[3.0] "This match fell flat very harshly and that definitely falls on Jericho more than Hook. This match just had zero chemistry and at this point Jericho has been so extremely washed anything he tries to do to breathe relevance into his character is not going to work. The weapons stipulation did not really make sense and this match absolutely dragged. There is just not much redeeming about this match other than the Hook T-Bone Suplex off the apron through a table. It is still fun to watch Y2J take moves like that because he is such an insufferable dickhole. Rating: *.5"
[0.0] "With out a doubt, one of the lowest points for AEW in 2024. The fans had already been sick of him, that's a clear sign that you need to pivot. But that didn't happen. They put Jericho in the ring with one of the worst performers they have which is just a recipe for disaster. The spots in here are slow and boring. Once again the crowd completely hijacks this which I can't say I can blame them for it. Jericho is an all time great and while his legacy is still intact, his AEW run is seen so differently because of how poor he's been since 2023. He needs to take a hint and retire. He looked awful here."
[2.0] "This was predictably terrible but it was like a car crash that you can't take your eyes off of. Hook is one of the most boring wrestlers I've seen and paired up with a Jericho way past his prime created a beufiully awful shitstorm. The chants at Jericho were incredible awkward as well"
[0.0] "Terrible, just a terrible fucking match. Jericho at that point was almost destroying his career with so many bad matches. The crowd was chanting "Go Home Jericho" or "Please Retire." That's how bad it's gotten to. I love Jericho, but man, this was sad. Hook isn't that good either, haven't seen a decent match from him. This guy was doing mostly suplex's."
[2.0] "Hooks selling is pretty bad. this miss off the apron jump was pretty abysmal. That german on the outside was rough in a good way. Hook has a tough time staying on his feet sometimes, I think he's just too fired up. The suplex through the table was nice but looked like Jericho kinda had to do it himself. You can see Jericho calling a lot of spots in the ring. It is genuinely cool to see him to a top rope hurricanrana at his age. The singaporian cane when Jericho has the trash can on is kinda cute, gets the audience interested, but its pretty silly. Hook takes the code breaker like absolute shit. Hook puts a sleeper hold on jericho and he puts him through the table to get out of it, but the table is so low on the turnbuckle, and then Jericho cheats on a pin but its supposedly allowed, so it just doesn't work. Then a terrible Judas Effect countered into an even worse knee bar. Hook terribly counters the Walls of Jericho into a pin. Low blow by Jericho which is legal. Then Jericho hits a judas effect, but Hook kicks out. he hits another one and Hook kicks out again. Jericho gets his bat, Hook gets hit in the face with it, and the match ends. At the end of the day, putting in a guy who is pretty green against a veteran that everyone is just completely over seeing isn't exactly a great recipe for success. this is the kind of program that kills careers, since no one wants to see the comeuppance. most exciting thing was Taz ALMOST getting involved. Drizzling shits"
[3.0] "Fell off completely after the suplex table spot that actually looked good. And then Jericho's low gas tank ran out and it turned into trash. The crowd begging Jericho to go home and retire was nice to hear though instead of just lazy boos. And it was soooo fuckingggg longggggg! *1/2"
[8.0] "I actually really liked this match. Of course Jericho is not in his prime, for that reason this type of unsanctioned matches are the best for him. Take for example the Owens Vs Austin bout at Wrestlemania some years ago, it was great, and mainly carried by Kevin, but making that the rattlesnake could look awesome. The same here, even with Jericho winning, he made that Hook could look even stronger and as a credible challenger to other mid card titles. In fact, this has been one of the Hook matches that I have ever seen. Really nice. [****]"
[2.0] "Another Jericho match that the crowd turned on, but the work was also terrible. A stupid brawl with ridiculous spots that went way too long. Jericho has no need to be wrestling in 2024, the crowd clearly hate him after everything, and it's not doing anything to get Hook over."
