[8.0] "A really solid match here as Toni Storm elevates the title and the division and Thunder Rosa as a perfect underdog who has won this in the past and is trying to get back there again. Toni Storm was the right choice for the one here for sure, but I felt like this was Rosa's best match up maybe in the company."
[6.0] "Kinda Meh match it was okay nothing to special, Rosa with no makeup for the match was cool, But Toni does get the win with a lowblow and piledriver to win"
[8.0] "This was a great clash for the AEW Women's World Title. A duel between former champions in Rosa and Storm both looked very strong in this match and there were consistently high stakes involved with the championship. The match stayed intense between the two and very technical in-ring not relying on spots but more of a general flow through in-ring back/forth. Storm Zero connects but Rosa still kicks out, Toni pulls out the Texas Cloverleaf from the arsenal but Thunder still stays in it. The ref gets distracted and Toni hits a low blow desperate to retain the title which factored heavily into incoming storylines at this point in 2024. Storm Zero connects for the retention. Rating: ****"
[9.0] "Very underrated match after rewatching again this morning. One of Toni Storms best matches under the timeless gimmick in 2024. Thunder Rosa resilient effort to do whatever it takes to win the championship that she had to vacate due to injury was nice to see. Still rooting for Thunder Rosa to be apart of what's going on in the women's division in aew more substantially. I thought this was great. ****1/4"
[8.0] "great use of time on the card. Both women delivered exactly what you'd hope for from two of AEW's top stars. Toni's character work was strong, though I think her personality is obviously better suited for a babyface--it's not a bad thing, and they definitely figured that out later in her character arc. Here, she still leaned into her over-the-top persona well, while Rosa brought her usual intensity and crisp execution. The pacing was tight, with every move feeling purposeful. There was a great balance between Storm's heel antics and Rosa's fiery comebacks, keeping the crowd hooked. Overall, it was pretty good--an enjoyable, well-worked match"
[5.0] "A good 4-5 mins too long and just boring. Was heated at the start and Rosa really tries to make this an epic but Storm at this point is still figuring out how her timeless style in-ring so its a little messy. **3/4"
[8.0] "Really underrated match in Toni's title reign. They had a great build with some awesome promos and in-ring angles from both. Rosa was at her best here which was more than expected due to her recent performances. Crowd was fully into it and both delivered. Very good stuff."
[6.0] "A really enjoyable feud and 75% of a really enjoyable match but unfortunately there were too many shenanigans for me to fully get behind this. So many run ins and interference spots that nearly negates all the great work Storm and Rosa put in before. Some solid submission spots and a few nice looking back breakers. Toni's best match in a while."
[7.0] "decent match but nothing to really get into as toni is still being given babyface opponents despite being over as a babyface herself it makes it hard to care. overall a pretty fine match that i did enjoy watching though. ***3/4"
[8.0] "This a good match between both women with some real good in ring work and psychology between them and this is the best title defence for Toni Storm's "Timeless" reign as AEW Women's Champion."
[6.0] "***3/4 Was debating giving it four stars, but it didn't go long enough for me to really reach the level of greatness. But really solid and would've benefitted from more time and less shenanigans. Good nearfall when Rosa kicked out of a hip attack and Storm Zero, and Purrazzo murking Mariah May and Luther was funny. This was probaly Storm's best title defense so far, as her past matches haven't clicked because of them being short and the crowd cheering her even though Toni Storm does heelish stuff. Also a good way to revive the crowd."
[6.0] "[3.0*] This was a good match and Tonis best in a very long time in my opinion. I enjoyed it a lot and I indicate the watch. She finally learnt how to mix-up the gimmick with the in-ring and now I look more forward to her PPV matches. Thunder was also superb there, specially for a person returning from injury. Very cool match, highly entertaining. Liked it a lot."
[7.0] "A solid match that actually got a good amount of time. It still ended up being that the two women's matches on the show were also the two shortest on the show, but it's different when this is about fifteen minutes and the TBS Title Match was about six."
