DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Dante Martin vs. Jay Lethal vs. Jay White vs. Komander vs. Kyle O'Reilly vs. Lance Archer vs. Penta El Zero Miedo vs. Will Ospreay

Match

Match Data
7.54
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 312
Number of comments: 44
10.0 1x
9.0 42x
8.0 140x
7.0 90x
6.0 33x
5.0 1x
4.0 2x
3.0 0x
2.0 3x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 7.55  [312]
Average rating in 2026: 7.67  [6]
Average rating in 2025: 7.86  [14]
Average rating in 2024: 7.53  [292]
Your Options:
Other:
ReiEscobar wrote on 03.07.2025:
[8.0] "Probably the weakest Casino Battle Royale we had in the 2024, but good as well. When Ospreay entered in the match, it was already obvious who was gonna be the winner, even knowing this was a point that Ospreay was into EVERY storyline that was going on AEW, somehow. Great match and action anyways, KOR here looked incredible and Komander did not disappoint. My only dissapoint here was probably Dante Martin."
SiticEye wrote on 17.06.2025:
[7.0] "The first Casino Gauntlet match in AEW history and I think it was a great success! 2024 Dante Martin and a phoning-it-in Penta kinda made the first few minutes of the match weak for me but O'Reilly and Ospreay really breathed some life into this. Archer too he had a terrific performance! Loved that he got a lot of time to shine just battering the whole competition, setting up the tables, and then getting rana'ed through them by the fresh Komander like 5 seconds after he came out. Best spot of the match for me! And he was genuinely out for the rest of the match which was a good decision. Ospreay had some "What have I become? " inner demon shit near the finish but I liked the quick Hidden Blade over Komander and Kyle's dead body lol. Excited to watch Ospreay vs Strong again! ***1/2"
Rjepic1 wrote on 03.09.2024:
[8.0] "The debut of the Casino Gauntlet stipulation and I thought this was a fun time; it's always fun when companies try a new match and they're not complete trash. This match was for an opportunity to challenge for the International Title at Double or Nothing. Solid starting two in Jay White and Dante Martin. The complexion of this match certainly felt like it changed once Will Ospreay entered this match. Kyle O'Reilly was another standout entry into the match. Honestly, everyone looked pretty good here. Ospreay wins the match and then has a face-off with the Undisputed Kingdom."
CoolKyle wrote on 01.09.2024:
[4.0] "This stipulation is so much fun and one of the best original ideas AEW has put out. That said, this wasn't half as good as the ones they did later on. The concept was still relatively new so fans and commentary alike were a bit confused. No countdown and 5 whole minutes between new entries didn't help either because of most this match was dull dead weight with nothing really happening."
rinyald wrote on 25.07.2024:
[7.0] "I'm always very hesitant towards new stipulations but this match was very fun, similar to Lucha Underground's Aztec warfare. They added some real legitimacy by adding people like Kyle O'Reily, Will Osprey & Jay White. It really helps make Osprey look like a megastar aswell, not only having unbelievable chemistry with everyone in the ring, but also tying so many story's together like the stare down with Jay White or him being shocked when Archer's music hits. Really fun action and the right decision was made."
Screaming Enigma wrote on 13.07.2024:
[8.0] "Definitely the best match on the show. Everyone had, at least, a little bit of time to shine here, which I appreciated. Furthermore, the action just felt non-stop here. That only felt more true as more and more people kept entering the match. I do wish there was a countdown before a participant entered and/or that we knew how many people were entering beforehand, though I also did think the suddenness of people entering was intriguing, along with the fact that the match could have kept going for a while, considering that one decision meant the match was over."
Naif Drake1829 wrote on 11.05.2024:
"I loved it , it's the best match in April, the near falls and the chemistry between the wrestlers, it's absolutely perfect I love to see Kyle vs ospreay asap the chemistry between them , seeing Jay white and ospreay in the same ring makes me feel nostalgic and I hope Jay competes in singles matches I loved this match really and I can't get it out of my head , absolute masterpiece"
Prince Osborne wrote on 02.05.2024:
[8.0] "This enticing concept worked like magic with talented surprise packages in the hunt for Roddy's title. The entry of combatants as a surprise for all added the spice for keeping the engagement within the fans even though the structure would've been more cohesive. Everyone excelled and had a key moment throughout the match, but the talking point was the interaction between Ospreay and O'Reilly which looked menacingly masterful. Roddy vs. Ospreay sounds excellent for the Big 4 and as much as I would love to see Ospreay as a World Title contender, the current lineup over there is complex and Ospreay's regime fits the International title's model so well. 3.75 out of 5 stars!"
