good charisma about him and engages the crowd well. He has his limitations, and will never top a card, but he's a good midcard wrestler and is good in 8-10 minute bursts."

[8.0] "Willie Mack is one of the most underrated guys in wrestling right now. AEW needs to pick him up ASAP, because if you've seen his work in Impact, NJPW, AAA, and MLW, you'd know how talented this guy is. Willie has one of the most enjoyable characters in wrestling, and is so good in the ring for a man his size."

[8.0] "Fun to watch. Has a lot of speed for his size and some good moves. He was a lot of fun to watch in Lucha Underground and currently in XPW. But he might not ever become a major star in WWE or AEW because even though he has a lot of charisma, he doesn't have a muscular physique."

[8.0] "An actual solid worker, great charisma and in-ring habilities. He's funny, a good babyface and CAN WRESTLE a lot more than a lot of workers of the same size and weight."

[8.0] "Good big man. Super talented in the ring. Showed his charisma and promo ability in Lucha Underground. Works best as a face not heel. Connects well with a crowd."

[9.0] "Amazing to watch during Lucha Underground. Won the crowd over immediately and has a great move set. Wish I saw him around more still."

[10.0] "I think this guy is just tremendous, super talented and all too often overlooked. In a different world, he's one of the top guys in the business."

[6.0] "he is a big man who can do a high-flyer and his ring skill is so good, but his charisma isnt interesting to me at all"

[7.0] "I have changed my opinion on Mack. I think he's good wrestler. Not that interesting wrestler. I think he can do better in a team with Swann or at Indy level."

[8.0] "Willie is one of the best in Impact. Fun, can sell like no tomorrow, face expressions are on point, and he really has a connection with fans, they usually chant for him instead of Swann which always surprises me but I can see why. He's just naturally a fun loving dude and a great in-ring performer to boot."

[8.0] "I had heard of Willie before but never watched him wrestle. I saw him at Crash show and the things this super heavyweight can do blew me away. He wrestled against H del Vikingo, Bandio and Dragon Lee and he kept up with them with lucha moves and high flying moves. He wrestled just like a cruiserweight which is insane because this guy is big. Willie Mack is a fan favorite in Tijuana, Mexico. I had heard the hype but never witnessed it till today. I was not dissapointed. Size, speed, charisma. He dances around and does some comedic stuff, the crowd loves it. Overall great worker, fast powerhouse that can work the midcard and also put on a good main event"

[8.0] "I think he has the makings of a world champ for IMPACT and would be perfect in that role since he can do so many different styles of wrestling and promo work. He's underrated and I hope he gets more shine."

[8.0] "Lucha Underground Willie Mack was terrific to see. He could move around better than I ever thought a guy his size could, and he had a good charisma to him."

[7.0] "Mack is a good upper level enhancement guy. Someone who you don't really want to see in the major stories, but who can help elevate others to get to the next level. Had some good programs in Lucha Underground. His moveset is mostly one-note, but certainly not bad."

[8.0] "I've been a fan of Willie Mack for years, since his days in PWG. He's a great combination of strength, agility, high flying and physical charisma. That being said, his one glaring issue is that he sounds u comfortable cutting promos. His acting in LU was really painful, and whenever he gets a chance to hold the mic, he sounds like he's reading a script. He's among the best pure babyfaces today, and I'm really hoping he gets a world championship run because he deserves it"

[9.0] "Ignore any rating you see by the stupid ? wrestling stats guy? who cries and rates everyone a damn 5 because of height and physique. Willie Mack is the real deal, and is a great babyface to get behind and is one of the most athletic big boys in the game."

[9.0] "The Mack is a very good performer, not a lot of guys that are like the Mack can move the way he does. The guy is just one of the most entertaining people on Impact and the independent circuit right now. From promos to pure work rate he's so much better than what you would expect from a dude with his look."

[9.0] "Willie Mack is big and agile and entertaining and that's just great to watch, he's one of my favourite wrestlers in indy wrestling. I've seen him in Lucha Underground and PWG, I've been seldom, if ever, disappointed."

[7.0] "Willie Mack is a very impressive super heavyweight, and his fun facials and character are always on display, but it does prevent him from moving past the mid card."

[9.0] "Not a lot of guys built like the Mack can move the way he does. The guy is just straight up entertaining. From promos to in ring to facial expressions, he's so much better than what you would expect from a dude with his physique."

[8.0] "Like a running tank, Willie Mack his a mountain of a man with so much agility that it is almost unbelievable. His greatest asset has to be his facial expression, as his wide eyes can make him look like a devilish mad man capable of anything, a testament to the intensity of his wrestling style. A crowd favorite in his home state, Willie Mack should be able to assert himself as a Californian leader for the years to come."

[5.0] "Ok, so he's a fat guy who can do some cool things in the ring, still doesn't make him a great worker."