[6.0] "Jericho has go home heat at the minute, so the crowd were not into this one, but Jericho took some big bumps and made Hook look pretty strong in defeat. It's a pretty average plunder match soured by the negative reception that Jericho receives. The match also went too long, considering there were a few long matches on this show, a few minutes shaved off of here wouldn't have been unwelcome."
[4.0] "actually a pretty decent match, annoyingly, given jericho standards. but no one wants this, he is getting full go away heat. however there were some fun spots in this match, i just hope hook can escape away from jericho. *1/2"
[1.0] "I just hate this match. All the action and spots throughout the match are just whatever, the psychology between both men was just awful and it made Hook looked very weak and Jericho more hated and unpopular with the crowd turning on him hard with go away heat."
[4.0] "**3/4 I don't want to dock any points because of the result, but why? Jericho was booed so hard, just call an audible. When the match graphic popped up, when he walked out, and even when the bell rang, boos filled the arena. "Fozzy sucks", "go home Jericho, go home", and "please retire" chants were heard throughout the match. I almost feel bad for him. But, it must continue I guess. but the match itself was solid at best. A nice exploder thorugh a table and trash can lid hits. HOOK kicked out of two Judas Effects and lost to a bat shot to the head. Don't know why the prior nearfalls were necessary. Personally, I don't like it when a wrestler kicks out of finishers just to eventually lose. Unnecessary match on this long pay-per-view and terrible result."
[5.0] "I don't know why I picked this match to review, but I did. Don't get me wrong, I was always a Chris Jericho fan, but unfortunately, the fans are getting sick of Jericho. The fans chanting "Please Retire" and "Fozzy Sucks" definitely caused a huge distraction in this match. Typical hardcore match that seen Jericho and Hook brawl on the floor, use the steel steps, announcers table, a garbage can lid, garbage can, a kendo stick and at one point Hook lands a flying T-Bone Suplex off the apron, putting Jericho through a table. Hook shows heart by kicking out of two Judas Effects but falls to Jericho in the end after Jericho busts Hook in the face with a baseball bat and leaves the new FTW Champion."
[6.0] "I didn't dislike this as much as most, apparently. That said, this still wasn't my favorite. It dragged a bit for me, unfortunately. The table spot off the apron was cool, though. Other than that, I don't really know what else to say about this. It happened and I am unchanged."
[6.0] "Yeah this was one of the more bad matches on the card. And this match wasn't even that bad. Honestly this was good. There was crazy spots that I liked and I enjoyed this. Other FTW matches are better than this one but this was a good showing. Maybe Chris Jericho winning wasn't the smartest choice because Hook was an awesome champion. But that doesn't take away from what happened in this match. I was stuck on a 8.0 rating or a 6.0. But ultimately I decided on a 6.0 because it makes sense instead of over rating it."
[4.0] "I don't think this match was awful, but it wasn't good. Hook straight up missed several jumping moves -- commentary played off the first one as a 'glancing blow' but it happened again later. Jericho wasn't much better with the Redrum sell looking super sloppy, no reason he couldn't have grabbed the ropes. Production straight missed the low blow. And from a storytelling perspective the match couldn't decide if was playing "Older wrestler outsmarts younger wrestler" straight or if it wanted to invert it. None of these were huge issues individually but they added up to a subpar match."
[4.0] "[2.0*] As I said to a friend, this was a bootleg Mox vs Yuta rip-off with 100% less aura and vibes, with the execution also being incomparably worse. However, it was not a DUD as some people are saying and was not the worst match of the night. 2024 Y2J sucks and he needs to be cut from PPVs and TV, and I felt very frustrated that Mox/Claudio/Takeshita/Fletcher/Hobbs missed the event just because of this douchebag demanding a spot on the card, but the match actually had some decent moments and things that made me laugh. If you try to not think that this is Chris Jericho, the ending is actually pretty dope and brutal too."