MaveDeltzer wrote on 02.05.2024:
[5.0] "This match was really dragged down by the inconsistant entry times (to accomodate ad breaks) and the lulls in action required to make that work. Things picked up a bit once all guys were in the match but the strange rules and lack of drama until the final stretch made the match largely uninteresting."
Nevermore42 wrote on 01.05.2024:
[8.0] "The nature of this match was such that we were never going to get the best in-ring action. What we did get was a match that captured a lot of the fun of the Royal Rumble, while also obscuring how many people were actually in the match."
diarchtct wrote on 29.04.2024:
[8.0] "Fantastic match. This kind of stuff is what we need in Dynamite more. Use the talent you have, Komander, Dante Martin, Archer, they all add to the depth of the roster and this is how to do it. I went into this match expecting Jay White to pin a bunch of undercarders to prepare him for a DoN match, but instead they just turned this into a match that kept giving surprises and got better every minute. It really helped that this was not the main event but the middle of the show, you didn't know how long it will be and who will come out. Definitely one of the most fun matches on Dynamite in a while and they picked the right winner with Ospreay going for the International title as his next step to establish himself on TV. ****1/4"
DoctorWhat wrote on 29.04.2024:
[9.0] "This match was incredibly fun, got across a lot of character, and honestly was a interesting and innovating take on the Battle Royale format that really, really worked for me. Honestly, they pitched this one exactly perfectly. What an incredible list of talent too, from the young up and comers, the big stars, the difference in sizes, the veterans. Everyone really went for it and there were brilliant spots throughout."
Modest wrote on 28.04.2024:
[8.0] "Honestly, they should do this match type more often. This was a lot of fun and a great way of showcasing how absurdly stacked AEW's roster is right now. Lance, Kyle O'Reilly, Jay White and Will Ospreay (obviously) were all standouts here for me. I especially enjoyed Ospreay and O'Reilly's exchanges and I'd love to see a singles match between them at some point. I know some are against Ospreay being put into the International Title picture after it looked like he was being positioned for a World Title shot down the line, but I'm not against it. With the unfortunate injuries to Fenix and Mox, and the weird booking of Roddy's reign and OC's 2nd reign, that title badly needs a shot in the arm, and I think putting Ospreay in the picture really helps revitalize not only the belt, but Roddy as a champion as well. Plus if you come up to me and say "Hey Will Ospreay and Roderick Strong are gonna have a 20 minute PPV match" you think I'm really gonna complain?"
Bren0 wrote on 27.04.2024:
[7.0] "[3.75*] I can't deny that the names that participated in this Gaunlet Match were much better than I thought, Jay White, Kyle O'Reilly and Will Ospreay participating was very surprising. Lance Archer's performance was very good, he was very dominant. Ospreay's interactions with Jay White and Kyle were incredible and made the match worth watching, especially the exchanges he had with O'reilly at the end. Ospreay's win was surprising, but I can't deny that I want to see Roddy vs Ospreay."
Oswuold wrote on 26.04.2024:
[8.0] "Ospreay vs Strickland isn't gonna happen that soon so I think that it's correct to put Ospreay in the International title scene despite I'm in minority. Talking about the match, it would have been better if it was an 8 way since the beginning but it was a very enjoyable Spotfest anyway. The ending with Ospreay refusing to hit the Storm Driver '93 makes sense but it's pretty weak, I'll miss that move. ****1/4"
WAKA Flockanoku wrote on 26.04.2024:
[7.0] "While this was a really fun match, it could have stood to be more cohesive. I really like the idea though and hope that they work out the kinks on this match and turn it into something even better down the line."
Retro Ricky wrote on 26.04.2024:
[6.0] "Some good action if a bit confused. This bout was largely an Ospreay showcase, previewing matches with some of the other guys in this bout and keeping him hot. The post-match angle was a waste of time but at least it didn't waste very much time. I'm not entirely sure about lining Ospreay up to face Strong - that seems like a step down from supposedly proving that he's the best wrestler in the world, doesn't it? - but there wasn't much wrong with the match in itself."
Soo-Play wrote on 26.04.2024:
[7.0] "This was pretty fun with the only downside being Ospreay taking a massive stepdown coming off a big win at the PPV against Danielson."
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 26.04.2024:
[2.0] "Oof, I hate to say but this was a real mess. It took me half the match to figure out the rules and I'm not sure even AEW understood in the end, the first half of the match had no urgency at all despite becoming exponentially harder to win with each randomly timed entrance. A lot of the guys really did not look their best and I gagged at O'Reilly doing his awful rope rebound attack not once but twice in the finishing stretch. This was just a total mess, only highlight was Archer taking a cool table bump randomly in the middle of everything."
