[7.0] "I honestly didn't have high hopes for this, but I came out enjoying this. Not by a lot though, for this kind of match, you do expect something extreme, there were moments that showcased that, taven's dive through the table was brutal, but then took two more brutal bumps, but this time not thumbtacks, both men were even bleeding pretty badly, but something felt missing here and I don't know what it was."
[8.0] "That was fantastic. Obviously, watching Orange Cassidy in a Texas Death Match is already hilarious. But the rest of what happened was also unreal. Who the hell dives onto a table head first like Matt Taven did ? ! So sick. The Chuck Taylor's fake chocolate box full of tacks was a great moment and added violence and tension in what was a simple funny match. The interventions of everyone else added chaos. The match was really original and memorable."
[8.0] "[3.75*] I am actually very surprised and happy for this great rating. I thought people were going to overhate this because of the overbooking, interferences and because it was a complete mess. However, it was so much fun, one of the matches I had most fun this year. It is nice to sit down and analyze a pure wrestling match but this kind of messed-up fun brawls are great to see. I went to sleep pretty happy."
[8.0] "For the love of the game. This match was AWESOME! Chills up and down my spine following what panned out. Matt Taven had a chance to main event Dynamite and he took it and ran with it. Both with and without weapons, he showed out in every way imaginable. Orange Cassidy, meanwhile, continues to prove why he's one of the best TV wrestlers on the planet. Every second of this match was tense and flush with brutality. And the final few minutes put the perfect bow on it. 4.25 stars, 8.5 out of 10. One of my favorite matches of the year."
[8.0] "Extremely fun match to close the show, with a lot of Valentine's Day references. This was all about the fun, of course it didn't had a masterful progression or even an impressive selling, but it was enjoyable, had crazy spots and made everyone go crazy about it at some points. I'm definitely not against this kind of matches. The spots and bumps were crazy, really good texas death match - {***3/4}"
[8.0] "I liked this match a lot! I wasn't sure what to expect with regards to a comedy wrestler and a tag guy in a TX deathmatch but they really pulled it off. Don't know why I doubted them in the first place. 8.4/10"
[8.0] "Another pretty fun match for this show, though I think the opening match just edges out this one in terms of quality. This one really picked up in the second half. I loved the table spot where Taven dove into it from the ring, and the stuff with the thumbtacks was fun, as per usual."
[5.0] "Another plunder match that really had no purpose or reason for happening. They did well though but it doesn't overcome the lack of heat or creativity in these match types either. Matt Taven didn't end up getting anything out of this, not that I'm arguing he should have, but it's just an example of diluting a stip."
"Bizarre main event, but when it's good, it's good, and I have this at 8.2. Orange's legend grows, and Taven gets some quality minutes in a big spot. The biggest thing we'll likely remember is the memorable bump Taven took through the table by the announcers, which looked painful but perfect in its execution. Having the Undisputed Kingdom lose a big match as they build their stable feels a little strange, but I don't think Taven should be the one to beat Orange if they were gonna do that. Basically file this under: AEW continuing to produce match quality, even if these overblown stips and booking decisions feel a little counterintuitive."
[7.0] "If you look at this match as a no dq match, this is a really fun match. BUT IT WAS A TEXAS DEATHMATCH. THIS IS A FEUD ENDER MATCH AND THEY USED IT FOR ORANGE CASSIDY AND A TAG GUY. Thats why it has the rating it does. If this was just a no dq match, I think I would have liked it more. But since it is a texas deathmatch. It gets knocks off it. Still fun."
[8.0] "Never been a fan of Taven but credit where credit is due, this was a damn fun match. Most of the spots were pretty cool. Really dug the thumb tacks in the Valentines Day box, and the spots on the thumb tacks as well. This type of Orange Cassidy is by far the best Orange Cassidy is."
[2.0] "Taven delivering major moves a minute into the match no build up just right into the heavy stuff. Then to the outside but there's no DQ, not that they'd count anyway. The opening stuff outside doesn't register at all because we've seen all this in two regular matches earlier tonight. They fight around until they find a table incredibly conveniently placed near the stage that never was there until this show. The table spot is weak because the table barely breaks. If Cassidy had any ability outside of selling I might not be annoyed that they put him on TV 50 weeks in a row wrestling the same match. Crazy spot where taven puts himself through the table. This should've been the lone table spot and it should've ended the match. Would've been so much better. Instead we get the lame Valentine's tie in with the thumb tacks that was predictable despite taz saying it wasn't. This was a car wreck but with no meaning and no logic. It turns into a schmoz and Cassidy wins. * One star for the table spot."
