Alex Reynolds

[4.0] "He is a forgotten wrestler, AEW use him twice a year and both Uno and Silver are better than him. Could be well booked if he was at least creative, sadly he never updated himself for something higher than a tag/multiman wrestler."

[5.0] "A good wrestler with one of the most vanilla presentations I've ever seen. He needs to cut his hair or do SOMETHING, as his ability to go in ring is actually pretty decent, and he's a pretty decent athlete in the ring. His promo work and character work is middling at best, but really its his look that prevents him from being someone I'd justify as "good." Dude needs to buzz his hair, grow a goatee... SOMETHING that makes him look different, because he looks like a create a wrestler and then doesn't have enough of a calling card when it comes to his style of wrestling. Being a good wrestler is awesome, but being generic in almost every way is a detriment, particularly when your style of wrestling doesn't stand out on a roster full of good wrestlers."

[6.0] "that Dark Order member that people forget about unfortunately, got talent, just need an actual opportunity"

[6.0] "Reynolds is a good wrestler who fails to stand out. He is a better wrestler than many of his dark order counterparts but he does not have the promos or charisma that they do so he does not stand out as much. Solid in the ring with his moveset."

[7.0] "Good wrestler, who is sometimes overshadowed by the more flamboyant members of the Dark Order and seems to be content in his current role staying mostly in the background. I get the feeling he could do more with his character or going into a different direction, but right now he is fine the way he is. Bonus points for being a really dependable and watchable wrestler in the ring."

[8.0] "Man, y'all are sleeping on Alex Reynolds. His in-ring skills are exceptional, has a good look, IE looks like an actual wrestler, and is pretty funny. Unfortunately, he does kind of lack that charisma or it factor when Silver is not with him, so he may need to work on a solo character for himself if he wants to break out as a singles star, because right now he's pigeonholed into being another Dark Order lackey, which is not enviable."

[6.0] "Alex Reynolds is an underappreciated workhorse. When given a chance, he has the talent to steal a match in terms of wrestling ability and entertainment. Unfortunately, he looks like any other indie wrestler with long hair, and his personality is overshadowed by everyone around him."

[6.0] "Reynolds is satisfactory to me. While not the most talented member of The Dark Order, he has a presence, and it works in his favor. He's got decent in-ring ability and works well as a tag team wrestler, plus he's entertaining in promos and BTE/Sammy vlog segments, not as much as his partner John Silver, but still very fun. I don't see Reynolds going far up the AEW card, however, it doesn't mean he's gonna fall to the wayside either."

[6.0] "Alex Reynolds hasn't really shown me a whole lot in his time at AEW, but he is a quality tag team wrestler"

[4.0] "Hasn't really done anything in AEW to differentiate himself from a dozen other guys. He's fine, but hasn't put on a show that has made me stop and take note as of yet. He and Silver have had good tag matches and work well together."

[7.0] "Really evolved in 2020 to a solid wrestler. Likely to be a tag guy for his career but him and Silver will be tag team champion down the line. Outshined by Silver usually but is still good"

[5.0] "On the indies, Reynolds did a great job developing a "pretty boy" heel persona. He competed in a number of American independent promotions in, primarily on the East Coast. However, prior to being signed by AEW, Reynolds' biggest appearances were for PWG, alongside partner John Silver. As far as in-ring abilities, Reynolds is nothing too special. His run as a member of The Dark Order has been below average. Perhaps Reynolds would have reached more success if he stayed in the indies, aiming to cover more ground."

[7.0] "a great wrestler, I had originally said in my previous comment that he lacked personality, after watching his singles matches and more Beaver Boys promos I've deduced that while he doesn't have the charisma that John Silver has, he still has great comedic timing, and can play his characters well. a 7 sounds like an appropriate rating."

[7.0] "Alex Reynolds has thus far made his name primarily on the Northeastern indy scene as both a singles and tag wrestler (the latter alongside both John Silver and brother Kyle Reynolds). Though he hasn't shown himself to be an especially charismatic wrestler as of yet - putting him with a manager might not be a bad idea - he has done reasonably well in portraying an arrogant heel through his mannerisms. His main strengths lie in the ring; he's a solid cruiserweight style wrestler and can put on strong, sometimes show-stealing matches, such as his HOH rivalry against fellow Whipwreck trainee Tony Nese. A regular with NYCW, CZW, HOH and others, he's also made enhancement appearances in WWE in 2009 and ROH in 2013, so time will tell if he'll find a singles or tag team breakout in the coming years."

[9.0] "I've seen Alex Reynolds at several East Coast promotions. He's a great talent with strong in-ring skills. He is an excellent heel, and he works well playing a serious and often agitated role against comedic characters. This man can take a beating. In his tag matches, he tends to take the bulk of the bumps. He is strong as a technical wrestler, but can do other things as well. Every time I see him, I appreciate his skill more."