ParkwayDriver wrote on 26.04.2024:
[4.0] "A clunky match to where it did not feel like anyone stood out beyond Ospreay as the winner. Ospreay/Roderick, while a neat match on paper, is an odd direction for Will coming off a big win over Bryan to go for what is essentially the fourth most important title in the company. There was not a lot of semblance with why they allowed who entered to enter while the intervals were inconsistent. A match that in ways raised more questions than answers as to why this was put together as it was combined with ad breaks hurting the flow. The match had a lot of talent in it but the layout did little for me. Once Ospreay came out the result was also never in doubt."
CSTLW wrote on 26.04.2024:
[10.0] "I enjoyed this match a ton. I love when wrestling is fun, and there are surprises. This match came out of nowhere as a lower third announcement like 20 minutes into the show, and by god did it deliver. The fact that no one knew who was next made it phenomenal. Best part of this match was the short exchange between Ospreay and Komander, followed by the face off between Ospreay and Jay White. Sneaky dynamite MOTY for me."
BigPeanutGuy wrote on 26.04.2024:
[8.0] "Sometimes, stupid just works. Bunch of good to phenomenal workers going in and having a match. MVP was Archer, who's still the best big man AEW has on offer (if Shane Taylor doesn't count). With a proper build, an announced lineup and a surprise entrant or two, this could be a staple for a long old while."
ZooWee wrote on 26.04.2024:
[7.0] "A completely random unannounced match with mystery participants ends up being the best match on this episode. I think the concept of this match is actually pretty cool. It's basically sort of a hybrid between a traditional gauntlet match, a Royal Rumble and a scramble match. That's the best way that I can describe it anyway. The unique rule set made this match feel as if it was constantly evolving and did lead to it feeling a bit messy at times, but also led to fun clashes of styles. You have the high flying guys like Dante and Komander, the dominating giant in Lance Archer, the technical prowess and striking ability of Kyle O'Reilly, you had Jay White being opportunistic and picking his spots carefully and of course there was the insane hybrid wrestling that Ospreay brings. This led to tons of really great moments throughout the match. I loved Penta and Jay chopping the shit out of poor Dante near the start. Archer's dominance when he first came in was fun too. Then you have all of the interactions that Ospreay had with pretty much everyone, especially Komander and O'Reilly who he absolutely tore it up with. There's also a bit of storytelling drama with Will in this match as he hesitates to hit the Storm Driver on Kyle at one point during the match which I'm assuming will come into play during his match with Roddy at DoN. Interesting decision to put Will in the International title picture when he kinda feels like he's above that title, but the match will probably bang so who cares. Overall, this match was very random but it ended up being super fun in the end. Wouldn't be against seeing another one of these. ***3/4"
Machavez21 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "At first I did not know what to expect with this match. It was promoted during the show and just seemed weird and initially I took this as the opportunity to bring back Jack Perry. However, I actually really enjoyed the match and it set up Will Ospreay for his first championship bout in AEW. The one feedback I would have is that hopefully some of the details within the match are explored in further storylines, ie. Will v Jay, Will v KO, Penta v Jay, etc. AEW should keep the 'casino' theme matches a thing during the builds to Double or Nothing. These matches are always fun."
Cal1641 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[6.0] "Could definitely use some refinements to this match type - a timer would be a huge improvement for the pacing, I like the first fall wins concept, but this match definitely needed more stars to convince me there wasn't an obvious winner in Ospreay."
Neutral wrote on 25.04.2024:
[9.0] "Just put all of your good wrestlers in one match and have them duke it out. Extremely fun and definitely the best match of the night"
The Elevated 1 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[7.0] "****1/4 So. Much. Fun. So many great interactions and singles matches I want to see coming out of this match. But, the rules were kind of confusing. Commentary stated wrestlers would keep coming out until there was a winner. So was the entire locker room lined up and in gear just in case the match went on longer? Were their time intervals? I don't know. But it didn't detract from the match very much. I love how the competitors were distracted when someone's music hit to come out. I thought it was a nice touch. Kyle O'Reilly & Will Ospreay were the standouts to me. They had a couple of awesome exchanges as well as Ospreay and Komander. Komander by the way, what an entrance lol. He came out and immediately hit a ropewalk hurricanrana on Lance Archer off the apron through some tables. Another nitpick I had was that the Hidden Blade got kicked out of again. In a multi-man match like this, there's no reason to kick out of a finisher when one of the other guys could just break the pin up. Wasn't a fan of that. Also, Ospreay should be getting ready to chase the world title, not a mid card belt. I fear that him winning the International title won't be the best way to capitalize on his popularity and could leave fans feeling unfulfilled. But the match will be awesome (against Roderick Strong) and I can't wait."
