[6.0] "I thought this was a solid match match. I was excited to get to see Mina Shirakawa's work. Anna Jay being distracted by Mariah May throughout the match was great. Mina Shirakawa won this one with a pretty sweet pin."
[6.0] "A solid match for what it was, but nothing outstanding. Both women had solid showings, though I did feel as though the ending was rather abrupt. Either way, I don't think this was meant to be a super great match, as it was mainly here to introduce Shirakawa to fans who haven't seen her work before."
[6.0] "Loved my first viewing of Mina Shirakawa and glad to see that Anna Jay's matches in ROH is getting her more polished in the ring. Yet there were some issues throughout the match that hurt the overall quality."
[6.0] "I enjoyed my first in-ring look at Mina Shirakawa, but this match was hurt by the fact that Anna Jay just isn't very good. I did enjoy the narrative beat of Anna losing because she took time out to talk shit to Mariah May instead of focusing on the match."
[5.0] "[3.0*] It was a pretty decent match, I liked Mina Shirakawa's performance, she did a good job, the match ended quickly and the ending was a little strange, it was still a very solid performance from Anna Jay."
[7.0] "A good TV match for what it was, nothing to burn the house down but I enjoyed it. Mina Shirakawa fits surprisingly well in AEW and I hope we see a lot of her."
[5.0] "I thought this match would be better based on the hype around Mina Shirakawa, but these two just never really clicked into anything better than average."
[3.0] "Even at nine minutes this was too long, too confused, too much like stuff being thrown at the wall. Nothing these two did was all that bad but there wasn't enough good for the time they were given either. The post-match angle was mostly nothing though Deeb's sit-down challenger promo deserves some credit for breaking the formula."
[3.0] "These two had a match on Ring of Honor that was alright but nothing remarkable, so I get why they would run this back but maybe that one was saved in editing because they had no chemistry here and it was pretty awkward throughout."
[5.0] "This was fine, and mostly carried by Mina if I'm being honest. While Anna Jay's in ring work has been a lot better as of recent, she's still not fully there yet in the ring and still doesn't really interest me as a wrestler. One area she definitely needs to work on is her selling. There's multiple attempts at leg work by Mina but Anna's selling of it was shoddy at best and nonexistent at worst. Mina showed off some unique offense here like a really cool springboard kick thing from the outside of the ring to the inside and a unique looking roll up pin which got her the win, but overall there wasn't a lot of chemistry between her and Anna which led to a fairly mediocre match overall. **3/4"
[6.0] "Anna Jay has been great lately and had a great match with Mina. Clearly Mina needs some further exposure to the american audience if the idea is to bring Stardom in for bigger stuff. It helped build onto the Toni-Mariah lore without putting Mariah as the front runner of the championship. With that being said, Serena Deeb has claimed the next challenger spot and this should be interesting."
[4.0] "**3/4 To be honest, I wasn't fully paying attention to this match so I can't really review or rate it fairly. Anna Jay can use more work and Shirakawa was good. This is the first time I've seen her wrestle. Too bad there was no video package for the casuals."
[7.0] "Good match between an improving Anna Jay (who has really impressed me the last few weeks) and the professional, but still young Mina Shirakawa."
[6.0] "I was impressed by the pacing and execution of this match layout, and Mina - in particular - shined due to her innovative-looking offense (much of which I haven't seen on American TV). The pinning sequence was very well-executed and creative, for example. Anna's strikes and kickouts continue to look unimpactful but she's really grown as a wrestler with all of the TV opportunities she's been given over the last few months."
[6.0] "A cool little match to dig deep into the lore of May-Storm-Shirakawa. I'm really expecting a match between Mina and Toni, maybe in the Forbidden Door (since it looks like Deeb will challenging for the belt at DoN). (***)."
[4.0] "Bit awkward but ultimately serviceable. The match really started picking around the point where Mina hit the rolling elbow/backfists, but prior to that it felt like they were slowly figuring out how to work together up until the end where it kind of clicks a little bit before abruptly ending."
[4.0] "Kind of an awkward match, but it did progress the storyline going between Anna Jay, Mariah May, Toni Storm, and Mina Shirakawa. There were some definite moments where Anna and Mina weren't on the same page in the ring. I feel like this is also a testament to how well Stardom is able to train people since Mina only has about 1 year more of experience than Anna but is leagues better in the ring. Anna would really benefit from a stint in Stardom, she's been in AEW for around 5 years and has only just started seeming competent in the ring in the last few months."
[2.0] ""This match was....alright. The two had an apparent lack of chemistry in the ring, leading to some awkward spots and a bizarre pace throughout the whole thing. The production of the match was, at best, decent, but it still doesn't help that this match was ultimately poorly scrapped together.""
[5.0] "A fine but ultimately predictable match in that it never quite got into another gear. It was largely designed to showcase Shiarakawa. I like Anna Jay but it feels like she is booked too often in an enhancement role and it was hard to feel overly invested in the dynamic between the two. The post match was equally a bit messy with both Toni and Mariahs involvement as well as Serena Deeb. Overall a fine match but not one that I felt overly invested in in terms of result or what followed in the post match."
[6.0] "I didn't think Mina Shirakawa and Anna Jay appeared to have particularly great chemistry together at first, but they improved as the match went along, and I think it turned out to be a fine (if nothing particular special) match. I thought Mina Shirakawa herself looked really good for the most part. Great to see her AEW debut, and great to see Stardom talent getting a spotlight on Dynamite. Her entrance was fun too; she's a really entertaining wrestler... and not just when she's kissing Mariah May."
[2.0] "This was so, so awkward. There was an obvious lack of chemistry here and that was portrayed heavily throughout the matchup. It wasnt crisp, the spots just didnt work and the near falls, they were terribly executed. Whilst this match wasnt good, it was the post match moments that really drag this down to the realms of terrible. Toni Storms awkward save, Serena Serbs promo not being heard over the entrance music. This was very disappointing and this was a very rough watch. Production, wrestlers, they all didnt click here."