[5.0] "Not a good, but also not a bad match... I understand that we hate Chris Jericho right now, and he needs to stay out of television ASAP, but the match wasn't that bad as some people here are saying, it was basically a failed try to repeat Moxley vs Yuta, with an established veteran dominating the match and failing to beat the rookie, but this time the rookie won, HOOK kicked out some finishers and won the match. It felt exaggerated sometimes, but the psychology was good - {**1/2}"
[7.0] "I thought that this was a fun attitude era type brawl with gun spots which out preformed the quality of Jericho on tv. I felt that Hook also had a strong performance as hook tends to shine in these wild brawls and hardcore showings. Overall I felt that they over delivered from what was on tv"
[4.0] "Easily the weakest match of the night. This went way too long, to the point it felt like it went longer than it actually did. This is still watchable but I just don't think these two are that good together. Chris Jericho wins the FTW Title here so the feud continues."
[7.0] "This was a fun hardcore brawl and Hook looked great kicking out of the Judas Effect twice. I'm guessing the lower ratings are down to the result. I know Jericho isn't the flavour of the month but Hook chasing the title isn't a bad story to tell, and I expect he'll get it back."
[2.0] "This match has good spots, but the emotional crux of Jericho feeling bad about winning just didn't work for me. 1- it makes Hook look weak, when he's been booked to be a killer against younger, quicker and stronger opposition. That Jericho had room to"feel bad" and still win... yeah.... 2- it requires me to take Jericho as an earnest, sincere character, which he hasn't been for some years. Am I supposed to feel pathos for him here? NO sympathy was generated. It's very rare that a story / character detracts from a decent match this greatly for me.... but yeah, this didn't land at all. There's a serious disconnect between AEW's booking of Jericho and the fans' feelings towards Jericho, a bigger disconnect than I even felt existed for the Codyverse. NOT GOOD"
[4.0] "The match was better than their first but it was a payoff to one of the least over fueds in the company, the HOOK kick out from two Judas effects and Jericho beating HOOK is all terrible."
[2.0] "(Sorry english is not my firtst language) Pls Jericho its time to retirement i mean he is so slow in the ring this guy needs to stop and HOOK dont do anything special either"
[6.0] "This match ins better than people give it credit for. Just like all Jericho matches these days. The guy isnt at his peak or anything but the online hate towards him has gotten out of hand. Anyways this was a fun hardcore style match, And step one in this story"
[3.0] "I know why people hate this match. But its the IMPOSION OF LIONHOOK. I actually cannot dislike this match. Jericho doing an "I'm sorry, I love you" moment with the bat is the funniest thing I have ever seen. This is so bad and horrible but its so good too."
[7.0] "Come on dudes Jericho isn't that bad. He can still go obviously he can't do the same stuff as 20 years ago. He's in his 50s for god's sake. I thought it was a good little match and the learning tree gimmick has been really good so far. Let's see what Hook does next."
[7.0] "well, this is probably my fate and it will not be the first time that I will be an advocate for Jericho's matches. In principle, everything is the same here, so a little slow start, but then the fighters began to show a good spectacle. The various items in the match were also put to good use. In addition, there were also fake limbs. Well, the result pleased me. Therefore, I will support old man Meltzer."
[7.0] "This is the first match I cared about. Not because I expected a great match but because I'm somewhat invested in both of these wrestlers. No matter what I might think of Jericho on a personal level, he is a legend and he was the first AEW world champion so he has some pedigree. A rivalry with Jericho at this point is still worth something. The people shouted, F Jericho; Go Home Jericho; and other things. He clearly has go away heat. And I agree that's the bad kind of heat... But it's still better than no heat at all, which is what everyone else in this company has. It made Hook look strong (even though he's not ready for television as a whole, let alone a push like this). The idea behind this rivalry was fine but the execution lackluster and very very rushed. Seems like this isn't going to be the end of the rivalry so maybe they can fix it somehow. My only real problem with the match is that Jericho isn't very good at hiding his weaknesses. He's getting older and his cardio isn't there anymore. I've seen other wrestlers hiding this very well. LA Park in MLW comes to mind as someone who's overweight and old and somehow still made it work a year or two ago. I don't know why Jericho exposes himself like this in a singles match nor why he doesn't learn from other veterans who do succeed despite their physical limitations."