TheHonestGuy69 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[9.0] "Like the end of the show, this match was original but very well executed, with some very good talent in the ring. When the match was announced like many I wondered how it was going to be and if it was going to be good and it was excellent and the hottest man in the company today was rewarded."
somerandommark wrote on 25.04.2024:
[9.0] "Really awesome match, super high paced, and with a cool and unique concept. Whenever Ospreay is in the ring it is electric, especially that closing stretch with KOR! Lance also stood out, wrecking every guy in his path before going through the double tables. Shoutout Jay White too, who plays the cunning, conniving heel to perfection!"
PartyRockz wrote on 25.04.2024:
[9.0] "I enjoyed this match a lot. The stipulation is a fresh idea into the battle royal type of match. If they can polish the execution a bit more, I think this can become a fan favorite. Adding the likes of Jay White, Ospreay, Penta, etc, made the match entertaining as hell & wasnt able to tell who wouldve been the sure winner. Very good all around for it being the first match of its kind."
Kennel wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "Surprisingly fun concept. Definitely a better way to choose a challenger than either a battle royal or a regular gauntlet match. A decent amount of neat spots and Ospreay both participating and winning was pleasantly surprising."
FAR5222 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "Ospreay is what AEW needed. The big babyface that you can root for and not feel ashamed. He ticks all the boxes. Match started fine but picked up when Ospreay hit the ring, and it followed up with some people entering from his past which added on to the match. Just fun all around action. Best match on the episode by far."
ABQMIKE wrote on 25.04.2024:
[9.0] "I like the twist of the battle royal. I think this was the best part of the show and it showed a lot of possible future match ups for all of the 8 that made it to the ring. Where any of these lead to I can't tell but it will be fun."
charliefiction wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "I'm not sure I would've called this match a "gauntlet, " as that usually implies overcoming multiple opponents through multiple pinfall scenarios, but setting that minor branding/marketing issue, the actual execution of the gimmick was surprisingly cool. They might've landed on something special here -- i.e., it's much more compelling than a traditional battle royale. In any event, the in-ring stuff here was high-spot focused with a contsant deluge of "sugar rush" sequences featuring different wrestlers every 30 or 45 seconds. Standouts in this match were definitely Jay White, Ospreay, and Lance Archer, but others played their roles very well (e.g., KOR and Kommander). If you missed this episode, I'd encourage you to check it out. It's worth it for the Jay White vs Ospreay staredown, at a minumum."
Vinny Santos wrote on 25.04.2024:
[7.0] "This match was strange? Yes, it was. I had fun watching it? Yes, very much. At some point, felt like Tony Khan just wanted to show how talented this AEW roster is, from the technical wrestlers, to the high-flyers, to the powerhouses. (***3/4)."
RuSyxx wrote on 25.04.2024:
[7.0] "The match stipulation was a bit weird given the repeated claim "We don't know who is going to come out! " However the talent involved made for a lot of great moments and felt like a glimpse and reminder of all the fresh matches that a lot of the wrestlers still have. The NJPW callbacks between Lance, Will and Jay were fun and enjoyable and reminder that if/when they work together in the future that they have plenty of history to build off of. The ending was nice, even if it made Kommander look a bit silly going for a pin when Will was still in the ring."
homunculus wrote on 25.04.2024:
[9.0] "I was quite confused about the low rating of this match, but then I checked some of the accounts rating this low and see that they give Trick Williams matches 10/10, and then it kind of clicked that most of these reviews are disingenuous. This match was a hoot. Ospreay, Komander, O'Reily were my personal MVPS of this match. Ospreay can have great chemistry with any wrestler and this matched showed it. Overall, super fast paced, chaotic, and just a fantastic watch. Lethal didn't add much, he was just kind of there. (****1/2)"
cbaus wrote on 25.04.2024:
[2.0] "Yeah I wasnt a fan of this. No consistency in terms of entrants entering the matchup, ad breaks cutting up the match and disturbing the whole flow of the match. Theres no doubt that all of the guys involved in this match are talented but this match was poorly put together. I just couldnt get immersed into the matchup with people coming out at random times, with how the ad breaks broke up the match and I think in general; this match missed the mark. The wrestlers arent really at fault here but this match could definitely do with some re-structuring and better production if they are to bring it back."
