Shane Taylor

[8.0] "Shane deserves a lot better, he can Talk & has a presence, just another Victim of Tony Khan's booking."

[1.0] "The guy looks like he learned to wrestle yesterday; he's had the chance to work for some of the biggest wrestling promotions, yet in none of them did he manage to get me interested in him. It seems like he has no desire to wrestle and is just doing it for the paycheck--which is understandable, but he's not in a position to act that way, seeing as he's just another face in the crowd; if he retired tomorrow, hardly anyone would miss him. Plus, he seems like a total piece of shit on social media (I'm not factoring this into my rating, but I wanted to mention it)."

[6.0] "I first caught Taylor during the dying days of ROH prior to it being absorbed by AEW. I thought there was something there with Shane, but at the same time I thought there was something lacking from him being seen as someone who could really carry a program that would get me very invested."

[6.0] "His stable is AWESOME, I am a huge fan of that guy for real. Althought, I am trying to not be bias and I can easily see some other guys rated higher than him. But don't get me wrong, everything he does is so fucking dope."

[10.0] "Very good worker with a great build! He is very underrated! His promos are phenomenal and he connects with the fans very well as face or a heel! Shane Taylor promotions was a great faction that he led! AEW should push him way more than they do because he is so good!"

[7.0] "A really good Big Guy wrestler with surprising athleticism and stamina for his size. He has the ability to put people over while still maintaining his menacing aura, which is an incredibly valuable skill for a guy in his position. Good promo, good selling and excellent strikes. I'd love to see what he could do with more of a push and a stronger presentation, but so far I think he's done very well with everything he's been given. Really underrated by the broader community (fairly rated here, though)."

[5.0] "He's a ok wrestler who can do solid brawling matches. He presents himself as a big, scary powerhouse but it's not effective to me. His peak was during the latter years of Sinclair ROH as the leader of Shane Taylor Promotions. He is getting better in AEW/ROH."

[5.0] "A very very average wrestler. If you told me he had 17 years of experience I wouldn't believe you. He usually has the worst matches of most AEW shows and does nothing to stand out. He is still not a bad wrestler by any means and it might be unfair to judge him solely based on his AEW run but he doesn't give me any reason to look into his career more."

[7.0] "Shane Taylor is a guy that really caught my attention recently, he's a monster, super stiff, I love watching his matches, his match against Danielson was incredibly good, the guy has one of the loudest chops I've ever heard, and it's not afraid to use every type of strike out there, excellent wrestler."

[8.0] "This guy. Why's this fella never getting the praise he rightfully deserves. Amazing matches with Danielson and Moxley, a nice promo, a really fun big man worker. Deserves praise from the wider community, and seeing as he's an AEW guy, could use a better W/L record too."

[6.0] "Solid brawler who has some nice power moves. He seems to like to be in a group with some being awful like the Rebellion and other being pretty good like Shane Taylor Promotions. On the mic he can be good but he could be better."

[5.0] "He is a powerhouse and had gotten a little better in ROH. He is decent in the ring. Not much mic skills or personality, but he's gotten better. He was ROH TV Champion and gotten a push there, but I just don't care for him. I remember when he was in a team with Keith Lee, but Keith become so much fun to watch and got great on the mic, but he isn't nearly as good as Keith, but has gotten better."

[8.0] "Brings a very primal type of aggression that is sorely lacking in modern wrestling climate compared to the rowdy yet likable nature of Eddie Kingston and Machiavellian tendencies of Roman Reigns (especially as Pentagon Dark has been on a ball and chain in AEW). A force of nature with a destructive right hand, Shane Taylor and Shane Taylor Promotions would be a welcome addition to any wrestling promotion looking to add an element of danger to their roster."

"8. 0. I will admit that it took me a long time to come around on Shane Taylor. A lot of it was his? build.. but also he was one dimensional on the mic. But he has mightily improved in every way and ROH could do worse than put the belt on him. It was a travesty that he got no rematch with Rush. He? s barely been on TV since then so I hope he was not hurt in that match. I hope he comes back to singles matches and the title picture soon."

[8.0] "Absolutely LOVE Shane Taylor. There are no frills about him. He's a straight up hoss. He will slam you down, and knock you out like few can. He has a presence in the ring, his matches are entertaining and look legit."

[5.0] "I am not fan of shane taylor and he is normal wrestler for me. i don't like his promos too. but his wrestling moves is better. i don't know why ppl make 10 rate for him !"

[10.0] "Shane Taylor is every bit as advertised, and has currently taken NWA Houston by storm. I had the pleasure of wrestling this young man early in his career, and from that day forward, I not only became a friend, but also a fan. If you get a chance to see a show he's on, buy the ticket, he's worth the price of admission..."