[6.0] "Fine match, one of the best from Timeless Toni Storm reign, the interferences didn't harmed the match but made the ending look a little weird, pacing was good - {***}"
[7.0] "Toni Storm remembers how to wrestle! Thunder Rosa returns to PPV! Mariah May debuts her Toni Storm throwback gimmick! A lot to love in this one, Toni bumping and stooging way more than she had to this point, not to mention doing actual, recognizable sequences with some degree of motivation? As I, and many others, have said before, Toni's run as "Timeless" Toni and as AEW Women's Champion really turned a corner around this point"
[7.0] "This was a really fun match for the Women's World Title I thought. Toni Storm has been locked in and producing better in-ring work with the Timeless character since the AZM match. Thunder Rosa has been really producing solid work for the past couple months as well and it's been great having her back in the fold. The title scene remains Timeless as Toni Storm is still champion."
[8.0] "This was a good match hard hitting and was Tonis first defence where she really nailed how to wrestle with the Timeless character. This has been Rosas best match so far since returning and felt like a return to the old Thunder Rosa. About halfway through this turned into a proper hard hitting bou and maintained through the end."
[7.0] "There wasn't much linking any of this match, and definitely wasn't framed like Rosa was going to win, but everything was executed well. It was fun but not quite great."
[8.0] "Good match here, I seriously think the AZM match has revitalised Toni's work. Her offence has got crisper, more physical and significantly quicker since she had to step up to AZM's level. Rosa's offence and selling were both great too, I think she is underrated. The double stomp that nearly caught Toni in the face was a highlight!"
[7.0] "I was going back and forth about skipping this. Thunder Rosa is fine but haven't seen her in a while and I'm tired of Toni Storm's gimmick. It was funny at first but went too much into parody fast. She almost has go away heat with me. In the ring Thunder Rosa is pretty good but I haven't seen a great match from Storm, ever. They kinda turned me over though. I got into this by the end. It's probably the best match I've seen out of Toni Storm. If only she would get rid of the gimmick."
[4.0] "Such a slow match. Even though I like Toni's character a lot her matches are always slow and boring and as for Thunder Rosa I just don't get what people find in her. Not a terrible match and not any noticeable botches but I expected better seeing the rating."
[8.0] "Another pleasant surprise on this card. Despite my disagreement with Toni Storm continuously defending her title against babyfaces the crowd aren't interested in rooting for (at least not as much as they want to root for Toni Storm), this was a great effort from both wrestlers."
[8.0] "as any Toni Storm match this was also great. The psychology of it all played a big part in it being great but that is what Timeless Toni Storm is all about"
[8.0] "Toni Storm's best match in quite a long time, certainly since she started this gimmick. It was an actual match and not just her doing her schtick and then winning in an appalling way that makes people look bad. Great showing from both women."
[7.0] "A very good match, and the best of Toni Storm's current title reign. Her reign just needed this, a more intense match. Even though it had a screwy finish, it didn't hurt the overall pacing of the match. It showed us, after Toni Storm changing her gimmick, that she can still go in the ring. I was never high on Thunder Rosa, but she did her part well, really catching my eye for the future."
[6.0] "A decent match, with a little bit of an anticlimactic ending. Solidly wrestled, but nothing really setting it apart. Both are capable of better, especially on a pay per view."
[7.0] "Easily Toni's best title defense. Both women went out there and fought tooth and nails for 15 minutes, they were given the time and they delivered. It started a little slow but the action quickly picked up after Rosa's beautiful tornillo. Both ladies took some nasty bumps and the action got increasingly more physical as the match went by. Both ladies throwed bombs at each other and the action was really intense which is something that Toni's previous matches really lacked off. I also liked Deonna/Mariah brawl. The crowd was into as well which elevated the match. The ending was great, really funny and innovative. 7/10 - 3.75*/5*"
[7.0] "A pretty good match for the Women's world championship. When Toni Storm decides to wrestle like she used to, it's surprisingly good. Thunder Rosa also does a good job for this match."