[9.0] "A hardcore match setup as part of "payback" for Chuckie T (OC's buddy) getting written off TV from a brutal Taven attack. It's great to see "serious" OC start the fight off with all fire and haymakers, catching Taven and anyone only casually familiar with his character off guard. This is a hardcore match that still finds room to let OC do comedy spots, with a long distance assistance from Chuck himself in the form of heart-shaped box of thumbtacks. Taven absolutely eats it with a dive from the ring through a table in one of the most shocking "i did this to myself" spots I've seen in a while. Both wrestlers went in with incredible violence and came out looking great for it, and did so without compromising anything about their characters. I loved this match in person and I loved looking back at tapings of it."
[7.0] "Very good match, almost my favorite of the night (I enjoyed Mox vs Dax a little more). This match helped som people to see that Taven is a great wrestler, and a singles push at some point can happen ( and I would enjoy it). (***3/4)."
[8.0] "I really enjoyed this more than I thought I would. Expectations were kinda low going in, I love Orange Cassidy but I didnt know much about Taven, and they put ON. The spot where OC pulls out the valentines heart with thumbtacks in it popped me, and it was overall a really well worked deathmatch that toed the line of this is over the top vs how is this a death match? Really well"
[8.0] "This was a really good Texas Death Match. Themed for valentines day. Both guys were cooking here. They used a couple of tables, thumbtacks(from inside of one of those V-day Chocolate containers), A big heart shaped thing that had something hard in it like cement or something, etc. I really liked the diversity of plunder they used."
[5.0] "Matt Taven got a lot of shit for being put in this match and he showed out well. I don't think anyone's ever disputed his ability, he's just not a very interesting wrestler altogether and doing hardcore matches with crazy spots doesn't really change any of that. So what was accomplished here exactly?"
[8.0] "Another wrestler on the same show that never thought would be a good singles wrestler. The table spots are replay worthy, valentines themed. Just an enjoyable match!"
[8.0] "Never took Taven all that seriously until this match. He had some crazy good spots and his offense is very intense. Definitely gonna keep my eye on him going forward. I think this was a great closer to the show, but would have liked if they had more time. But for a 13 minute Texas Death Match, this hit the spot. The dive through the table, tacks in the Valentines box, and final sequence with the Orange Punch and Beach Breakall added to the intensity of this match. And Taven looked like a star!"
[6.0] "This was a pretty awesome match until the overbooked and silly finish. Matt Taven takes a Beach Break onto a chair AND thumbtacks, but gets up three seconds later like it's no big deal. Then Taven just stands there like an idiot while Orange Cassidy wraps his fist in a chain and delivers an Orange Punch. Why didn't Taven move out of the way? Taven was standing there for six seconds waiting for Orange to attack him. This spot could have worked if Taven did the standing groggy sell, but since he wasn't, it just makes his character look dumb. Lastly, Roderick Strong comes in and could have helped his friend Taven get back up, but instead attacks Trent for some reason, thereby costing Taven the match. Overall, the wrestling here was great, but the booking was awful and made the Undisputed Kingdom look completely inept."
[9.0] "Incredible match! Way better than I would have expected from these two. Taven surprises me from time to time and this was definitely one of those times. I've been really down on OC for doing the same match every show and this was definitely not that. I can honestly say this is one of the best OC matches I've seen in a really long time (maybe ever.)"
[7.0] "Man, AEW had a pretty amazing track record with the Texas Death Match, dont they? This is going to get comparisons to Swerve/Hangman, which I guess is unavoidable, but these are very different circumstances. For a TV bloody stip match, as an aside to an ongoing feud, this was excellent. Taven wrestled this match like a man possessed with a ton to prove. God bless him. The Kingdom have mostly been presented as goofs, so a match like this goes a long way for them seeming like a meaningful and dangerous part of Coles faction. On paper, I didnt know what to expect with this. Were they going to go a silly route or present this as serious and violent? It was definitely the latter but with still a bit of lightness to it with the Valentines Day theme. This had a big splash of blood, tons of crazy bumps (that dive through the table was wild) and lots of great visual violence with the tacks. The ending with the chain-wrapped Orange Punch looked really lethal. Theyve been teasing a possible Trent turn and I hope him taking the shot for Orange squashes that because I think hes better as a babyface. Theyve focused less on it but I love the story of OC being taken to a really dark place by Moxley and losing the title so that a match like this is now something he can do with no hesitation. Gone is Orange Cassidy, the joke wrestler. The pocket ripping at the end was really symbolic of that. AEW is at its best with these random, over-delivering, violent spectacles and this is another one to add to the list. Id give this a 7.5, rounded down to a 7 for the Cagematch system."