colinmcev wrote on 25.04.2024:
[7.0] "This variation of the gauntlet match is SO much better than, for example, the Battle Royal we just saw on Raw last week, which started out chaotic (as most Battle Royals do) and only got good after most wrestlers were knocked out of the ring. By contrast, the pacing of this one was great, and not knowing who was coming next added a fun element of surprise to the match (especially when Ospreay came out). It also gave multiple wrestlers their moments to shine, particularly a great spot when Kormander's reversal sent Lance Hoyt flying through two tables (well, one-in-a-half, really...)"
birds123 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[2.0] "I just was not a fan of the way they introduced this stipulation nor the actual execution of it. I think it has potential but I just feel like the logic is so off. If there could be endless entrants, where was the urgency from all of the wrestlers? Their odds drastically would go down after each entrant, yet it just felt like a run of the mill match at multiple points. The only real wrestlers that came off looking decent were Will Ospreay and Jay White. Dante Martin imo continues to look lost in the ring, and I felt that Komander, Lethal, and Penta all did as well. Archer and OReilly were fine. I just felt like the layout and execution couldve been infinitely better."
Michael Morbius wrote on 25.04.2024:
[7.0] "Well this was a nice surprise. First of all the whole of the sudden death gauntlet is great. Not knowing who's next adds a nice sense of surprise and for this match they threw as many ballers as they could. Jay White, Ospreay, Penta, O'Reilly... crazy star power. The match itself was quite fun, especially towards the end. First part of the match was alright until Ospreay came in and got a hell of pop. Loved his interaction with Jay White. Lance Archer came in and destroyed before getting put through two table by Komander, really nice spot. Final minutes were great with some awesome exchanges between Komander and Ospreay and, especially, Ospreay and O'Reilly. Would love to see a match between the two. Also Ospreay deciding not to do the tiger driver '91 furthers the story of Will retiring the move which was great. The ending was cool as well. Roddy vs. Ospreay looks fantastic on paper, can't wait to see it. 7/10 - 3.75*/5*"
Billy Boy wrote on 25.04.2024:
[7.0] "Before I discuss the match itself, I want to talk about the stipulation here. I love it. The idea of a gauntlet match where people just keep coming out until someone gets the pin. Its a nice enjoyable bit of chaos. The best thing that I can compare it to is a mix of WWEs Royal Rumble and a 6-pack challenge. It is obviously because of the timed intervals as well as the sudden death part of it all. Everyone vs everyone. Jay vs. Dante was pretty solid. Dantes definitely one to keep an eye on. I do feel as if hes being held back in the Top Flight tag team with his brother. His in-ring work remind me of Ricochet in a good way. Jay continues to show that he can be a formidable force as both a singles guy and a tag team guy. Pénta didnt add much when he came out. It didnt help that most of that interval was during PIP. OReilly did add a good little bit to this. His MMA style did help. Also, hes probably the best quality wrestler to enter at this point. It did feel like this interval was considerably shorter than the other two so far. Ospreay got a nice reaction and made a quick impact. Him and Jay had a nice little segment. I definitely see them having a singles match soon. Are these intervals getting shorter and shorter? Archer was next and made perhaps the biggest impact thus far. He laid out everyone. Even Ospreay. By the way, beautiful counter to the guillotine. Then he just had to set up tables. At least it was during the break. I wonder whos going through them. Good god I dont like Komander. Haha table didnt cooperate. Why is Komander getting in the most offense on Ospreay? Where the hell has Jay Lethal been? I like that he shows everyone why hes been doing this for as long as he has. I forgot Dante was in this. OReilly too. Im beginning to see that this has the typical segmental format of multi-man matches. Seems like a one-on-one match with both guys rotating in and out. This Komander guy is such a one-trick pony. We get it. You can walk the right rope. Yeah, its cool that you can do that, but thats all you do. Ospreay won. Cool I guess. He remains undefeated. Hes definitely winning at Double or Nothing. Or someone gets involved to make it a fluke. Regardless, hopefully Roddy can lead him to a good match. Just a reminder, my main gripe with Ospreay as a performer is that hes a checklist wrestler. All he has is a good move set and hes able to make it look visual attractive. He simply fails to sell virtually anything or put any meaning behind the moves he delivers. To put it in simplest terms, hes a Cirque du Soleil act. 7/10. ***1/2"
arisenby wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "[7.5] Unironically, a really fun first outing for this stipulation, and I would love to see it become a fixture for Double or Nothing time. The intervals were inconsistent, but was still fun. Ospreay came out with the win, and while he's absolutely a great choice, I can't help but feel like it's a bit of a step down for him, especially since he's just coming off of putting on one of the best matches in history just a few days prior, but I'll look forward to what he does. Very fun match concept, would love to see it developed on more, and should lead to a good match in Ospreay vs Strong."