[8.0] "Ever since Storm emerged on the scene of AEW, a rare bunch of women tapped in the best out of her and delivered a certified hooper of a match. One of those is Thunder Rosa, and this match is undoubtedly the best from the champion since embracing the Timeless moniker. After her return from injury, I had a doubt, but Rosa proved me wrong by being more confident and polished in the ring. Of course, the interference from Mariah was expected, but Deonna equaling her leading to a fantastic finishing stretch made this match even better. 3.75 out of 5 stars!"
[8.0] "This was one of the best women's matches in AEW in a long time, Thunder Rosa did a great job despite not really feeling hot going into the match. ***3/4"
[9.0] ""Timeless" Toni Storm...I get the gimmick, but those granny panties kill any appeal she had when she was a badass in WWE. Thunder Rosa seems to have the company behind her as she's been featured prominently since her debut. Toni Storm seems to have her fans in the crowd, but Thunder Rosa did excellently here. This may be Toni Storm's best match."
[8.0] "This match kicked ass. It seems as if Timeless Toni has shifted her in ring style. In recent months it seemed a bit too focused on the gimmick but now she's reminding us that she is one of the best workers in the world. Thunder Rosa seemed a bit rusty but has slowly been regaining form. This match was very hard hitting and aggressive, calling upon the shared history between the two performers."
[8.0] "This match was great. Thunder Rosa was very aggressive here, heel turn soon maybe? Here are my favorite moments from the match. They started brawling immediately. Thunder Rosa had an awesome tornado dive from the top rope onto Toni and Luther on the outside. Toni finally got some good offense in. Thunder Rosa had a Crucifix bomb for a good near fall. Thunder Rosa did a Death Valley Driver to Toni on the apron, she rolled her into the ring for a really good near fall. Great backstabber by Toni. Toni hit Thunder Rosa with a really great fisherman suplex(or maybe it was a northern lights suplex? ) and bridged for a good near fall. Nice chop exchange by these two which turned into a slap match. A brutal headbutt from Toni. Thunder Rosa got Toni in a waistlock and Toni quickly countered and got Thunder Rosa into a waistlock of her own and then hit Thunder Rosa with a german. After some distractions, Toni hit Thunder Rosa with another German and then a Storm Zero for a near fall. A low blow by Toni followed by a piledriver for the win."
[7.0] "I really enjoyed it, I think Thunder Rosa's resilience was a key point here. She really managed to deliver the match that champion Toni Storm needed. I wasn't a big fan of the ending with the referee's distraction, but I don't think it detracted from the great match it was. It's always good to see both of them in action."
[7.0] "Rosa was wild here, she showed great aggression and you can feel her bitterness. Commentary hype her up well but no way was I ever in the belief that we would have a new Champ. Storm is on a roll now, the crowd is behind her, and since taking a more serious approach in her match, she has only become more beloved. The action was very physical, hard hitting, it was stiff, the timing could be a little better but nothing too much to complain about, there were some interferences which I didnt find necessary, Storm then cheated a little to win. All in all a good match, nothing too intense but solid in all aspects. ***1/2"
[6.0] "It takes two to tango, doesn't it? Thunder Rosa is an incredible talent, combining the physicality that the "smart" audience craves with an intense and believable emotional performance. She was entirely in character throughout and wholly believable in her pride, fury, and pain throughout the match. Storm gets a lot of praise for her character work, but frankly, I didn't see much of it once the bell rang. She didn't come across as the egotistical champion who held her challenger in contempt, or, really, much of anything. She executed her moves well enough and there's nothing wrong with her selling, but from bell to bell she's just a wrestler. (Not even a heel wrestler, just a wrestler.) That damaged the bout a lot and, combined with an audience poisoned by dirt sheet gossip, led to mixed reactions. Really think about that in context of the billing: this was a fight between a proud athlete fighting for her people and an insane egotist who treats everyone with disdain. For the crowd to be anything less than 90% Rosa is a colossal failure. While she certainly carried her part in the physical execution, Storm didn't do any of the emotional work to push the audience on to the babyface's side. This is probably an 8 for Rosa, a 3 for Storm, so we'll split the difference and call it a 6. Tentative recommend, it's good if you're just watching for moves or really adore Rosa's work regardless of the outcomes."