[8.0] "I wasn't expecting much from this match as I thought it would be some sort of joke like the Texas Chainsaw Massacre death match from last year but, to my surprise, it was actually a very well done and brutal fight. Taven brought his A-game and really shined against Cassidy. The table bump he took on that dive to the outside was wild. The thumbacks spots were also super cool. I also really liked all the Valentine's day references. The closing stretch was a bit messy with a bunch of interferences but nothing that ruined the match. The Orange punch with the chain was awesome and the ending with Beretta taking the bullet for Cassidy was also nice. 8/10 - 4*/5*"
[5.0] "I was honestly pretty unwhelmed by this match, the highlight was absolutely Taven just eating shit on that dive through the table. How this is a texas death match idk because it was pretty tame by those standards and also dilutes this match type which had at least some worth in AEW."
[10.0] "I was kind of skeptical about this match coming in. I like Orange a lot but Taven, well, he's hard to predict. Occasionally I've seen him do really well, often I've seen him just be kind of there. Little did I know he was going to pull out all the stops for this match! I guess he saw an opportunity to show off in a singles main event and he took it. Orange was great as expected but Taven was working overtime, that wild dive into the table was just ludicrous. Both guys got bloody and it felt like a really tough fight, and the story that Orange is getting chewed up on his way to the PPV is being told well, even though I really hope it's not leading to Roderick taking the title."
[6.0] "This match was a bit messy and fell flat in the first half. The match picked up after Taven's dive but it still felt like a weird rush of moves and nonsense. At one point they hit three thumbtack spots in about the span of ten seconds. Cassidy was split open by an elbow drop to the sternum. Then you had Strong getting in there and hitting Trent, who wasn't really in place to block Cassidy, all the while Taven - who Strong had to run past - was being counted out on the floor. Weird stuff, but the blood, Taven's dive, and the flying chair Trent took to the face made somewhat of a spectacle of it."
[8.0] "This was the first time I've seen a Matt Taven singles match and I've got to say that I'm impressed. I Knew Orange would be great, but I though that he'd struggle to hold up his end."
[9.0] "For 13 and a half minutes this was an absolute treat. Obviously nowhere near as good as the Hangman Death matches against Swerve or Mox, but I think it was about on par with his Deathmatch against Cole. Matt Taven doesn't mess around he looked great and that Table dive was utterly insane and is up there for spot of the year so far. People have OC fatigue and I would like to see someone else hold the belt, but he's legitimately one of the best in the world right now and he continues to deliver on the International Title Farewell Tour 2. (****1/2)"
[10.0] "Matches under 15 minutes rarely get their flowers, but this one turned up the intensity so much in the second half it deserves a 10. Felt like it belongs on the top shelf of "short, sweet and brutal" aisle with classics like Masato Tanaka vs Mike Awesome at ECW ONS or Samoa Joe vs Necro Butcher."
[7.0] "Matt Taven in a main event? Thats a decision that surprisingly worked out well. For an AEW Texas Death, this wasnt one of the best but for TV wrestling in 2024, it was really fun. The color on both guys was excellent. Especially on Orange who borderline looked like he was cut the hard way."
[8.0] "This match completly caught me by suprise, Taven showed exactly what he could do in this match and made his mark with this chance against Orange Cassidy in the main event of Dynamite. Taven's facial expressions i thought were incredible and the spots in itself in this match were great."
[7.0] "[3.75*] Since his match against Moxley at All Out, Cassidy has risen a level for me in terms of doing more violent matches, here he mixes violence and humor in an incredible way, Taven worked well in this match in a way he hasn't done since his ROH days, he It was great playing on the table and then on the thumbtacks. The match, despite not being the best Texas deathmatch in history, used the stipulation well to bring an interesting variety of spots. The end of the match suffered from unnecessary interference, but it was a great victory for Cassidy in a very entertaining match."