[6.0] "Jericho transitioning to a more hardcore influenced, Terry Funk style as he ages is about what I'd expect, as his character arc in AEW has been one of an aging star hopelessly sliding down the card despite his best efforts and there's little left for him but tricks and weapons. Still, wish this leaned further into balls-against-the-wall ECW insanity. Give me 20 run ins, give me chair shots and absurdity. Take it all the way! I'd love for Hook to lean more into a shoot style/strong style match set at this point. If the story was to get the FTW belt away from him permanently I'm here for it. I don't think he needs to be feuding for that belt for the rest of his career."
[6.0] "So, this wasn't bad at all. I sought it out hoping for something laughable, or just sad. I imagined Jericho totally embarrassing himself and the match being full of botches. So why didn't any of that happen? Oh, because this is clearly a case of AEW fans "rebelling" against Jericho which results in low ratings out of protest, instead of low ratings because the match is actually so bad. For me, I'd probably enjoy your typical high-rated AEW main event less than this match, due to how overly abundant and nonsensical they tend to be. Now, I'm not claiming this match was great - in the end it just barely reached "good" status. They certainly packed a lot into the runtime, with Hook impressively rag-dolling Jericho with suplexes. The T-Bone off the apron & through the table was fucking awesome. I also loved how Jericho soaked in the crowd's go-away heat and played up to it. The ending is also strong with Hook kicking out of the Judas Effect twice, because Jericho took too long gloating to the crowd. This put Hook over well and the crowd seemed genuinely shocked at his kickouts. Following this, the baseball bat shot was actually done well and looked deadly. Taz did a PERFECT job on commentary too - he didn't overplay the father-son thing because as he said "Hook is a grown man and can take care of himself". However, he let his paternal instincts come through at the end when Jericho took it too far, and overall it all came off really authentic, so huge props to Taz. Overall, yeah this was a really solid match and certainly nothing to complain about. Jericho is a bit sloppy but I don't think that warrants the reaction he got. As a match, this was good. (3*)"
[2.0] "Whatever Jericho manages to do with an FTW title run aside, it doesn't really excuse from featuring a "non-sanctioned" belt in a match with someone who probably shouldn't have such a prominent role on Television to begin with. Plus the match was boring and bad outside of a couple hardcore plunder spots that were fun."
[7.0] "Chris Jericho seems to have the time of his life in matches where he can use weapons. Taz added to this match so much. I thought it made Hook look really strong. I am always a sucker for conflict within a pro wrestler. It had a lot of variety in the foreign object usage and the pace was good."
[2.0] "The lowest and only real major low on what was otherwise a very good night of wrestling. The booking was quite bad and the match was pretty forgettable as well. Chris Jericho doesn't help anyone these days regardless of whether he is trying to or not. I also don't like how they put on their ultra serious voices for a simple baseball bat shot."
[4.0] "Ehh, the wrestling itself isn't really that bad. Jericho and Hook pulled out a couple of nice moves, and the overall pacing was good; it even popped me a few times, given how much I'm a sucker for hardcore wrestling. Although, I had to rate it lower due to a stupid finish and a baffling booking decision, putting over a 50-year-old Jericho over a young, promising star. If it's going to transition into a nice storyline, I might change my rating, but for now, it's a four."
[6.0] "I've been down on Jericho for a while, long before it was "cool" to complain about how washed he is in the ring and how abysmal his segments are on dynamite, but this match was really not that bad, and actually had a few cool spots in it. The finish is kinda wack but overall this was a decent match."
[7.0] "Pretty good match, Jericho can still show cool stuff. Hook held his own, too. Nice pace, using different items, it's all great. Hopefully there will be more defences on these rules, for I was surprised the match wasn't under standard rules (slipped my mind)."
[4.0] "The match itself is a 5-6, at the very most a 7. But the confusing and downright terrible booking decision to put a washed up, 50 year old chris jericho over one of the most promising young stars in wrestling is way too horrible to rate that high at all."