[6.0] "This match had a bit of awkwardness with the interference near the end, but still had some nice action, like the apron driver. Nothing really stood out aside from it, some of it was a bit formulaic and standard. But a good return to the world title scene for Thunder Rosa. [3.25]"
[8.0] "Before I can get into the actual match I just gotta give a quick shout out to 'Toni Storm, taut faced like Betty Davis, Thunder Rosa, looking like Princess Jasmine, and if she wins the title it will certainly be a WHOLE NEW WORLD FOR THE MIRROR MIRROR' from Nigel, I think Nigel's commentary is incorrigible and I particularly like how his silver screen knowledge adds to Toni's gimmick. Right of the bat I loved the mask reveal, and then the two of them just get right into it. I love Toni, I love Thunder Rosa even more, so I was incredibly excited for this and it did not disappoint. I really like the story here, it really got a new side of Thunder Rosa across. The expression on Toni's face right after that DVD was, for lack of a better word...timeless. And THAT HEADBUTT, God almighty! This was a hard hitting physical match, I think it further validates this reign as Toni's best, and sets up Thunder Rosa for a much more exciting run overall. I thought the weakest part was all the business with Marsha, it only took away from the match. Why the hell did she get up 2 seconds after being busted on the ring side and busted on the steps? But it was a great match, and I think this pair could give us something amazing if they keep working together."
[7.0] "This was an amazing match that I'm glad didn't get overshadowed by the rest of this fantastic card. I really enjoyed this and I'm glad I get to see Rosa is wrestling on PPV again, not to mention the amazing character work from Toni Storm. Overall I think the build and the match was awesome."
[7.0] "Really enjoyed this one. Best Toni Storm match in awhile. Worked stiff as fuck and as a result got the crowd super invested by the end of it. Rosa's stomp towards the end made me wince."
[7.0] "Toni Storm is one of the best things going in professional wrestling. Thunder Rosa looks better than she even did during her first run. This was a brutal battle between two of the top stars in AEW's women's division. They threw bomb after bomb, constantly looking to prove their toughness in a World Championship match that will likely go down as one of the most memorable of this reign. The Death Valley Driver on the apron was especially violent, as was the Double Stomp that left welts on the chin and throat of the champion. All the way to the finish, this was a shining example of how great Storm has been as champion and how nice it is to see Rosa back in action. 3.5 stars, 7 out of 10."
[9.0] "I really enjoyed this. Both women brought a lot of fight to this, a lot of intensity that baked up well with the build to the match. It felt very hard fought and very personal, and though I was pretty sure I knew who would win, I was still really engaged in this one."
[6.0] "[3.5*] Very cool match, much better than I thought it would be, Thunder Rosa's performance was very good, her effort, she gave all her energy here, Storm's performance was also better than what she had been doing in her last matches. Storm put on a good sequence at the end to secure the victory and retain the belt, an enjoyable match and a great performance from Thunder Rosa."
[5.0] "I had a lot of questions about Thunder Rosa being washed prior to the match, and I think she overdelivered. Conversely, this was a 'Timeless' Toni Storm match, which I think forces unnecessary errors more than it should have. I thought the finish was creative, but fell flat for the live crowd. Sometimes new ideas aren't always good ideas. Props to Thunder Rosa for proving me wrong and giving something passable. Toni has some strange issues for me, it's not like she isn't talented, but I think the output of her action just usually feels cartoonish and lackluster."
[7.0] "Match is pretty good. The ending is a bit strange, but it's unusual, I haven't seen this for a long time. And it seems to me that their fued will not end there, I think there will be a triple threat with Purazzo and Thunder Rosa will win the gold."