[7.0] "I wasn't a expecting this match to be so good here for a pre-show, but very solid. I love seeing Claudio shine like this wild that he's on a preshow putting on this type of match up, but he's so solid."
[6.0] "[3.0*] This match was pretty good but suffered for lack of in-ring time. Buddy vs Yuta on Collision was slightly better for this exact reason: It had more time to develop. The strikes were great and we had good sequences, but the lack of heat took a little bit from the bout, which was the best one of the pre-show."
[6.0] "A fun pre show match between two great wrestlers to kick off the BCC vs HoB feud. Claudio has excelled and found his place in AEW where it shows that Matthews is still struggling to find his groove which shows in this match from reaction and effort put in. Personally, I really liked the ending to this match but it did make it seems that HoB and Matthews was weak. Fun free match to watch, would recommend."
[7.0] "Excellent match for Zero Hour. If it was on the main card, I don't think anyone would complain. Both wrestlers are really good and I hope we have more matches between these two."
[7.0] "Is it surprising that the caliber these two possess could result in a bad match? No way! I adored the barrage of offense they clocked in on each other in such a short time period. If the previous bout didn't set the mood, this definitely did! I'm curious to see the advancement of the brewing enmity b/w BCC & HOB as they're almost equal in numbers to bring a blazing trios fight. 3.5 out of 5 stars!"
[7.0] "The best match of the Zero-Hour, in my opinion. With the amount of talent these two possess, I have to say that I was hoping for a bit more. However, I still enjoyed this for what it was and Im especially glad that Matthews got a match like this. Ive been a big fan of his since his 205 Live days and I really want him to succeed."
[7.0] "My favorite match of the Zero Hour, Buddy and Claudio showed a good chemistry, nice strikes and counters. Wonder what's next for them. (***1/2)."
[7.0] "7.5 - Screw this crowd. I know it's preshow but these two are great, and showed at least a little of the magic they can produce. Instead we got cringe Mami and Sportsmanship chants. Buddy's movements are tremendous, and Claudio was able to show a few of his best power moves."
[4.0] "Love Claudio but this was a pointless uninteresting match. They tried to make it interesting with some counters and what not but it still was not interesting and was indeed forgotten by everyone by the end of the night. Babyface was an obvious favorite and nothing was done to get him in any sort of trouble."
[7.0] "Well, if you notice four or five errors and botches, a little striking, but nothing to reproach these two gladiators, almost similar styles, speed and rudeness, lethality in each attack, realism and extreme fatigue, it is not the best match of the two of them separately, but it is more than acceptable."
[7.0] "It was really great. The wrestlers didnt put it off for long, so they started right away. I absolutely love how Claudio is positioned. It's just a Terminator and a killing machine that is impossible to approach, but Buddy was constantly trying to find holes in its armor. Either he uses cunning as at the beginning of the fight, or he tries to stay on his level. But still, Claudio is Claudio, so all these counterattacks were not crowned with success. A very good power match, which even impressed me a little with its intensity"
[7.0] "It's a shame that the two athletes as talented as these two ended up in the Zero Hour but at least they gave us a good match. There weren't any crazy spots but they hit some of their best manuevers and it was enough to make this enjoyable. There were also a couple of good sequences and counters. The sharpshooter at the end looked great. 7/10 - 3.5*/5*"
[6.0] "Surely better than the first match and actually a good back and forth offence. Perhaps nothing too deep at the end of the day but it worked, just a clear example of wrestling with a Sharpshooter that looked really good. Anyway it's s a pity that Claudio is in the Zero Hour. **3/4"
[7.0] "Better than the previous match. Claudio is amazing with his power moves and his Uppercuts and Buddy did some really solid kicks and knees and he sold everything Castagnoli did really really well, making some Uppercuts look really devastating. The sequences were pretty smooth and the time they had was used to its full I think. The post match was interesting too, after all though this one was a pre-show match so what more did you expect? They did more than what I was thinking at first. A solid *** for me."
[7.0] "A solid match in wich two great workers showed a bit of what the can give in the time that they where given during this pre show. Claudio like always is going to shine and make his opponents like great wich Buddy doesn't much help cause he shines by himself cause he is a great talent who in my opinion need more of this single matches cause he has been the worst booked guy on the House of Black and has even been overshadowed by the great success of Julia! Hopefully this is the beginning of a start for a solo run!"
[6.0] "It had the energy of a 2019 midcard PPV match, which is not necessarily an insult but not exactly a compliment either. Matthews has improved his striking but is less explosive and captivating than he was in WWE, when his pace was so dictating. Claudio is an immense talent and it was lovely seeing him win with the Sharpshooter, which feels like a rare sight in AEW, but it didn't seem like he fully clicked with Matthews on this night. Maybe the lack of build hindered their ability to get a great match."
[6.0] "This was disappointing honestly. This has almost no build sure, but I expected these two to have a better exhibition than this. They just went out there and had the most basic match these two could've had. Nothing bad, not by a long shot, but nothing really stuck out outside of the Swing counter. The strikes were good, the strength spots were good, the crowd wasn't silent, but it's like nothing ever moved out of first gear here. Post-match teased Buddy being offered a BCC spot, but I'm glad he turned it down for heat. ***"
[6.0] "Solid match that did not have a lot of energy to it seeing as this match was just thrown together roughly 24 hours ago. Both are talented and can deliver. Similar to Kingston/Lethal, they did not get a lot of time. There was some good work involved but it felt like this would have been a match more suitable for a television show rather than a Zero Hour. They did work hard but it was not much in the way of a show stealing match which is at least fine for a pre show. Claudio winning with the Sharpshooter was a choice but he does do a good one."
[6.0] "A hot start with many stiff strikes- these two are here to beat each other up. Some headlock work paces out the middle section of the match. Some great headbutts in the corner from Claudio, but thats followed up by leg slap super kicks and some not so great looking elbows from Matthews. Hardway juice for Claudio sells the idea that theyve been hitting each other hard despite these two weak looking spots. Claudio gets the sharpshooter and its all over in the middle of the ring. Kind of an anticlimactic end to what started as a hard hitting contest. I was hoping for something more like Matthews matches with Andrade. Good pre-show fodder to get you excited for the rest of the show."