[6.0] "I think this match is getting too much hate because people are down on Jericho now but the action in the match was still solid including Jericho taking a great table bump on the outside. I believe this turn in character for Jericho does have potential if handled properly and Hook can ultimately either move on to bigger things or come back and beat Jericho to get revenge"
[2.0] "This match was the equivalent of seeing Jerry Rice on the Seattle Seahawks. A legend far passed his expiration date. His aura gone and surpassed by the current generation. Hook is lost to the Jericho Vortex and we might not like what gets sent back out of it. The ending was so contrived and forced to try and make Hook look strong but it just feel flat."
[4.0] "Jericho is one of the absolute best to step inside the squared circle and do what's best for the sport, but I acknowledge the crowd and their chants from this match. He must stop everything and call it a day! There's nothing left to prove rather than tarnish his legacy even worse. Amidst the dark cloud of unproven allegations and the washed-up physique, he's still alive and kicking in the charts of AEW, and honestly, the match wasn't the worst ever. It didn't do any favors for both men even though there were a few moments that made Hook the badass he is. I hope Hook recovers from this in one way or another, and I pray that whatever is planned for Jericho becomes decently interesting and not the usual schtick of siding with someone who's shown a ray of progress. 2 out of 5 stars!"
[4.0] "The match itself isn't bad but you can see the crowd just doesn't care about Jericho anymore and yeah I can get why. The booking is bad, Hook doesn't come up over or anything, it's just useless at this point."
[6.0] "I enjoyed this. Too long but this new delusional Jericho could be fun. Its not like Hook was doing anything so this could be a good chance to show something beyond his increasingly stale character. The crowd reaction kept this entertaining throughout and Im intrigued to see where this feud goes. ***1/4"
[6.0] "I am an unapologetic Jericho fan and always will be, but I think it's time for him to call it a career. This was a decent hardcore match, but Jericho can barely do anything anymore. He's becoming Mickey Rourke's character in The Wrestler. I'm not sold on Hook, as I don't think he has the right look for how they're pushing him. But this is ranked in the 3's. I don't get that. It was still decent."
"Honestly didn't think this match was too bad, albeit I don't get to watch AEW television on the regular so I'm not as overexposed to Jericho as some may be. I thought this was pretty fun, but definitely don't think Jericho needed to win here."
[5.0] "I think this match was better than expected. We get it, the people do not want Jericho anymore, but the match he put on was pretty good, so that's what we're rating here, not the general dislike of Jericho. The FTW rules helped a lot, the plunder spots saved a match that was otherwise doomed to fail on this loaded card. I particularly liked how HOOK showed he's the more resilient man by kicking out twice out of the Judas Effect. Even though it's theoretically inside the rules, Jericho practically couldn't beat HOOK until he used his bat. So the story here is that HOOK does not need to learn from Jericho, Jericho needed the bat to bring the man down. Jericho plays the delusional babyface but in the end throws that away and goes back to heel tactics because he couldn't accept that HOOK is better than him, it's a pretty nice story they told."
[2.0] "Went on for far too long and the crowd was not into this at all. "Fozzy sucks", "Please retire" and cheering for Taz shows the guys in the ring weren't able to capture the crowds attention. AEW sometimes does a poor job of adapting to the crowd and they went with some defining moments for hook but as the crowd were not into this match at all it fell flat. Jericho's fueds and matches get a bit too much screen time and we're seeing what happens when the crowd goes against that."
[5.0] "This match was boring and went on way too long, but it wasn't bad. The AEW formula of a million false finishes on a PPV really didn't do Hook any favours, though. He's too limited to make it work. Honestly, a 10 minute match on the pre-show would have been better."
[6.0] "I get all the frustration reading the other ratings here. I understand people think Jericho should retire and that his time has passed, but evaluating it in-ring, I actually think it was a decent hardcore match. Hook will definitely have more opportunities, and probably will finish the story, as he's quite talented. I think we have to overlook the bad booking in these cases."