[8.0] "Taven gets his third singles match in AEW/TKROH with a proper opponent and it delivers. Never really understood the disdain some have had for him over the years. Adaptable to a variety of match situations, right there with Cole on being the best on the mic in his current stable, smooth offense, can make an opponent look good, and can play a good foil for an underdog which OC felt like more of here than in a number of matches as of late. OC is an underrated brawler when given the platform to work with. It was a very welcomed change of pace from the usual OC match. The interference added to the chaos of the match in this instance. A nice win for OC to have in the build to OC and Strong at Revolution. 7.5-8"
[4.0] "Well, first of all, it's hilarious to see that this match is rated higher than Orange's last match, it's something extremely strange and inexplicable to me, but come on, I'm used to it. Secondly, this is just a perfect example of the fact that the main events of AEW are mired in maximalism, Matt Taven is at best the fourth in status in his stable, but Cassidy (the man who defeated Moxley, and the closest uppercarder to the top) should fight him as if Matt is a big-level superstar who stands up after important moves over and over again, and who finally loses only after an enhanced finisher. The ideal ending of a match is a loss after flying into the table, it is both spectacular, funny, and unusual, but this is minimalism, and AEW don't know how to do this and don't finish the match until the gasoline in the tank runs out. The price for this is as follows: the rating on this site is higher, because the match lasted longer, and Strong also didn't look very smart (**)."
[9.0] "Was really tempted to go 10. It was a lazy use of the Texas Deathmatch stip. Should've just called it a Valentine's Day Street Fight or something. But man, it was dope. Super freaking fun. The leap from Taven was brilliant. Some other spots with the tacks afterwards were also great with some good claret on both men. This match popped me a good few times and was just sheer, unadulterated FUN."
[9.0] "Quality ME. Taven came out big you Melvin's! He showed that he can go 1x1 with anyone. OC of course really sold a lot and showed out. Both took some harsh bumps and made this a a very good to great TX DM match. AEW pulls of TX DM matches really well. I know this style may not fit some but if you do like this one holds up well."
[8.0] "Main Event-worthy stuff from both wrestlers, and an especially inspired performance by Matt Taven. He fully committed to several high spots that allowed this match to accelerate into a high/hardcore gear in its latter half. The sub-plots involving gimmicks and props also straddled the line effectively between comedy and danger. This match even elevated the Best Friends vs Undisputed Kingdom feud somewhat (and that's impressive as it was somewhat lukewarm to date). So kudos to both guys, but especially Taven who really over-delivered."
[7.0] "A tier or two below every single Texas Death we've seen in AEW so far, and i'm genuinely not a fan how they just threw a random Texas Death match at us, but the last half of this match was genuinely loads of fun and I think I saw that Matt Taven dive at least 5 times and gasped at every single one of them. Clunky ending but lots of fun on this one, looking forward to see Roderick Strong win at Revolution though, it's time. 3.5*"
[7.0] "This was pretty flawed and there was a lot here that wasn't really to my taste, but the table spot was fantastic, the blood looked great, and the thumb tack bumps looked like they really sucked to take. While I could pick the booking apart, don't really care for the comedy, and think that AEW has really reached the point of diminishing returns with these hardcore matches, they put their bodies through a lot here, and considering that and some of the more entertaining aspects of the match I feel it would be overly harsh to go with a lower rating - even if there was a fair bit here that could have definitely been better."
[8.0] "Orange is such a strange wrestler to me, I never look forward to his matches but always enjoy them even if he very rarely goes above the four star hump. Taven has been under rated for years and I enjoy his heel schtick. This lads put the effort in and Taven sure did take some very nasty bumps for my entertainment. Still not quite sure what made both of them bleed."
[8.0] "I wasn't keen on this going into it because I knew it would be nowhere near the level of the other Texas DMs (even the TV ones) but I was pleasantly surprised. Lots of fun"
[8.0] "Well, that was unexpected. I was prepared to see only the silly stuff given Cassidy was participating in this match, but I was wrong. A very good TV Texas Death. I appreciate the effort from both men, especially those tables and thumbtacks spots"
[8.0] "This match came out of nowhere and certainly surpassed my expectations. The booking of this as a Texas Death between Orange and one of the lower ranked dudes in the opposing stable painted the match in a bit of an odd corner going in. But Taven in particular busted his ass far beyond what I would expect for a tv match and really pushed this into a match I went from being cold towards to quickly invested in. Those table bumps from Taven were gnarly. I thought the boxes of candy were a clever touch, and the ending was a solid use of interference even if Orange ultimately still wins the match."